News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by tptacek on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @01:30PM (#3212055)
Should they be allowed to track everyone? No. I'm comfortable with the limitation that someone has to actually walk up to the subject vehicle and attach a device to it.

If you want to talk about things like dragnetting every car on the road through things like OnStar, this is going to be a very boring conversation, because I can't imagine anyone on HN --- myself included --- is comfortable with that idea.

(Even though it's inevitably going to happen, not because law enforcement is grasping, but because technological progress is going to make access to that information the default).

Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by gojomo on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @02:43PM (#3212425)
Falling costs and shrinking size mean that over time, your standards of 'walking up and attaching' and 'detection and removal is allowed' will become less meaningful over time. They could become so cheap, ubiquitous, and nearly undetectable that your 'same activity just more resource efficient' standard will allow a quantitative difference to become a qualitative difference.
Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by tptacek on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @03:13PM (#3212570)
And I'll be right there with you when that happens. But right now, what's happening seems to this particular liberal who is generally concerned with his civil liberties to be reasonable.
Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by gojomo on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @03:30PM (#3212655)
I think the problem is then: how do you decide, and build a consensus, about how much use is too much use? Especially given that the use is covert, you might not even know when it passes the threshold you might find abhorrent.

That's why my preferred kind of civil liberty protection relies on bright-line rules. Saying, "it's OK until it starts to feel excessive" is an invitation to law enforcement to go up to, and then beyond, that abusive line – in secret – waiting for some sort of delayed backlash as the only check.

Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by e40 on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @07:25PM (#3213603)
"Falling costs and shrinking size mean that over time, your standards of 'walking up and attaching' and 'detection and removal is allowed' will become less meaningful over time."

Not to mention co-opting devices like those employed by OnStar. No way to remove that one.

Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by lwat on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @05:36PM (#3213192)
That's where we're headed. Soon these devices will be so cheap that they CAN track everyone. And if they don't require warrants, why wouldn't they?
Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by tptacek on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @05:46PM (#3213235)
You can be pulled over anywhere at any time without a court order or even the permission of an officer's supervisor. All it takes is a reasonable suspicion that you've violated any of hundreds of fiddly traffic laws. People generally don't have a problem with this; you learned about this when you were 15 and in the classroom part of driver's ed.

There are places where you can be pulled over for no reason, by default, because everyone is being pulled over. These are usually "sobriety checkpoints", but sometimes they come right out and call them "compliance checkpoints". In some states, they're lawful; in others, their lawfulness is more questionable.

I have a problem with checkpoints. Lots of people do. So there's a bright line: you can pull some people over (you hopefully have a reason, but we accept the notion that nobody has time to make sure and then if you're an officer and abuse that privilege there is a process for disciplining you). You should not be pulled everyone over.

There's a slope, I agree, but I dispute that it is as slippery as you say.

Re:Two New Fed GPS Trackers Found on SUV by cperciva on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @08:27PM (#3213798)
There are places where you can be pulled over for no reason, by default, because everyone is being pulled over.

This is the case in Canada, and I don't know anyone who has a problem with it. The police can't pull everyone over and demand that everyone provides a breath sample for alcohol analysis -- but people accept that if you've got 10 police officers stopping cars, it's a heck of a lot safer to stop everybody than to have them jumping into and out of traffic picking out individual cars.