Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by tptacek on Sunday November 13, 2011 @10:29PM
(#3232692)
OmniGraffle isn't remotely as good at what Balsamiq does as Balsamiq itself. You might just as productively compare Adobe InDesign to Emacs.
Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by alanh on Sunday November 13, 2011 @10:31PM
(#3232695)
I disagree. You can make and download and share stencils. There are great sets for different UI systems...
What am I missing?
Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by tptacek on Sunday November 13, 2011 @10:35PM
(#3232711)
This is the kind of comment you write when you've never actually used Balsamiq. I use and adore OmniGraffle (though I'm back to doing more technical illustration in Illustrator), and it is nothing like Balsamiq. It's not a difference of stencils or downloading or anything like that; they are simply very different applications altogether.
Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by alanh on Sunday November 13, 2011 @10:36PM
(#3232719)
You don't know that.
I have used both. Though I only used the Flash version of Balsamiq, since my AIR installation refused to work.
Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by tptacek on Sunday November 13, 2011 @10:49PM
(#3232756)
I'm inclined not to believe you, if you need someone to argue with you that OmniGraffle has a similar approach to UI mockups.
Perhaps you downloaded it, dragged some things onto a canvas, and then never picked it up again. You missed a lot of great stuff. It's a thoughtfully designed (and very nerdy) app.
Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by myoder on Sunday November 13, 2011 @10:02PM
(#3232622)
If you're anti-AIR, check out their MyBalsamiq :)
Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by alanh on Sunday November 13, 2011 @10:08PM
(#3232636)
Thanks.
The page is not forthcoming in terms of tech. It's "hosted." What do I interact with? Flash? Native?
Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by melvinram on Monday November 14, 2011 @12:49AM
(#3233039)
It's Flash for the mockup part and plain html for the rest of the app.
Re:An Open Letter to Peldi Guilizzoni of Balsamiq
by jdale27 on Sunday November 13, 2011 @10:10PM
(#3232641)
It's Flash.
But damn, I hate to see anything popularize AIR apps. Also consider OmniGraffle if you are looking for prototyping :)
Really don’t want to rain on parades. Just want to make sure people know there are (IMO better) alternatives.