Appeal to the stone fallacy!
Re:The Harry Potter fallacy
by BeFlatXIII on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:52PM
(#32266949)
Appeal to the stone may be the most effective refutation to "very smart" A+ students with B- intellects (a.k.a. my K–12 peers)
Then again, I generally have a dim view of using deductive reasoning as the first method of thinking. Lots of petulant "my absurd conclusion is correct because you agreed to my premises and that my argument contained no obvious logical fallacies" in that camp.
Re:The Harry Potter fallacy
by throw0101a on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:48AM
(#32263569)
> But math is fiction […]
Anyone interested in this can search for "Is math invented or discovered?".
I wouldn't say that math is fiction. I'd say that it's a tool that can be tested, but there isn't one tool that's correct. There can be many such as Euclidean vs Bolyai-Lobachevskian geometry. Both are non-fiction, one maybe more useful than the other.
Re:The Harry Potter fallacy
by sandworm101 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:52AM
(#32263097)
All the tools are fiction. They are creations of man. The rock doesnt care. Its existence is not altered one iota by the tools that man use to describe its motion. Things that have no impact outside the minds of men are fiction.
If you are correct, then man must also be fiction.
I keep using my consciousness to figure out if my consciousness is real, but I think it might be biased.
We can predict what will happen to the rock. That predict will or won't be fiction. If the rock is nahcolite we know what'll happen if we mix it with acid. The prediction will be fact or fiction.
Re:The Harry Potter fallacy
by disconcision on Thursday July 28, 2022 @11:57AM
(#32266095)
well then 'fiction' is fiction so i guess everything is real
I just threw a rock at your head. It hit your head. Therefore, motion is possible without math.