So I went to buy a car urgently...
It was my first time buying a car by myself, the one that was totalled was a "hand me down" I purchased from a relative.
Dealerships were a nightmare. New cars sucked and were ludicrously expensive. I found out some older cars were good for reasonable prices, and went looked for one.
One dealership had a google review about how they allowed a car for servicing get stolen and didn't notice until police shown up to return the car. That same dealership tried to sell me a car that was obviously repainted in a shoddy manner and had literally misaligned parts while claiming the car never was crashed. And later a private seller complained to me unprompted that the same dealership despite being the official leadership or his vehicle, put the wrong oil in it.
Another dealership had very pushy people that didn't listen and kept attempting to sell me weak cars (0.8 liter 3 cylinder) when I kept explaining my house was on a giant hill and I had more powerful cars stall on it before.
Another one said some parts for the potential car were imported and expensive and I wouldn't want them when I asked the price... instead of just telling me the price. (I ended wanting the parts anyway, from another store obviously)
What that tipping/inflection point is, I haven’t done the math. Smaller dealerships or those at the margins of course will be the first to close or sell out to mega corp dealer chains.
Carmax is pretty decent for new car sales where they’re able to offer that, in my experience, and their used car buying experience is very good as well (have bought a handful of used cars from Carmax). Cannot speak to Carvana, haven’t used them.
Carmax is a good service but it does not sell new cars, only used cars.
While Texas’ protectionism of its dealers is definitely a bummer, it’s trivial to work around.
Honestly I think this is sadly untrue. The corruption is there, just hidden very very well and legalized in the form of political lobbying and wall st. hedge funds.
Dealerships are a direct result of our Federal Government stepping in to protect consumers.
Vehicle manufacturers, before dealerships, would setup a lot to sell vehicles and then disappear several months later leaving citizens on the hook to attempt to resolve damages, repairs, or warranty issues.
The US Federal Government had enough complaints from citizens across the country to propose dealerships as a resolution. These car lots would become responsible for repair and warranty issues directly acting in the place of manufacturers.
In order to remove dealerships, one must first propose a valid remedy for these issues that dealerships are currently liable for.
Ford in my experience is especially bad about making poorly engineered low-mid tier vehicles that require consumer recalls, lawsuits, etc.
They would benefit greatly from a reduced dealership presence without a corresponding decrease in sales volume.
I'd prefer to go to a showroom, test drive, not be hassled because there's no commission on the line. Then go do that at several other manufacture's showrooms, then go home and make my final selection in peace with a web browser and my spouse.
If this system becomes efficient there's no reason why the manufacturer cannot have an interstate warehouse Amazon style with some "next day delivery" vehicles. So you can either pick your bespoke configuration and wait [period] or get something in inventory for almost immediate delivery, but in both cases you're ordering via your browser/phone.
Now instead of shopping each state dealership's inventory one by one, you're shopping all collective dealership's inventory together and getting an incredible buying experience.
I do not expect to get any of that with a new car, or even one made in the last couple of decades. That is why I will continue to maintain vehicles that were made before the turn of the century.
Carvana "guaranteed" offers are not guaranteed. Dealers don't respect them. It's essentially clickbait that dealers put out to get leads.
Carvana is a search engine and nothing more. The offer numbers are entirely fictional. I was unable to get dealers to honor them even under threat of legal action for false advertising.
The only companies trying to work around dealers are Carmax and Tesla.
My experience with them was incredible - I picked out the car and paid for it online and they brought it on a truck at exactly the agreed time. The whole purchase took 20 minutes of my time, including delivery. When they delivery person started to explain the car's features, I said I was familiar with the model as I had rented it before and researched it. He said great, he'll leave me to it. The price charged was exact, to the cent. The car's condition was exactly as shown online.
Hopefully those types of start-ups will be successful and will become more popular. It was exactly what I wish all car buying was like.
My past experiences buying cars in the US from dealerships was always a nightmare. Even if you walk in with cash to buy a specific car, it was always somehow a 4+ hour process with all the hoops they make you jump through and all the add-ons they try to tack on.
That would be a complete game changer. I would pay a premium for that.
For most households buying a vehicle is their second largest purchase. It is meant to be enjoyable/fun. But dealerships have managed to make it very unfun/stressful/bad.
And there's always "but what if you find the unicorn dealership?!" but frankly those are few and far between. If you talk to random people in the street 9/10 will have a negative dealership story.
Dealerships do nothing to control price increases, and suggesting they do misunderstands the market forces. What controls prices is competition (i.e. other vehicles, from other manufacturers). All dealerships do is rent-seek in the middle.
I'd like to know that if my next door neighbor and I buy the same vehicle, that we paid the same price, and had the same experience. Just open up "show rooms" that don't sell vehicles, then a website where you can order for home delivery for a fixed price.
The whole "local jobs" argument would have more merit if dealerships weren't a toxic influence on local politics, and nobody is suggesting that manufacturers won't need to continue to offer local repair facilities for recalls and of course to staff these showrooms.