News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by chii on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:17PM (#32233128)
i don't get why so many software companies want to prevent modified clients. The fact that they can detect the client is modified (and kick them out) means they could've gone a different route - allow the instance host to choose whether to allow it or not.

For some instances that are public, and needs rules and clients to obey those rules, it would make sense to ban modded clients. But for some private instances, it doesn't make sense to ban anyone, as it's private and presumably accessible to only trusted parties. The instance creator ought to be allowed control.

In a similar vein, the new minecraft reporting features (https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/article/addressing-player-ch.... ) affects private servers as well, and it's not an opt-in by the server admin.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by neoromantique on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:44PM (#32233313)
This!

For example Discord has a splendid unofficial client(Ripcord), but because they don't care about their users they choose to ban people who use it and force them to use the original lag-o-matic mammoth of a client(Like, seriously, an IM that takes up a gig of ram on its own).

Source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25217170

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by haupt on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @12:12AM (#32234168)
Their client is terrible. You can't prevent it from snooping on your processes without putting it in a sandbox.
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by ThatMedicIsASpy on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @03:31AM (#32235412)
I use web only, block every access to things and customize it with Firefox builtin custom CSS. It will put me in an idle state when I'm not interacting with it compared to a desktop client that knows when I move my mouse.
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by Grimburger on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:37AM (#32236922)
> I use web only

Which is intentionally garbage to use. I'm with the GP, pop it into an unprivileged LXD container and stop dealing with their corp snooping nonsense.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by floatboth on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @08:26AM (#32237344)
?? It's entirely identical to the desktop version. Desktop is just an electron wrapper that adds fancy integration like rich presence and in-game overlays and whatever else.
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by rebane2001 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @12:02PM (#32240073)
I use both the web and the desktop version depending on what I'm doing and I'd say they are identical except for a few features that obviously cannot work on the web (eg global keybinds for push-to-talk).
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by neoromantique on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:07PM (#32244709)
lol.

This brings me to a different pet peeve of mine. Discord is really opaque in a way that it handles activity status, it doesn't show you what status it thinks you are (i.e it can show you as Online but Away or Mobile to others). Which is very annoying when working with others.

For times when I work off my iPad, I use a vnc and xdotool to press a button every few seconds on my PC (not in Discord though, don't want to get banned). That is the only way I found to make sure it shows me as Online and not breaks their T&C.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by qweqwerwerwerwr on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:36AM (#32236918)
same. but I get the feeling that the era of services like that available in the browser is near its end. 10-20 years, and their website will only have links to 'get our app'
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by chii on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:14AM (#32234519)
i'd just use the web client for discord.
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by Spivak on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @12:50AM (#32234363)
The why is spam prevention which is why it’s against their ToS to send automated messages as non-bot accounts. How do you (somewhat) enforce that you make everyone use their not scriptable client. Is it perfect, hell no, does it work, yes.

Like I get that this is HN and the hacker ethos is “anything I can do as a human I should be able to automate” but that makes the already intractable spam problem that much harder.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by chii on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:17AM (#32234533)
a spammer can automate the spamming via tools like autohotkeys, rather than modding a client. It's slightly more resource intensive, but not by much imho.

Preventing spam is more a task for server-side detection and filtering. Gmail's been doing it very well for decades, and i can't see why similar methods won't work for messaging. And adding a rate-limit server-side is another defence. The least useful option of banning modded clients for chats is a bad trade-off for most users whilst providing very little actual protection.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by mike_hearn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:54AM (#32235889)
Stuff like AutoHotKeys is far slower than a multi-threaded bot driving the protocol directly, and spam is all about speed/volume, so in practice if spammers are reduced to that it's a big win.

Gmail actually does rely on various forms of "anti cheat" to control spam, including obfuscated code that detects attempts to automate the browser. That doesn't help for inbound mail but it helps a lot to stop people sending spam from Gmail.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by chii on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:28AM (#32236094)
> Stuff like AutoHotKeys is far slower than a multi-threaded bot driving the protocol directly

Not by an order of magnitude, esp, for chat applications that are limited by http application protocols.

> ..that detects attempts to automate the browser.

Nobody sends spam from the gmail web browser client, but suppose google successfully bans (somehow?) all other email clients, the enterprising spam sending people would still easily automate the browser, esp. with things like autohotkeys (which doesn't require modifying the browser itself, nor run code in the browser).

The point is, banning a client side mod for any service is irrational if the justification is to prevent spammers.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by mike_hearn on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:53AM (#32236613)
I used to work on Gmail anti-spam. Blocking attempts to send spam through the browser UI was most of our job. Driving browsers by things like AHK is (a) detectable and (b) definitely slower by more than an order of magnitude! You can much more easily run many requests in parallel (through proxies) within the RAM budgets of ordinary desktop/laptop computers, when going direct to the network. You don't have to believe me, go read spammer forums to see people discuss how much better multi-threaded bots are.

"the enterprising spam sending people would still easily automate the browser, esp. with things like autohotkeys"

It's not at all easy for them, and people who try approaches as simple as that don't make any money. Or didn't when I worked on it at least.

"The point is, banning a client side mod for any service is irrational if the justification is to prevent spammers."

