The Fed has always shied away from saying things too bluntly, and preferred to deal with wishy washy code words. If it ever says something bluntly you know they really mean it. Something like "softened" is a deliberately ambiguous phrase designed to acknowledge the reality that they're declining without causing panic, by being uncertain and sounding not terribly bad. You're supposed to wonder what that means and argue about it, so the markets don't bolt one way or the other.
If you look up the history of Alan Greenspan ("The Maestro") and the way that investors in 2003 watched for the changes in single words from meeting to meeting from the Fed, so that he never startled the emotionally delicate markets you'll see there's a long history of this kind of language.
Also it kind of scares the crap out of me that they're bumping rates by 75 basis points every meeting. If you understand how much Greenspan was walking on eggshells back in 2003, they're fucking screaming right now by their actions that they're going to plunge the economy into a recession in order to get wage growth and unionization under control.
> Well, we’ll have to wait and see. The good news is that policymakers appear willing to do just that. From my point of view, the most encouraging aspect of the Fed’s statement on Wednesday was the paragraph declaring that the committee setting monetary policy is prepared to be flexible, that it “will continue to monitor the implications of incoming information” and “would be prepared to adjust the stance of monetary policy as appropriate.” That’s a not-too-subtle rejection of demands from inflation hawks that the Fed commit itself now now now to a long period of extremely tight money.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/28/opinion/recession-inflati...
My reading of that language, on the other hand, is that its pretty tepid and just what would be expected, and that the Fed not actually coming out with the most hard-line language possible is not worth much. It still suggests that they'll stick to their guns until they see a considerable amount of change in the data. I'm drawn more to the single blunt sentences which are "The Committee is highly attentive to inflation risks" and "The Committee is strongly committed to returning inflation to its 2 percent objective" which are two pretty harsh statements that they terminated paragraphs with that I think signal their overriding concerns.
Given that I think that they'll wait until they see clear changes in the data, and given that I think that the foundations of the economy are vulnerable to shocks and I'm expecting at least a commercial real estate implosion to go off once everything gets "stress tested" by higher rates, I am not anywhere near as hopeful as Krugman.
The fact that people can get such wildly different takes out of the Fed language is a feature, not a bug.
I'm over here building a nuclear fallout shelter, Krugman is in la-la land thinking its all coming up roses, we're both reading the same announcement, yet nothing in the Fed announcement is wrong or false.
Energy, as well as being a CPI component itself, is a key production input and has outsize effects on prices across the board (though that effect is smoothed compared to immediate energy costs); if energy costs have peaked (and not just seeing a downward fluctuation over the last month or so), then that itself is going to be a huge brake on core inflation.
I'm not much for conspiracy theories but it's hard to not fixate on the sequence of events here. The past year or two is the only time in my lifetime that workers have seen their market power increase significantly, and it's being quickly followed up by moves that will likely crash the economy and will certainly decrease labor's bargaining power.
Interest rate hikes slow the economy and reduce labor demand and leverage.
You could consider this almost ritualized. That's something very different than corporate doublespeak that seeks to obscure rather than inform.
None of those things are trivially true to people who regularly post contrarian and/or conspiracy theory takes about the fed on this very web site. It makes sense for the fed to restate these "trivial" matters rather than ceding the discussion to "alternative" facts spread by contrarians.
* restate the fed's mandate to keep to full employment
* say that the fed will consult many sources when it makes its verdicts (I should hope so!!)
* say that their verdict might change if they get new input or new guidance
Surely even a true dissident on monetary matters would still acknowledge that the fed's mandate says what it says?
Someone on this thread stated the interests rates are actually being raised because the committee seeks to crush unions.
So if that "obvious" sentence was removed I'd only be hearing one side of the story if I read the poster's take and the attached press release.
More on the mandate: https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2022/02/23/how-does-...
First, this article buries the lede. The first seven sentences are framing. Only sentences 8-9 are actually news. The next four are, again, context. The headline also does not actually say what happened.
Second, of the fourteen sentences here, a full six are trivially true -- "The Committee is highly attentive to inflation risks. The Committee seeks to achieve maximum employment and inflation at the rate of 2 percent over the longer run." & everything from "The Committee is strongly committed to returning inflation to its 2 percent objective" through "The Committee's assessments will take into account a wide range of information". These are all obvious and don't add any actual information -- or maybe they do and it requires more cultural knowledge than I possess to read between the lines?
Third, use of jargon, e.g. "Recent indicators of spending and production have softened". WTH does 'softened' mean? From context, I'm guessing it means "show evidence of decelerating growth." Why not just say that?
Fourth, hyperlinks? references? Why not provide links to the economic data that's informing the decision?
Molly Young has a great article called "Why do cdorporations speak the way they do?" [0] that provides a compelling account of exactly that. Do we have something similar for the Fed? Or for bureaucracies in general?
[0] https://www.vulture.com/2020/02/spread-of-corporate-speak.ht...