The FBI, ICE and DEA absolutely do scaled collection. DEA/ICE was known (ie NY Times article) to be tracking cars via LPR/camera a decade ago up and down I95, for example. Individual cities and other jurisdictions share LPR and camera data. Things like fusion centers and drug task forces probably get access to various forms of intel.
Civilian government is different - they are subject to lots of controls and audit, and usually take data protection seriously.
Do we need to list the number of government data breaches/leaks over the past 20 years? My own PII has been in several.
They may take it seriously, but their actual track record isn't really that great.
It's not necessarily personally identifiable either (considering all the different ways to fake it, make mistakes, the inability to correct mistakes once the information is out there, and the unreliable methods used to verify identity)
Our SSN's, names, ages, address, phone numbers, emails, locations, habits, interests, political opinions and affiliations, sexual orientations, medical histories and countless other "private" and identifying information are in countless databases and available to those willing and able to pay for, spy on, or steal them
- use a VPN to obscure rough IP based location lookups and if the VPN has shared traffic it also make tracking more difficult
- limit apps which are useful with geolocation to use rough geolocation
- If on ios, opting out of app tracking will at least disable Apple’s advertising ID.
- Be mindful of granting bluetooth and network access.
For apps which require precise geolocation this becomes a problem (ex: google maps for navigation). If you can, find an alternative with better privacy incentives (ex: apple maps).
For the stronger privacy willed when signing up for a service think about what information is identifying and whether or not it is worth withholding:
- use unique email addresses (ideally with a unique domain or a shared domain; ex: simplelogin)
- use a credit card with a unique number which can make payments under a unique name (ex: privacy.com)
- use a unique name
- phone numbers are a bit more tricky (ex: talkatone)
None of these things are perfect, introduce their own risks, and may trigger fraud alerts but I think they help in some of the situations listed above.
I admit this certainly isn’t realistic to expect of most people.
If you or anyone else have thoughts on this or know of other services, I’m all ears.
I was recently discussing the Uber revelations in an ethical tech group that I run. The most shocking part for me was that at one time the app was designed to behave differently depending on whether the user was categorised as law enforcement based on their usage history.
This surely required complicity at all levels, from management down to engineers and testers.
But someone point out quite astutely that such a feature can be generically framed as "optimise/adapt behaviour based on historical usage". It makes business sense to categorise a user's profession and alter ride costs based on that. All that's needed then is to give a higher-up the control over a dial that effectively nullifies law enforcement's ability to get a ride.
The sad fact is that our surveillance society was built with the willing cooperation of countless developers for whom money was far more important than the privacy of their users.
It's gotten to the point where we just sorta accept that people want to work at places like Facebook and Google. There's so many of them that the thing to do is treat it like a morally neutral job or be seen as a weirdo.
And when the largest and most pervasive global surveillance systems history has ever known "aren't so bad", then nothing is.
For vast majority of devs, any level, the way data pipes out to different business units from your appliance at a large business is often obscure/unknown. You integrate SDKs and API's that are black boxes, you send data out to warehouses with 30 analytics teams measuring/creating new data products you'll never see.
like it or not, there are always people who will see this as the lesser evil because of their personal circumstances don't give them other options.
I should go work for Google? Because they clearly value privacy?…
https://www.unikumnett.no/2019/10/12-reasons-why-no-one-shou...
It's not a rabbit hole to hear out someone you disagree with. Unless you're either afraid 1) they might be right, or 2) the listener doesn't have critical thinking skills. I get that #2 is scary, and it's a legit issue in society, but they shouldn't be listening to you either.
Also, there are good tear-downs Peterson's message online, the one you linked is... not.
However, having been through a fairly significant psychological journey myself and then reading the 12 Rules for Life, I'm quite worried that his rules have the potential to prolong or exacerbate psychological insecurities. Some of them, e.g. "Pursue what is meaningful" and "Make friends with people who want the best for you." are absolutely fine. But there is nothing there I can see about self-compassion or self-acceptance. If anything there's a general trend in the opposite direction of encouraging self-criticism. This probably works in the short-medium term for people who experience pleasure from validating their own self-critical thoughts, but I fear in the longer term that it will postpone or diminish their potential to love themselves.
