News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sending spammers to password purgatory by ImPostingOnHN on Thursday August 04, 2022 @01:25AM (#32339646)
it is unfortunate that some people believe those pros outweigh the punishment inflicted on innocent users

it is better a thousand criminals/ spammers go free than a single innocent non-spammer be treated as if they are one

essentially the companies are shifting their own pain (with spammers) onto innocent users ("it's your problem now, suck it users, lol!!!")

Re:Sending spammers to password purgatory by raverbashing on Thursday August 04, 2022 @04:48AM (#32340665)
> better a thousand criminals/ spammers go free than a single innocent non-spammer be treated as if they are one

Sounds like you never had to actually deal with such a spammer problem yourself

Re:Sending spammers to password purgatory by ImPostingOnHN on Thursday August 04, 2022 @10:09AM (#32343120)
"its easier to just punish everybody than single out the person actually deserving of punishment" is actually a common defense of collective punishment

the equal and opposite response would be, "Sounds like you never had to actually deal with such a usability problem yourself", but I'm not interested in trying to devolve this discussion into one about you and me, instead of the topic

[dead]
Re:Sending spammers to password purgatory by raverbashing on Thursday August 04, 2022 @08:52AM (#32342173)
Yes banning users from a website is exactly like sending them to the gulag, it's exactly that
Re:Sending spammers to password purgatory by dingleberry420 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @08:57AM (#32342237)
So you don't believe in guilty until proven innocent? Or do you? How do you justify banning innocent users?
Re:Sending spammers to password purgatory by fjfbsufhdvfy on Thursday August 04, 2022 @09:43AM (#32342791)
It really depends on the scale of the punishment doesn't it?

Got sent to the gulag - well now you have a major problem. Can't post meme on reddit - oh no!

Websites generally aren't obligated to accept all users, precisely because we as a society decided that it's not really a big deal if you can't.

Re:Sending spammers to password purgatory by dingleberry420 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @12:13PM (#32344810)
Can't post a meme on facebook - oh no!

Can't access facebook marketplace - legitimately annoying!

Can't access your mail archive going back a decade - could be a huge problem for some people

Sure, it's not as bad as getting sent to the gulag. But the problem with most of these tech companies is far bigger than not being able to post a meme.

Re:Sending spammers to password purgatory by thegrimmest on Thursday August 04, 2022 @09:58AM (#32342977)
I do believe you're misapplying Blackstone's Formulation. I think it's perfectly fine to presume guilt in some cases when operating a public service. This can be reformulated as making users go through extra steps designed to screen bad actors. We in fact do this at places like airports (and increasingly schools) all the time.

For instance if your user happens to be an unwitting botnet member (or even if he has a newly assigned IP previously belonging to one) - his IP will be suspicious and you can "punish" him accordingly. Also Blackstone's ratio was 1/10, not 1/1000.