No it's not. This is very realistic: pay once for a license to use the software, and then you pay a maintenance fee every year to get the updates and new versions. You stop paying, you stop getting the updates, but whatever you have already still works. There's no shortage of examples but I'll give a shout-out to one of my favorite software products, PRTG: https://shop.paessler.com/shop/prtg/new/?preselected_license...
We can pretend it will work for a while, but I do not think this is realistic.
Support is not something you can ignore: people will request support, post negative reviews and opinions, and you will need to deal with that.
My point is that we should all stop pretending and just accept that apps cannot be used without regular maintenance anymore.
I think the model's seen as being more lucrative, so even businesses that don't inherently need it so much try to find a way to adopt it.
That's the other extreme though.
There's a middle ground that http://reaper.fm/ uses. You buy the current x and x+1 versions. Then you pay for the license again for x+2, x+3 if you want to. The price is very reasonable and there's no subscription as such. If you're happy with the old major version, you can use it as long as it continues to work.
> You can stay on Windows XP to avoid that, would you?
People do. But realistically either you'd upgrade your computer since XP was sold and get a new license included, or just pay for the update once in almost 2 decades. I don't get the issue you're trying to point out.
It is of course necessary to make ends meet and plenty of software shops do just fine with the business model of making a good product and charge for upgrades.
You get all of whatever version you start on (Even if you start at x.99), plus the next, and then your license is done unless you renew it. So no matter what, I don't get updates after 6.99 unless I renew.
Most of what I do music-wise nowadays is making songs live in Ableton Live on Twitch, and I rarely bother to take them to a "produced" state, so what I have in the current Reaper is plenty. I probably won't upgrade, but I'll keep recommending it.
In general, I do think software should be cheaper than ever. The main reason it isn't is the crazy pace of changes in platforms. I maintain a web app, which helps me keep my sanity, but I'm not even considering writing mobile apps: there is no way for me to keep up with the pace of changes and updates that vendors make there. It's just way too expensive.
Devs have it do easy now, that many are so abstracted away from DB, OS, network stack, persistence, that they literally have no idea how anything really works.
This is desired of course, devs today are in short supply, just like the bow vs the crossbow, years of practise turns into months.
But the point is, it is indeed far far far easier to deploy software today.
(why the 0 and now double u usage in place of w with auus?
I suspect auus, n0de, c0mposer dependant entities, such as auus,spend time defending their business model. I want honest discussion, not "omg, defend n0de" discussion, which latches on mention of such tech and pulls in the army)
I think systems nowadays are larger and more integrated, more complex.
Deployments sometimes are simpler, whilst other things instead are harder. Software will always be pushing the limits.
Maybe you don't want the comment to be found by search engines
Infinite support or updates and a one-time-payment is unrealistic, yeah, ruling out cloud-based SaaS. But for common desktop apps and on-prem stuff, that just isn't neccessary. Drop support at some (previously announced) point and the customer can decide if they want to upgrade. Adobe CS6 still runs fine.
With a one-off purchase, you can sell the same thing to a customer multiple times, you can sell upgrades, and you "magically" remove churn.
You own a SaaS, how long do your customers stay customers? If it's 8 months, sell a one-off purchase for the cost of 16 months. Bam, you've made more than you ever would from an average customer, and you don't have to hunt them down and try to get them to stay a customer. You can just focus on building an awesome product and not worry about churn at all. In a year or so, think about a new feature or two that increases the value of your product, sell that new feature (eg, discounted) to existing customers and increase the price for new purchases.
One of my ideas is that we should package manage solutions to problems at a level higher than just code and subscribe to them. We all depend on BSD sockets due to history. BSD sockets Just Works™ and people don't really evolve the BSD socket API over time. If only the rest of the software stack was as feature complete as BSD sockets.
Imagine a labour market that was also a package manager.
When library "xyz" upgrades from version 1.2.0 to 1.3.0 there's an interface change that breaks everybody. If there's 1,000 dependents of "xyz" and it takes 1 hour to upgrade and 1 hour to pass all QA tests and get into production, then that upgrade takes 1,000 man hours + 1,000 hours automated testing.
If we don't depend on library "xyz" throughout our codebase, we reduce the number of callsites to change. If we use a facade, they're all in one place. If we use a Service Provider Interface, we isolate ourselves even more and add flexibility of implementation.
If our facade or SPI is in escrow on a labour market, someone can fix it for us for a cost of their time. Ideally the software maintainer fixes it so they don't break so many people.
"Greedy" as a criticism of a for-profit business makes about as much sense as "predatory" does as a criticism of a cat.
So a for-profit business is greedy by nature, so we need to regulate its natural impulses since it can’t control them itself, much like the cat.
If we assume that not all people (as it is people who drive these organisations) are greedy, we can also assume that greed is not baked into every profitable org.
Source: I run a SaaS business.
A related observation: we have unrealistic expectations of how cheap software should be. Software development is very expensive and has been becoming more expensive over the years, as system complexity grows and the pace of OS/platform updates increases. There are very few "mainstream" apps that can take advantage of economies of scale, and yet we still expect to be able to use hundreds of apps for cheap one-time payments. That leads to unsustainable business models and app churn.
Myself, I'd rather have a small number of expensive (subscription-based) good applications that are sustainably developed and maintained over many years.