Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash
by eslaught on Thursday August 04, 2022 @11:20PM
(#32351148)
The thing is, policies like this make it really hard to manage open source projects, which (a) typically do not make a lot of money, and (b) in the very long tail, are sometimes "dormant" according to this metric. And the cost goes up the more projects you have and the more services they're spread over.
If they really wanted to save only on costs, surely they could have gone for the biggest repos first? E.g., politely email owners of large-but-inactive repos to consider spinning them down, and then if that fails to move the needle, then put in a policy (starting with big repos first).
There's no reason for someone's 1k LOC project to get swept up in something like this. The costs for that must be trivial.
Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash
by bredren on Thursday August 04, 2022 @11:56PM
(#32351408)
There was a time when sentiment was very against GitHub. Iirc, it was when prices went up before Microsoft acquired the company.
GitLab dined on that, and really any time negative press has come from GitHub.
I don’t think people would have been pushed the move it to GitLab narrative If they had foreseen this.
This is a really great insight that I hadn't thought of. Sure, if they, from the start, had promised to do so, that would be one thing. But users of free plans are essentially freeloading (sure, there are useful network effects of having free users on the platform), and it's a bit entitled to expect that free services are free in perpetuity (especially from a company that isn't profitable), even for projects that might be abandoned.