News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by BolexNOLA on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:15AM (#32203034)
I am so tired of the public square analogy. You don’t need Twitter. You don’t need Facebook. You don’t need Reddit. And what’s more, you can still read them if you’re banned.

If you think it’s ok for a restaurant to turn you away because of a dress code, then this is a non-issue. The are several major platforms you can use as a megaphone, just like you have plenty of restaurants to choose from for your meal. If you are systematically getting banned from each social media platform and being “cut off from the public square,” that says more about you than it does the current state of speech.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by ricardobeat on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:20AM (#32203071)
That’s a very naive argument. If your friends and family are on Facebook, your work contacts across the country are on Twitter, the only forums left alive on the web are on Reddit, how can you not need them?

These things have replaced existing connections you used to have via other channels. You can not step away without severing them now, it is no longer a matter of personal choice.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by JackFr on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:10AM (#32203500)
> If your friends and family are on Facebook, your work contacts across the country are on Twitter, the only forums left alive on the web are on Reddit, how can you not need them?

You can absolutely step away from them and it’s not even hard. Call, text or email your friends and family. It’s far more intimate and frankly more satisfying. You lose the ability to broadcast a curated persona, but honestly in the grand scheme of things that’s better for both you and the rest of humanity.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by emn13 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:26AM (#32203633)
I did this for years. I regret it. It's overly simplistic to think this works well. The devil is in the details; and being a decent human being also means adapting to other's wishes, needs and habits. Being a small-scale dictator about modes of communication isn't great.

You _will_ miss out of valuable personal communication if you choose to go this route. It's not just about an online curated persona.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:57AM (#32203893)
I've been doing this since forever, and I don't feel I miss out on anything meaningful. Granted, I've never had that many friends to begin with, but the ones I do have haven't given me any trouble about not being on social media or whatever. In my experience these online platforms cater to shallow communications of dubious value.
Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by BolexNOLA on Monday July 25, 2022 @01:37PM (#32227991)
> Being a small-scale dictator about modes of communication isn't great.

Oh come now, isn’t this a little dramatic?

If I was forcing them to use one app I want in order to stay in touch you’d have a point, but isn’t that also functionally what you’re saying we should have to deal with? Meeting someone all the way, only on ONE mode of communication they demand?

This also doesn’t address how niche this situation is. There can’t be that many people who can only talk to their family on Facebook messenger. This can’t possibly be a major issue.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by emn13 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @08:55AM (#32249842)
It's not just about family; it's about friends too, and perhaps the periphery of extended family. Losing contact is a price. Is it worth paying?

That'll vary from person to person, but my personal experience with this was that this was a mistake I now regret. I incidentally also avoided whatsapp and other facebook-owned apps, which certainly didn't help. And some people are probably naturally great at collecting other contact details and keeping in touch via phone and email; I'm not.

I stand behind the principle, mind you; I just think I should have placed day-to-day human beings I needlessly lost contact with above that principle. I still encourage contacts to avoid facebook, but that's it. But to each their own, for sure.

I'm simply saying this because in a forum such as this one that likes to focus on the abstract and principled it's easy to overlook the plain and quotidian daily existence we all have too; we shouldn't.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by leephillips on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:28AM (#32203156)
“These things have replaced existing connections”

I hear this now and then and it puzzles me. All my personal online and business communication is through email, with some friends and groups on WhatsApp and Telegram. People sometimes talk to me on Twitter but, if I want to talk to them, I steer them to email. I seems really risky, as we see in so many incidents reported here, to actually rely on platforms like Twitter for maintaining connections.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by OrangeMonkey on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:51AM (#32203335)
For users who are banned from these services, they have to do just what you say.

Lets not confuse ourselves though - the vast majority of America does not feel the way you and I do. My kiddos swim team is on facebook, thats how we track and sign up for service, and if we lose our access we are excluded. Asking everyone on the team to move to email is a nonstarter.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by ricardobeat on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:53AM (#32203348)
Almost nobody in my circles uses email for personal conversations anymore. People don’t share their email when you meet at a conference. You don’t join the X tech discussion group over email (anymore).

