News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by Jordrok on Saturday July 23, 2022 @07:53PM (#32208777)
Yet another reason why requiring phone numbers for account creation/verification is an awful, user-hostile idea. I've always hated services that do this.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by richbell on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:35PM (#32209022)
Facebook pressured people into adding their phone number under the guise of account safety, however, their true motive was to harvest phone numbers.

As far as I'm concerned it's not only user-hostile, but deliberately malicious. Moreover, there's no excuse for services to use phone numbers for 2FA.

Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by EddySchauHai on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:39PM (#32209050)
Yep. “Suspicious activity detected, please add a mobile number to confirm you’re account” 24h after creating a new account like clockwork.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by smolder on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:47AM (#32221269)
Microsoft did this when I signed up to play Halo Infinite. I had a few hours of play time doing nothing at all suspicious and deleted the game rather than give them my phone number.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by throwaway290 on Sunday July 24, 2022 @12:49AM (#32210425)
Yes, though least it's a free product. Now imagine MS doing the same trick with paying customers who spent at least $30 thinking they'd get to own a copy of Minecraft.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by blooalien on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:37AM (#32260816)
Not only that, but their Android apps all do their very best to convince folks to allow access to their phone's contact list as well. Even more phone numbers for the "All Seeing Eye of Zuckerberg's Giant Database of Everyone™".
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by cronix on Saturday July 23, 2022 @11:39PM (#32210100)
Not nearly as bad in my book as the despicable people who haphazardly give access to their contacts. I don't care if you dox yourself.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by pid_0 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:37PM (#32209033)
It’s actually to reduce trolls, bots, etc. the easier it is to make an account the lower quality most accounts will be.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by xyzzy123 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:34PM (#32209371)
One reason many well-meaning security teams want mobiles is that phone numbers "cost" money for (most) attackers to create but do not create much additional burden for (most) legitimate users.

In a sense they are used as a kind of "hashcash" to raise the cost of fake accounts.

You can improve privacy by one-way transforming the number in a way your systems can't undo (eg hmac with a key in hsm configured for enc only, with rate limiting), but naively you lose agility and some useful capability (eg ban accounts with numbers from this range).

Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by oarsinsync on Sunday July 24, 2022 @05:39AM (#32211782)
> You can improve privacy by one-way transforming the number in a way your systems can't undo (eg hmac with a key in hsm configured for enc only, with rate limiting), but naively you lose agility and some useful capability (eg ban accounts with numbers from this range).

So store two hashes, one being the whole number, another being the number excluding the last 2 digits. These aren’t difficult problems to solve. The bigger issue is that they’re not revenue generating solutions, but rather the opposite.

Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by solarkraft on Sunday July 24, 2022 @12:57AM (#32210456)
It's also something the service provider has to do and I can't verify as a user.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by busymom0 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:42PM (#32209068)
Genuinely curious - what's a better way to verify accounts aren't bots?
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by hirako2000 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:51PM (#32209104)
Sell a service rather than sell your users and suddenly the bots are far less of a problem. In essence make users pay, bots will become shy
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by RustyConsul on Sunday July 24, 2022 @01:52PM (#32215884)
Captcha's, rate limiting, slight changes to the way you interact such as changing words, changing positions, etc.

This is a solved problem, but these things create friction for the user. And friction is the opposite of what modern tech says you want to provide to your user.

Get them to endlessly scroll, comment thoughtlessly.

Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by brigandish on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:56PM (#32209123)
Allow bots but also give users the tools to filter out bots that Twitter keeps to itself.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by gscott on Sunday July 24, 2022 @01:36AM (#32210644)
You send out a mass DM asking if this account is not a bot to not respond.

Just kidding but this happened to me when I used IRC back in around 1993-1994. For some reason I would respond anyway and would get banned for a time.

Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by qweqwerwerwerwr on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:12PM (#32209599)
there isn't one. but that's irrelevant because the services that require your phone number don't do it for the sake of security or to combat bots, they do it to gather data. when you give a megacorp your phone number, they get your real name, your relationships, and a myriad data points to sell.

this is the reason why all megacorp mobile apps and every other free flashlight/calculator/alarm app require access to your contact list.

Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by nemothekid on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:28PM (#32209705)
>but that's irrelevant because the services that require your phone number don't do it for the sake of security or to combat bots

Discord allows you to enable phone number verification at a per-admin level basis; and it is done to reduce spam and bots. You can't just pretend the problem doesn't exist.

Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by 55555 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @11:14PM (#32209984)
Twitter is at least partly asking for phone number in order to fight spam. I am aware a big motivator is also to link you to an advertising profile.
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by qweqwerwerwerwr on Saturday July 23, 2022 @11:47PM (#32210137)
twitter is a great example of phone number verification doing fuck all against bots
Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by toofy on Saturday July 23, 2022 @11:15PM (#32209990)
yes, that’s all great, but it goes out of its way to ignore the very _very_ real problem of malicious users and bots.

i’m a privacy junkie, but we can’t just handwave those away and pretend they don’t exist.

Re:Twitter data breach exposes contact details for 5.4M acco... by password4321 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @08:48PM (#32209093)
I don't mean to suggest the burden is on you to provide one, but what alternative even comes close to requiring a phone number for account creation... perhaps a credit card authorization?