Unfortunately, all too often regulators and Government agencies take the wrong lessons from de-anonymization -- remove data altogether, try to ban de-anonymization, etc. [1] I'm actually visiting D.C. right now with my policy hat on.
In this case, I think we should be having a conversation about whether doctors' right to privacy is more important than public interest and patient safety. Ironically, a major reason why medical practitioners are often against public data release/reviews etc is apparently because they cannot publicly refute allegations or bad reviews, which is in turn because of patient privacy. Sometimes it feels like a morass of bad laws with unintended consequences.
[1] Recent proposed changes to HIPAA do exactly that, without even an exception for research.
The only thing the federal government is doing is aggregating the data into a single source.
Every single step involved here is public, but for whatever reason the federal government is trying to claim that this data isn't to be used for public purposes. What right do doctors in these instances have to privacy in their public practice?
It sounds like this is an example of that principle. It's not feasible for the public database to be both useful and preserve complete anonymity of the doctors. You can check out much more from his two websites: http://randomwalker.info/ and http://33bits.org/