We just provide a bridge to create a safe place for the community :)
First, the site advertises LGBT+-friendly housing – it does not appear to discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation. Fortunately, "LGBT+-unfriendly" is not a protected class.
Second, the FHA does not apply to shared living units – see https://www.casebriefs.com/blog/law/property/property-keyed-...
IANAL or even an American for that matter.
There’s a fundamental tension between certain non-discrimination laws and freedom of association. The more intimate the association in question (with roommate selection being much more intimate than leasing in a large apartment building) the stronger the interest in freedom of association.
It's like you can party, just don't party SO hard it irritates your neighbors. :)
I really like the context here and thanks for sharing something I almost did before I saw your post.
1. https://www.engadget.com/meta-housing-discrimination-settlem...
> Find your next LGBT+ friendly household
I don't see this as discriminatory. Likewise, if somebody made a site for wheelchair-accessible apartments, that wouldn't be discriminatory either.
The difference between making a site that only lists housing with wheelchair ramps and a site that only rents to those with wheelchairs.
Like craigslist, this site is entirely user-generated listings, and I imagine it gets the same 230 protections.
> Because this website is a tool with the specific purpose of discriminatory housing
It is not. It is a tool to connect people to be roommates together. No housing nor product is provided by the site at all. It is not a platform that targets advertising nor enables targeting advertising to protected groups.
> We hold that one who distributes a device with the object of promoting its use to infringe copyright, as shown by clear expression or other affirmative steps taken to foster infringement, is liable for the resulting acts of infringement by third parties.
I'd argue that this is essentially the same. Craigslist gets a pass because its housing posts are generic, so HUD violations are entirely on the poster.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MGM_Studios,_Inc._v._Grokster,...
It clearly states it is targeting people who want to live or post a LGTBQ+ friendly place.
Disparate Impact is a bit crazy.
EDIT: I was wrong, it was having a NO pet policy, which discriminated against families with children! (And people with support animals, and a few other cases) https://kylandlordlaw.com/blogs/news/116214853-unintentional...
Still though, I think you'd be more likely to run into the anti-steering provisions: https://www.nar.realtor/fair-housing-corner/steer-clear-of-s...
It clearly states it is targeting people who want to live or post in a White friendly place."
It clearly states it is targeting people who want to live or post in a Black friendly place."
:) I think the key word is "friendly" not "exclusive".
If I (white) saw 'black friendly cafe' or something, I don't have a problem with that to be clear, but I would absolutely assume that I'm not exactly welcome, that it's intended to serve that community - as in perhaps even specific to a particular country/region people are from (or have heritage) locally.
If what you want is actually a hyper-inclusive mix, I don't really know what you can actively do, but I do think you need to not mention any particular groups or categorise people like that.
"Pro-black" is not equivalent to "Pro-white" mainly because of the context within the US. "Pro-black" however is equivalent to "Pro-Italian" or "Pro-Irish" because of the historical context of how those phrases relate to generalized heuristic (cultural celebration usually involving commerce).
> If I (white) saw 'black friendly cafe' or something, I don't have a problem with that to be clear, but I would absolutely assume that I'm not exactly welcome, that it's intended to serve that community
If your lived experience is that you haven't been welcome to a 'black friendly cafe', then that is unfortunate. That is not my experience and I can't find any data or historical context that reinforces that narrative. I'm not saying it doesn't happen or that if it did, it would not be wrong, but that statement reinforces my point.
You are using the context of how you would feel as an equivalency to the intent of the person who puts out the message. If you don't allow for nuance, then you will have missed the point.
"Pro-white" or "White friendly" messaging historically has been extremely overt as being anti-Black, so much so that we have entire amendments in our US Constitution that exist in an attempt to combat them.
Do you see the issue with this mode of thinking?
In a perfect world, the best thing for inclusivity is that nothing is said
Sadly we don’t live in a perfect world and many LGBT people don’t feel safe
It is not uncommon for people to advertise a room in an "Asian household" (for example) and that isn't discriminating against non-Asians. It is suggesting that Asian people would probably be happier there, but it isn't excluding anyone.
If you did this in China (for instance), where foreigners are not treated all that well, it might be a welcoming message
Although I would change the word white for foreigner
Nothing on the site suggests any restrictions on who uses it.
Also, all the autocomplete suggestions seems to be in the UK.
> Please don't comment on whether someone read an article.
You don't need to respond to it, flagging will do.
I'm curious to know what advice you've gotten from your lawyer on this.
[1] https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/fair_housing_equal_opp/h...
> The Fair Housing Act prohibits housing and housing-related discrimination because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex (including gender identity and sexual orientation), familial status, and disability.