That belief is widespread, but I built a part of my career on proving it wrong. We got unexpectedly excellent results from cracking down on alternative clients that were pretending to be browsers.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by neoromantique on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:45AM (#32236555)
The point of third party clients is not even to expand on any functionality, but rather to strip down unnecessary bloat of the official client.

Users still get banned for that, even when they are well within reasonable use, and then they are unbanned with words “This serves you right, now use our spyware* of a client”.

* Discord used to scan your entire HDD “for games” when starting up.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by Manuel_D on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:36PM (#32233267)
> In a similar vein, the new minecraft reporting features (https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/article/addressing-player-ch.... ) affects private servers as well, and it's not an opt-in by the server admin.

What does this mean? Do users not connect directly to private servers? Does every minecraft client have to authenticate with a central server before joining a private one?

Or is it just an on-by-default "use official banlist" option?

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by Hanschri on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:16PM (#32233491)
Yes, you do need to authenticate before joining a privately hosted server, unless you change 'online-mode' in server.properties in the server folder. This came with a few issues. Offline servers usually had a plugin which let you create a password connected to your name in-game, since anyone in theory could just change their name to yours and get your inventory and permissions, including OP. AuthMe is an example of an authentication plugin, if you're interested in checking it out.

So central authentication has been a part of the game since the beginning of multiplayer more or less, but Microsoft has taken it quite a bit further with the recent changes. Quite a shame to potentially be banned from a private server I host myself, whitelisted only for IRL friends. How strict the criteria to actually get banned is irrelevant in my opinion, I bought the game over ten years ago, and now suddenly risk losing access to multiplayer, which was the only reason I bought the game. But we'll have to see how it actually gets implemented, I really hope it's opt-in, or at the very least possible to opt out for privately hosted servers, but I have no issue with it being implemented on Realms.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by chii on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:06PM (#32233424)
> Does every minecraft client have to authenticate with a central server before joining a private one?

yes - login is required by the user iirc. You need a microsoft account to play minecraft (and i believe they recently migrated all old mojang accounts to microsoft now?)

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by Akronymus on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @02:28AM (#32235047)
It used to be "Migrate voluntarily and get a free cape, we will never force you to migrate"

So much for that.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by ridgered4 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:42PM (#32252770)
You'll also need to provide a phone number, with the usual BS of the requirement appearing after you've migrated suddenly for "security reasons". They know people would bail on the conversion if they made this requirement so instead they take your account away and hold it ransom until you cough up the goods.
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by Handytinge on Sunday August 07, 2022 @01:06AM (#32374053)
Oh, this is common practice? I noticed the account was suspended a few days after creation for "ToS violation" - requiring phone verification to reactivate - and have so far spent hours of supports and my time hunting down the why.
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by xahrepap on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:12PM (#32233458)
Yes. They are forcing them all to migrate to Ms accounts.
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by wolrah on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:05PM (#32240937)
> What does this mean? Do users not connect directly to private servers? Does every minecraft client have to authenticate with a central server before joining a private one?

Minecraft servers in the default "online mode" authenticate users against Mojang's "session server". The clients get a token when they log in to their launcher and the servers then validate that token when the user logs in. This verifies both that the user is who they're claiming to be and has a legitimate copy of Minecraft.

Server admins can turn off online mode, but this means that anyone can claim to be anyone else unless some independent authentication scheme is implemented. As a result it's usually only done for actual offline servers and those that want to allow pirate copies to play.

I'm not super familiar with the current controversy but the understanding I have is that chat reports could potentially result in being unable to log in to online mode servers which seems likely to have overreaching effects.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by xahrepap on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:11PM (#32233452)
I haven’t looked into it because it seemed straight forward. But now you have me curious.

The clients always authenticated before launching the game and required a valid session to join even private servers. I’ve assumed the change just disables the option to join any games similar to if they weren’t properly authenticated.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by OkayPhysicist on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @01:05PM (#32240936)
> Does every minecraft client have to authenticate with a central server before joining a private one?

Yes. The way it works is that when a client attempts to join a (private) server, it sends the user id to the private server, and then sends Mojang a message informing them they it's trying to connect to a server at this address.

The private server then asks Mojang if the supplied user id is valid, and attempting to sign in to the server at this address. Mojang then replies to the server confirming the authentication of the client, and then the server lets them in.

There's also an exchange of cryptographic keys mixed in there, but that's the basics.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by asherah on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:25PM (#32233546)
they all have to use the central auth server, which does the banning you can turn off using the central auth server but it comes with downsides (no skins, no way to protect people from using your username without a separate auth plugin)
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by bowsamic on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @03:14AM (#32235317)
Runelite takes Runescape to the next level
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by tymscar on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:45AM (#32236976)
And it is fully approved by Jagex!
Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by yreg on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:52AM (#32236262)
>i don't get why so many software companies want to prevent modified clients

Perhaps not the most crucial reason in non-competitive gaming like VR Chat, but generally many companies want to have full control of their interface. It often totally makes business sense, but comes at a cost to the users.

I worry about the day reddit closes their APIs the same way Twitter did.

Re:VRchat bans mods, embraces EAC by shultays on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @03:59AM (#32235568)
It is also a security issue for users apparently, such as client mods that are also keyloggers and their accounts getting stolen.