News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by gojomo on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @02:43PM (#3212425)
Falling costs and shrinking size mean that over time, your standards of 'walking up and attaching' and 'detection and removal is allowed' will become less meaningful over time. They could become so cheap, ubiquitous, and nearly undetectable that your 'same activity just more resource efficient' standard will allow a quantitative difference to become a qualitative difference.
Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by tptacek on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @03:13PM (#3212570)
And I'll be right there with you when that happens. But right now, what's happening seems to this particular liberal who is generally concerned with his civil liberties to be reasonable.
Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by gojomo on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @03:30PM (#3212655)
I think the problem is then: how do you decide, and build a consensus, about how much use is too much use? Especially given that the use is covert, you might not even know when it passes the threshold you might find abhorrent.

That's why my preferred kind of civil liberty protection relies on bright-line rules. Saying, "it's OK until it starts to feel excessive" is an invitation to law enforcement to go up to, and then beyond, that abusive line – in secret – waiting for some sort of delayed backlash as the only check.

Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by e40 on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @07:25PM (#3213603)
"Falling costs and shrinking size mean that over time, your standards of 'walking up and attaching' and 'detection and removal is allowed' will become less meaningful over time."

Not to mention co-opting devices like those employed by OnStar. No way to remove that one.