News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by olliej on Thursday August 04, 2022 @10:13PM (#32350710)
I was kind of surprised that the hosting of such stuff was a significant enough cost that removing it was seen as worth it - but I have no idea what their annual revenue is, and a million dollars is a million dollars.

That said, they were talking about deleting dead projects from unpaid accounts, and it does seem kind of shitty that as a community we seem to have decided that once a company has hosted some content that they should be required to host it forever at their own expense.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by kelnos on Thursday August 04, 2022 @11:04PM (#32351065)
> it does seem kind of shitty that as a community we seem to have decided that once a company has hosted some content that they should be required to host it forever at their own expense.

This is a really great insight that I hadn't thought of. Sure, if they, from the start, had promised to do so, that would be one thing. But users of free plans are essentially freeloading (sure, there are useful network effects of having free users on the platform), and it's a bit entitled to expect that free services are free in perpetuity (especially from a company that isn't profitable), even for projects that might be abandoned.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by eslaught on Thursday August 04, 2022 @11:20PM (#32351148)
The thing is, policies like this make it really hard to manage open source projects, which (a) typically do not make a lot of money, and (b) in the very long tail, are sometimes "dormant" according to this metric. And the cost goes up the more projects you have and the more services they're spread over.

If they really wanted to save only on costs, surely they could have gone for the biggest repos first? E.g., politely email owners of large-but-inactive repos to consider spinning them down, and then if that fails to move the needle, then put in a policy (starting with big repos first).

There's no reason for someone's 1k LOC project to get swept up in something like this. The costs for that must be trivial.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by bredren on Thursday August 04, 2022 @11:56PM (#32351408)
There was a time when sentiment was very against GitHub. Iirc, it was when prices went up before Microsoft acquired the company.

GitLab dined on that, and really any time negative press has come from GitHub.

I don’t think people would have been pushed the move it to GitLab narrative If they had foreseen this.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by UpstandingUser on Thursday August 04, 2022 @11:14PM (#32351121)
> as a community we seem to have decided that once a company has hosted some content that they should be required to host it forever at their own expense.

We need something like public (book) libraries for code. Or a Library of Congress. FOSS has become critical infrastructure and we need to act like it. Done well, this could also help foster people learning to code. Sure there will be some political issues with it around funding and what code we should or shouldn't host, but the benefits would outweigh the drawbacks I think. I've seen tax money go to worse things, at least.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by rapnie on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:41AM (#32351758)
We might just start having a more open landscape where code can roam freely to wherever you want to host it. In other words more than just two full-service providers to choose from who lock you in by network effects and FOMO, made worse because the entire software development tools vendor ecosystem is based on them too.

When it comes to open source and free software projects both of these platforms are not your friends. The "free" services are just an enabler for their revenue models, part of the business plan. Especially Microsoft is well-known for their long game and EEE strategies. If it is up to them we'll move to GOSS, Github Open Source Software, that is so dependent on nice GH services that it can never move away.

I have my hopes in more open technologies, be they low-level like DVCS, or taking care of social aspects of software development, like ActivityPub. On this last bit cool developments are taking place. Extensions to ActivityPub that will allow code forge features to federate with any vendor that supports them. We'll get decentralized software development if that is done well.

Some FOSS projects and communities are taking first strides here. A report of their activities is in this blog post of the Forgefriends project:

https://forgefriends.org/blog/2022/06/30/2022-06-state-forge...

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by progval on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:35AM (#32354137)
Software Heritage does this. We archive as much publicly available code as we can, and make it available at https://archive.softwareheritage.org/

Notably, it includes Gitlab.com and discontinued forges like Google Code and Bitbucket's mercurial repositories.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by nonethewiser on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:53AM (#32351853)
> FOSS has become critical infrastructure and we need to act like it.

Some FOSS has become critical infrastructure. But how much of that has been inactive for a year on gitlab free tier?

I dont see how this threatens critical open source projects.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by Gigachad on Friday August 05, 2022 @01:58AM (#32352294)
Gitlab projects are way bigger than you’d expect. The actual git repo is usually not the biggest part. It’s the build artefacts and docker images. The average project I have worked with on Gitlab has been in the tens of gigabytes while active repos like the gitlab itself repo are in the terabytes.
Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by UncleEntity on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:01AM (#32351441)
At who’s definition of dead?

I have one project which I use all the time which is basically finished, once in a great while I have to fix some minor thing when python changes their C-API or I get bored and add some minor feature because I wanted to figure out how to do something in python. From the outside the project is “dead” as I barely ever touch it, just recompile when I do an OS upgrade and forget about it until the next python version bump.

I honestly don’t think anyone else has used it, its a python wrapper around boost:: property_tree which I use to transform rss xml to json, but it does contains a lot of magic to do things using the python C-API which are pretty hard to figure out because there’s no documentation so I think the real value is having examples to look at. I spent many wasted hours figuring out how these things worked by reading other peoples code and adding them in the easiest way possible. Might someday save someone a bit of time…maybe.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by olliej on Friday August 05, 2022 @01:07AM (#32351955)
It doesn’t matter whose definition of dead, the point is that we’re demanding that someone pay to host content in perpetuity for free.
Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by olliej on Thursday August 04, 2022 @10:28PM (#32350814)
Quick googling says 300 million in annual revenue, but a -155M net income or -61M profit margin (how are they different?)

So that’s somewhere between 0.6% and 1.5% of their annual loss according to the claim it would save 1M a year

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by abofh on Friday August 05, 2022 @02:04AM (#32352333)
It's not costing them 155M to run hosting. It's maybe a tenth of that. Online business costs are inordinately around people, marketing, and sales acquisitions. Someone wants you to look at X to save money, because Y is more important to them. I don't know gitlab's financing, but it's a pretty common play when someone is looking to boost their figures so someone else won't notice - either for executive payments or acquisition, someone's looking to goose their margins.
Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by snoopy_telex on Thursday August 04, 2022 @11:19PM (#32351138)
https://www.theregister.com/2022/08/04/gitlab_data_retention... says "Hopes to save a quarter of hosting costs by binning repos that haven't been touched for a year", so perhaps it's from looking at cost centers more then just the company wide costs.
Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by ArrayBoundCheck on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:12AM (#32351535)
I'm still wondering why there isn't a bittorrent for git
Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by pabs3 on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:53AM (#32351856)
There was GitTorrent in 2015:

https://blog.printf.net/articles/2015/05/29/announcing-gitto... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31534936

There are also multiple git-remote-ipfs projects on GitHub.

Re:Gitlab U-turns on deleting dormant projects after backlash by mdaniel on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:49PM (#32358683)
In some sense, this has the same problem as TFA: who is going to seed those disused repos (same problem with ipfs linked in the sibling comment, which one can pay a "pinning node" but pay)