News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by nitwit005 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:47PM (#32346783)
> For example, a professional tennis player can follow the trajectory of a tennis ball after it is served at a speed as high as 160 miles per hour, move to the optimal spot on the court, position his or her arm, and swing the racket to return the ball in the opponent’s court, all within a few hundred milliseconds.

I suspect if you made a perfectly invisible ball, you'd find people would manage to hit it back quite often. There's a lot of signal from the opponent's body motion.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by mseepgood on Thursday August 04, 2022 @04:41PM (#32348059)
> For example, a professional tennis player can follow the trajectory of a tennis ball after it is served at a speed as high as 160 miles per hour, move to the optimal spot on the court, position his or her arm, and swing the racket to return the ball in the opponent’s court, all within a few hundred milliseconds.

This doesn't seem to be specific to the human brain. My cat is probably quicker.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by mlyle on Thursday August 04, 2022 @04:54PM (#32348184)
Sure. The point is, biological brains are quite good at this compared to machines, despite it being a composition of trivial mechanics and kinematics problems, and a vision problem that is similar to ones that computers are pretty good at. We seem to do better at it and in a fraction of the power budget of computing.
Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by cgrealy on Thursday August 04, 2022 @09:52PM (#32350558)
Let's say you're building a robot tennis player. Ignoring the physical engineering for a second, let's assume it can move around and swing a racket with roughly the same speed as a human.

It doesn't have anything other than a camera to track the ball.

So in terms of it's control, we have two options: 1: track the ball in 3d, work out the velocity, trajectory, ballistics, etc and then calculate the optimal position and swing to return. 2: use some form of ML that recognises patterns and applies patterned responses.

I'm willing to bet that 2 will significantly outperform 1, for a fraction of the compute power (once the training data is done).

Because that's what humans do. No one is working out equations in real time.

Human brains aren't bad at this, but I'd bet large sums of money that machines will out perform us at this within a decade.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by mlyle on Friday August 05, 2022 @01:05AM (#32351942)
> Human brains aren't bad at this, but I'd bet large sums of money that machines will out perform us at this within a decade.

I'm not so sure. Many other spaces where computers outperform us come nowhere close to doing it in the same power budget, and the amount of power it takes isn't reducing quickly.

> Because that's what humans do. No one is working out equations in real time.

I believe we do something in-between-- like have a kinematics and tracking engine that is fuzzy and gets tuned/updated/supplemental training for particular problems we face a lot, but isn't very tennis-motion specific.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by kaba0 on Saturday August 06, 2022 @10:06AM (#32368192)
I’m not sure human brains don’t do equations in real time. Sure, not in the form a computer would do it, nor in a way we could use up intermediate calculations, but humans have great spacial/visual skills which are not solely akin to ML algorithms. I’m a layperson, but what I mean here is rotating a 3D object in your head is not the same mechanism as your general flow of thought. It can perhaps be thought of as “graphic acceleration”.
Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by mlyle on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:42PM (#32370059)
I think both brains and ML in practice "solve equations". The main thrust of machine learning is using linear algebra as a universal function fitter. Sure, the state space may be transformed in interesting ways and the overall process may be relatively opaque, but you could easily end up with the quadratic formula in there.

The equations may be very strange from the point of view of the underlying physics/kinematics problem. There's a lot of representations of the problem that fit well and may map better to what our perceptions see and the level of precision that our muscles need.

And it's likely very messy--- we don't have some clean, nested set of controllers here, but strange ways that many kinds of feedback are combined.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by rowanG077 on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:58AM (#32354859)
I honestly doubt ML will outperform a classical approach. A tennisbal is relatively easily recognized using basic filters. The kinematic equations to solve are cheap.
Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by revolvingocelot on Thursday August 04, 2022 @05:46PM (#32348701)
I think that's the answer to the question TFA poses: because your cat's enormous ancestors also had efficient, fast brains. In order to not get got, we needed to be similarly equipped, reaction-wise, and optimized for fuzzy analysis of high-speed, blurry objects.

This, of course, shunts the question one level of abstraction away, but the standard evolutionary arms-race handwaving suffices here. So long as one side does it, by random chance or a side effect of sexual selection or whatever, the other side eventually does, too.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by austinjp on Thursday August 04, 2022 @10:04PM (#32350654)
Agreed!

