News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by zecho on Thursday November 10, 2011 @04:32PM (#3221972)
It's "ignorant" only if one narrowly defines (or conveniently ignores common definitions of) anarchy.

Anarchy can be a state of political confusion or disorder and/or defined as an absence of authority. Both are common usages.

Chaos is confusion and disorder.

So sometimes anarchy is equivalent by definition.

Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by king_jester on Thursday November 10, 2011 @05:22PM (#3222172)
Anarchy is only a state of political confusion or disorder if you believe that a central authority is a requirement for a political system. Anarchists believe and participate in non-hierarchical social structures, which does not inherently lead to chaos, confusion, or disorder.

People do colloquially use anarchy to mean confusion and disorder, but that has a lot to do with societal acceptance and condition in regards to central authority and power structures. In a piece directly about government, to use the word anarchy is this fashion is dishonest and in poor taste.

Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by slowpoke on Thursday November 10, 2011 @05:52PM (#3222281)
Edit: Woops, this was supposed to be an answer to your parent (zecho), not you.

A common definition must not necessarily be a correct definition - ask any scientist, there's probably a number of terms that are misused by the general populace in every field. As a very general example, theory and hypothesis come to mind. When most people say "theory", they mean what in a scientific context would be referred to as a hypothesis - an unproven claim that requires verification.

Now, we can argue whether or not evolution of language justifies using wrong definitions of a term, but technically, defining "anarchy" as "chaos" is - in my opinion - not correct. The term denotes a state of society where there is no governing authority, but does not imply the absence of rules, laws or values.

The major problem I have with these two definitions is that people who assume the negative one (anarchy == chaos) are, for the most part, not aware of the other meaning, and that quickly leads to confusion - which is sometimes used intentionally to defame opponents in an argument. I personally try to make it clear upfront which definition I am using (anarchy == absence of government or authority), but it's sometimes still hard to escape the negative association of the term.

Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by zecho on Thursday November 10, 2011 @11:02PM (#3223330)
> In a piece directly about government, to use the word anarchy is this fashion is dishonest and in poor taste.

That's a fair assessment, I think. Good point.