News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Introduction to Apple Silicon by smoldesu on Monday August 01, 2022 @07:45PM (#32313585)
> Switching it round though, 99.99% of customers are buying a toaster. I put bread in. It makes toast. I eat toast. Does it make commercial sense to support the 0.01% use case?

Fair enough. I think most toaster manufacturers will at least test what happens when you put a bagel inside, though. If said bagel causes an electrical fire or doesn't toast as well as the previous model did, it doesn't matter if ~1% of users will encounter it; it probably needs to get fixed before it ships.

I think this fully extends to Apple Silicon as well. Apple's "contributions" to Asahi mostly amount to adding a feature that pre-existed on x86 machines, and probably intended for Bootcamp/Windows rather than Linux. Hell, there's compelling evidence that Apple simply uses that functionality to flash testing firmware onto Macbooks, and the Linux compatibility is just a nice side-effect. Much like you said though, with Apple you never know. Until they release an official statement on the matter, it can only be assumed it's a coincidence.

Re:Introduction to Apple Silicon by GeekyBear on Monday August 01, 2022 @11:19PM (#32314769)
> Apple's "contributions" to Asahi mostly amount to adding a feature that pre-existed on x86 machines

Nope.

Apple tossed out the UEFI used by Intel Macs and replaced it with a system that allows you to control the security settings per partition, so you can have a single machine with full security enabled on your Mac partition while allowing for the installation of an unsigned OS on the same disk.

It's a complete replacement of the boot system that preexisted on x86 machines.