Basically, as a former Intel employee, Intel is ripe for being disrupted. (The employees only want to follow the rules and believe the rules will last forever.) Why it hasn't been disrupted yet, is a bit harder to explain.
Disruption is overrated. It's a lot harder to do than it is to think about or wish for. Neither Nvidia or AMD have "disrupted" Intel. Only Apple came close to that and even then only in theory, and only in their own walled garden market. If they were selling M-chips to everyone, you MIGHT have disruption, but that's easier said than done because there's an enormous list of tasks that need executed to a T that has to be completed. Everyone wants to be the disruptor, usually without the vision, talent, or execution, when "just making a lot of money" is also a fine goal that seems to be overlooked. Nvidia was always more likely to disrupt Intel with their ARM chips, but again, easier to dream about than execute. Hasn't happened. It's not that easy nor is it truly done often.
Especially the concept of sustainably making money is dismissed outright by nearly everyone. Here in the US it's all about the "bottom line" and quarterly executive bonuses. They love their reorgs. It's a broken model. While the Japanese, such as at Toyota, do a good job out of national honor. We can't compete with that sense of national pride. Western employees are broken culturally, and largely due to decades of watching the rich take it all as their prospects dwindle. Most of it lay at the feet of management though, as we made quality stuff in decades past.
I'd prefer to execute in a disciplined manner with quality output, something I could be proud of and fairly compensated for. Sustainably "just getting rich", Toyota style. That's not good enough in the US, we prefer booms and bust, then ending up broke. Best case for an American company is ending up a zombie corporation reliant on endless bailouts while claiming they're too big to fail. Even financial organizations that do nothing but sign documents as "product", reissuing Federal Reserve loans at usury rates, and would leave no gap upon disappearing overnight. To be replaced with a more rational actor that will be more responsible with such an easy way to make money.
At some point the Americans are going to have to realize that disruption can also be simply be delivering quality, reliably for decades. Toyota vs GM/Ford is a perfect example, as they were definitely disrupted. Being the market leader, dominating while getting rich is too longterm for us though.
Apologies for this excessive screed. This topic always bugs me. If I'm wrong, I'd appreciate it someone correct me so I can be a bit less pessimistic.
They might want to have a third party foundry business but at the moment they don't have a credible one.
So they have massive historic and prospective capital investment and a cost base focused on difficult or uncertain markets.
Add to this poor recent execution and you have a toxic mix.
---
1: https://www.intc.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/1563/...
Intel's single quarter performance in that market is quite a different thing altogether with short term post pandemic issues and Intel's own competitive struggles.
It's like like there's some law of nature that means Apple will always be on top. We'll see what Intel does - they might go down the RISCV path for all we know, wherein their own talent richness may well put them at an advantage.
Similarly is TSMC falls behind there's other fabs out there, like Samsung, or even Intel.
Promised fab shrinks and CPUs are years behind schedule. The sapphire rapids Xeon chip is in it's 12th revision and despite being 1.5 years late looks to be another 6-7 months out. It was originally going to compete with Zen3 Epyc chips and now looks like the Zen 4 Epycs will have a good head start.
Apparently the GPU effort is also years behind, failing to meet numerous previous timelines, and still has an uncertain future.
Optane never quite delivered and has been killed off.
So major setbacks in servers, fabs, desktop chips, storage and GPUs.
The semiconductor shortage has helped intel, better to buy an Intel server than wait a year for an AMD ... but that only works until AMD can meet demand.
Can Intel turn it around, sure. Will that happen? Seems far from sure. Today's situation has been years in the making and it's far from clear if the fixes have been made.
I don't write Intel of but they have a LOT of catching up to do.
AMD and Nvidia will always be beholden to TSMC - yes, they avoid the capital outlay and risk of foundries, but they also give up the possible upside of owning the foundry.
Perhaps intel will never be as dominant as they once were, but as the computing market grows there’s a growing pie to share in regardless.