Admittedly I have only read the rules themselves and not the whole book; in fact I'm reluctant to read the rest if that is the best he can do.
I read all sorts of terrible stuff, and it probably influences me more then I'd like, but it's easy to jump in the middle of something that "seems" reasonable on the Internet.
Reminder to readers to use F-Droid
You can still install other proprietary location harvesting apps on your phone. If you do so, you are just minimizing the number of data harvesters.
To ensure nobody but you knows where you are: 1. Have only safe apps installed. 2. An OS that does not send your location to Google, Apple, or others 3. Your SIM must not be transmitting to the Telco's. This means no SIM or airplane mode.
Having no SIM does not help you conceal your phone's location at all, only perhaps to make it harder to map it to your identity.
I don't know if any location data might leak in airplane mode, but I would not be surprised if some did, for example, through NFC or Bluetooth.
WIFI triangulation or bluetooth mesh can be used for location tracking in particular areas. MAC address randomization and generic phone ID makes this more difficult, but broadcasts of known devices in WIFI or bluetooth scanning can give you away.
Others may know more than me on this.
I didn't know that, that's really smart and so simple. I like it. I don't know why such trivial thing is so amazing to me.
Which is why hardware kill switches are the future (see Librem 5 and Pinephone).
The worlds worst privacy offenders make/sell phones. Google. Samsung. Apple.
Google, no need to explain.
Samsung? All their apps, their keyboard, collect, collect collect.
Apple? Walled garden of share data with Apple.
And beyond this, for example on Samsung builds, the GPS daemon calls home(Qualcomm? looked into it a year ago...) to update agps data, but also... provide tracking info.
None of these people want hardware kill switches.
Not sure about NFC, but at least BT gets disabled in airplane mode.
Unless you wrap that phone in a Faraday sleeve, what you mentioned does not prevent tracking.
Any f-droid app that depends on location uses the standard android location APIs. That means you're submitting what RF networks (mobile and wifi) are visible, and Google then passes back an approximate location. Once you have a good GPS lock, the same data is submitted to Google again for inclusion in their database.
If you avoid installing Google Play services, you'll have to use a framework like microG that re-implements the Google APIs. microG lets you plug in a number of backends, with a default of sending the same data to Mozilla Location Services instead of Google. You can easily turn this off and use local-only location providers that either build their own database any time you have a GPS lock, or use downloads from opencellid.
Significantly, there is very little overlap in the apps available on f-droid and the apps available on the google play store. Most play store apps siphon data, and most f-droid apps don't.
at least with google play you know they're selling your data so can adjust your behaviour accordingly.
They tend to keep those kinds of things pretty secret. We didn't know about all kinds of spying they do on us for even decades after the spying started.
Further and rarely understood, but it never is about what the government currently does, but what it could do when change occurs.. like the Nazis could exterminate the dutch jews (was it then?) better because they had those registers.. like what if the next Putin/Orban/Trump takes over and wants to take some more steps..
General principle of data economy is one pillar for civil rights! Its abuse by companies right now is an super annoying but comparably small issue.
What are you implying here by bring up those names?
I don't think it's fair to pit this as a US gov't surveillance problem. It's true though - the Government missions involved, where this type of data is relevant, face rather compelling offerings especially in complex times; e.g. immigrant/refugee surges where understanding the flow of people up to the border is important for stability.
All of this data comes from Big/Small/all tech; usually branded as "ad tech" or "mobility data". And the supply chain is rather murky, masked, and rebranded/repackaged numerous times between a network of data providers & downstream businesses.
Working close to Government... I've never seen any mission specifically seeking large-scale citizen-based tracking capabilities. US government in recent timeframes have seemed adamant about not purchasing any US-based location data & are cautious even for non-US based monitoring; especially as they learn more about the origins & scale of mobility data.