This also implies only talking to people you already know, no opportunities to join or start communities.

And that’s still besides the point: just imagine that your email account is cancelled tomorrow because they don’t like something you said in a mailing list.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by leephillips on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:02AM (#32203433)
I don’t doubt what you’re saying about your circles. I live in a different universe. If someone only communicates through Twitter, etc., that’s a useful filter for me. I don’t have a Facebook account.

“only talking to people you already know”

Far from it. For example, the contact information for an author on a scientific paper often includes an email address.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by BolexNOLA on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:21AM (#32203089)
In what world are people only able to communicate with their family and friends on Facebook?

Who only communicates with colleagues over Twitter?

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by haswell on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:41AM (#32203257)
In the world we live in now.

I knew a guy who was having serious financial trouble, and couldn’t afford to keep a phone line active. He relied on Facebook to stay in contact with his wife and son because he at least had access to WiFi.

You can make a similar argument about phones. People can just reach each other via mail, or physically visit each other…but this doesn’t exactly constitute a healthy state of interaction.

Use email you say! Almost every big email provider requires verification via phone or another email address these days.

It’s legitimately getting harder and harder to communicate in these other ways.

> Who only communicates with colleagues over Twitter?

I don’t use Twitter much these days, but for a period of time, it was by far the easiest way to get/stay in touch with the communities I was organizing. I did dev advocacy, and if I ran a meet up somewhere, I didn’t want to just hand my phone number to a room full of people, but did want the option to stay in contact.

Could I have found another solution? Yeah sure. But at the time, this seems pretty reasonable, and Twitter wasn’t yet banning people for inane things.

If I lost that account now, it’d sever an entire community. Could I work around that? Sure.

But downplaying the significance of these things seems short sighted.

I rarely touch social media these days for many other reasons, but that is definitely an isolating choice to make in 2022.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by avereveard on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:34AM (#32203204)
Unless your family counts two you cannot possibly compare the time facetiming each one of them vs just scrolling an aggregated news feed
Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by BolexNOLA on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:39AM (#32203235)
Phone call, email, text message, Viber, WhatsApp, Instagram, Twitter, Snapchat, Telegram, actually interacting in person.

Half my family isn’t even on Facebook and virtually none of us even use it anymore. If that’s the only way to keep up with family then don’t act like a complete jerk online, or you know don’t harass people, and you’ll be fine. Same as regular society.

Contrary to popular belief, it actually takes a lot to simply get banned. Yeah there are cases like the post above, but the reason it is even here is because it is noteworthy.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by OrangeMonkey on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:02AM (#32203432)
It does not take a lot to get banned - you just have to have a stated opinion that does not correlate with a large portion of the user base.

If the civil rights movement was being organized on facebook today with the culture and beliefs of the 1950's as our users, I am very confident MLK would have been banned from every service.

... and someone, somewhere, would say 'don't act like a complete jerk online, or you know don't harass people, and you'll be fine'.

I don't mean this pointed at you, I completely get the feeling, but I think ignoring history and the current in/out groups is likely to lead to conclusions that are not realistic.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by BolexNOLA on Saturday July 23, 2022 @12:17PM (#32204697)
This is an accusation by American conservatives that has little to no basis in reality. It’s just an easy source of fake outrage they don’t have to back up. You won’t get banned for “wrong think.” Look how long it took Alex Jones to get de-platformed - the dude was literally starting witch hunts with his accounts.

Look, I will be the first to say we need to rein in social media companies. Their ability to shrug and say “oh well!” with no repercussions as their vaunted algorithms (mis)handle the impossibly large scale of their businesses is wrong. No other industry gets away with so much except maybe religious groups and oil/gas.

That being said, we should not conflate it with the incorrect and frankly dishonest cries of “censorship” by the right.

Related note: I think you’ll find this Twitter bot very interesting: https://twitter.com/facebookstop10/status/154978628117712896...

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by feurio on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:03AM (#32203443)
If you get banned, just create another account and then don't do the thing that got you banned.

