Who gets to decide what counts as emissions?
With those emission outputs in hand, a table of carbon prices is referred to before the final tally is made.
Seems to be somewhat hardcore to reduce the entire debate down to (effectively) "any CO2 is bad CO2"
For example, the production of fossil fuels releases both carbon and methane. You want to tax those as well, to incentivise cleaner production methods.
If a single country taxes their production, then products made with carbon intense methods in other countries will be imported, so international co-operation is required.
And outside fossil fuels, which we already have great low-carbon replacements for 80% of the uses of, there's other stuff that matters, like not destroying forests and peat bogs.
We don't need to figure this out from first principles on a nerd forum, the entire planet has been figuring out the details for the last few decades and publicly published the best answers we have collectively found, and continually update them:
Not doing it because other countries won't is a completely defeatist point of view. It is not destructive to the US to do it, because the carbon tax can be offset by reductions in other taxes, making it a net zero effect on the economy.
Not sure how making the government profit from it is gonna solve anything.
Smoking could be completely phased out but it wont because it's just too profitable for the government.
Yes, it is. Tax the fuel on its carbon content at the point of sale of the fuel from the refinery.