What follows is in addition, not in contradiction.

The complexity of human musculoskeletal coordination is astonishing. Particularly in sport, but also in daily life. Consider: how many ways are there to raise a cup to your mouth? Basically: infinite. And yet you do it without a care, almost reflexively, barely paying attention. In sub-second sporting tasks, the role of the conscious brain is likely to be zero, but the role of anything above the brain stem is also often unclear.

The spine - home to reflex action - doesn't have the processing power to determine how to return a tennis serve, yet this sort of action is far quicker than any deliberate, calculated, conscious action.

When I last spent any time reading around the subject, the literature was full of stuff like how the central nervous system updates its expectations based on feedback when trying to achieve a goal; and hints about how musculoskeletal movement might involve "orchestration" of composable units of coordination.

It's a fascinating area of research.

Overlaps with robotics and ML are obvious, although I suspect those approaches are "inventing" rather than "discovering". Nothing inherently wrong with that, of course.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by Teever on Friday August 05, 2022 @02:05AM (#32352343)
I don't think that returning a tennis serve is a literal reflex as you're claiming.

From my understanding a reflexive move requires some sort of stimulus, and there's no way that your spine can have stimulus of an incoming tennis ball unless the eyes and therefore the brain are involved.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by austinjp on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:05AM (#32354400)
My post isn't clear, in that case. I'm not claiming it's a literal reflex :)

A top-flight tennis player is responding extremely quickly, and extremely accurately. Deliberate, planned action is not happening. It's something else. It's not a spinal reflex, it's something that involves parts of the brain to very rapidly 'orchestrate' a highly complex musculoskeletal dance.

The raw processing necessary to coordinate that dance cannot (in my understanding) be achieved by familiar neurological pathways -- observing, planning, deciding, coordinating. The planning and deciding aspects are bypassed. Only a tiny fraction of the observing aspect is used, such as the moment the other player strikes the ball (because the ball then moves too fast to react to). Some form of prediction happens. Then a number of 'movement primitives' seem to be selected and orchestrated. Ideally, the whole system is tweaked in real-time based on feedback (visual, proprioceptive) regarding whether the goal was achieved -- i.e. did you return the serve well.

It's wild.

It's also possible I'm mis-remembering and mis-interpreting some of this stuff :)

Good place to start reading: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=%22motor+primitives%22...

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by nh23423fefe on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:05PM (#32346992)
I disagree, and think it would nearly never be hit. Servers use false movement to disguise the serve.
Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by nitwit005 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:12PM (#32347061)
They do, but within limits. You can't make any random movement and hit the ball somewhere useful.

The existence of feints is why I knew people were using the body motions as a strong signal in the first place.

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by okwubodu on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:37PM (#32347315)
This is most obvious in soccer and basketball where you’ll see two similarly skilled players almost get stuck in place trying to predict the other’s next move.
Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by mulvya on Thursday August 04, 2022 @04:00PM (#32347582)
Well, Ronaldo could hit a soccer ball after lights are cut.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aoScYO2osb0

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by nh23423fefe on Thursday August 04, 2022 @05:10PM (#32348319)
close but not really. the lights were on at the kick. he couldn't make contact with an invisible ball
Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by jerojero on Thursday August 04, 2022 @07:19PM (#32349533)
There was an experiment done on training for basketball players where a group was told to train for a couple of weeks 3 point shoots.

One group trained normally, as in, they would position themselves and throw the ball.

Another group trained the same way, except they had no ball. So they had to position themselves and throw an imaginary ball.

A final group was obviously told not to train at all.

The results of this study showed similar progression between the ball group and no ball group and no progression for the no training group. And the study continued on showing that the exercise of repeating the pattern even without the ball strengthened the neural pathways that are usually activated when doing the action. From brain to arm and that a big part of "learning" is not actually adjusting but reinforcing.

So I imagine the players in tennis would definitely be able to hit the ball if they trained without it. At least to a certain point (adjusting is important as well obviously).

Re:Why Is the Human Brain So Efficient? by alephxyz on Thursday August 04, 2022 @07:37PM (#32349674)
That doesn't make it any less impressive