It's really not that difficult.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by OrangeMonkey on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:10AM (#32203491)
Banned users creating new accounts is not a feature, its a 'bug' that the current platforms are trying to fix.

Ever create a new facebook account? Even as a flesh and blood human being? Lots of folks have tried to do this for oculus and a great number of them were banned. It made the news on HNN. Facebook is fixing this bug now, and the other sites are trying to do the same.

Eventually, when the big tech companies have 'fixed the bug' and your ban is - in fact - permanent and for life. . . what then?

"Don't do bad things" - a simple question... if the 50's/60's civil rights movement was done today on facebook, would MLK have been banned from twitter/facebook/instagram? I think he would be.

If you know a way to fix this, let me know. I think we - as humans - need to fix this sooner rather than later.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by feurio on Saturday July 23, 2022 @10:29AM (#32203654)
If it doesn't require you to prove your identity with a gov issued document then you'll be able to create a new account. My FB account certainly doesn't have my real name.

If it does require you to do so then run away from that platform very fast.

Yeah, a Million Man Meme is going to be so effective ... BLM & Antfi seem to have no problems organising themselves anyway and apparently they are practically terrorists according to the alt-right.

If you want a way to "fix it" then vote for someone who will bring in regulation to crack down on the powers that tech companies have.

And if you don't want to do that because you're a libertarian fan of light touch regulation of business, then you probably need to have word with yourself.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by motoxpro on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:34AM (#32203199)
But I "need" that restaurant because I am hungry, it's only a block away, I really love the pasta they cook, and the bartender I enjoy talking to only works at this particular restaurant :(
Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by bigDinosaur on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:31AM (#32203184)
They're used to organise the social graph, so the analogy is off but not actually wrong in spirit. Yes, you can gather without them, but organising without them is what's difficult because again, they now nearly monopolise the social graph of acquaintances in terms of organisation (e.g. Facebook groups for a hobby, political protests where most people don't know each other IRL). This wasn't inevitable, but the analogy to me seems to be like saying: you don't need to drive when the country decided to only build roads.

As for your last sentence, well, not necessarily. I just don't see how that logically follows. Bans tell you that you're violating a rule, but those rules can be terrible. That's true of anything ever, I don't see how you can state that it's always the fault of the person being cut off. That's like saying all social ostracisation is really the fault of the person being ostracised. The person who is unpopular might be a terrible person, or they might be right but with uncomfortable facts or opinions.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by jacquesm on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:19AM (#32203069)
> And what’s more, you can still read them if you’re banned.

That is changing and in many places already no longer true.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by BolexNOLA on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:21AM (#32203080)
Such as?
Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by paganel on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:41AM (#32203254)
Also FB private groups that may be of interest to the user.

For example many football club-related groups are private for obvious reasons, and, as such, getting kicked out of FB also means getting kicked out of your local supporters' forum where the online discussions happen. Yes, people from that group also meet irl, but not all of them attend those meetings and those meetings happen, at most, once every week (after the football season starts). For example we're out-season now but this is also the time of some of the most heated and interesting discussions, because right now we're in the middle of the transfer season.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by satyrnein on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:59AM (#32203396)
Twitter throws up a jarring sign-in wall if you scroll down more than a few tweets now.
Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by sneak on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:23AM (#32203106)
Instagram.
Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by BolexNOLA on Saturday July 23, 2022 @09:25AM (#32203124)
IG has always hobbled the browser version and always restricted access without an account.

It’s also pretty easy to just set up a new account on a different machine.

Re:A clip from Stray got me banned from Twitter by ls15 on Saturday July 23, 2022 @11:04AM (#32203952)
> You don’t need Facebook.

There are countries that use Facebook for everything, including business and official announcements. If you are not on Facebook then you are left behind. Mostly just because it is available and "free", I think.

People should not use these platforms as their "public square", because their "public square" then becomes hostile territory, but people don't listen to us and indeed use these services as "public squares".

I think that the only way to reverse this trend is regulation that will most likely come when societies finally start to realize the damage that has been caused by moving their communication to computers that are owned by a couple of Californian companies.