Re:Mass and angular momentum, left ambiguous by Einstein, ge...
by atwood22 on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:22PM
(#32114152)
That seems like it would violate the conservation of energy. If all the momentum was linear, than changing the direction of those individual particles would require a force.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mass and angular momentum, left ambiguous by Einstein, ge...
by Schroedingersat on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:54PM
(#32114338)
Changing linear momentum does require a force (but not necessarily work), as does changing angular momentum. In orbits it's gravity, in particle interactions it's the electromagnetic force.
Re:Mass and angular momentum, left ambiguous by Einstein, ge...
by mlsu on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:59PM
(#32114360)
Well, if it completes a full rotation, the applied force over the time of the full rotation is zero (hence, work is zero). So yes, the momentum is linear, but it all pencils out by the direction, right?
That's my understanding of this, but I'm far from a physics expert.
Re:Mass and angular momentum, left ambiguous by Einstein, ge...
by uoaei on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:28PM
(#32114183)
There are forces holding atoms together, such that the conglomerate constitutes a solid object whose geometry is stable in time. Those forces are strong, and are often sufficient to keep a solid object in the same shape even if rotating at high speeds. Sometimes they are not, in which case the solid object is deformed as the individual atoms are "flung outward" by the (ultimately linear) momentum, which overcomes the attractive force that binds atoms into molecules/lattices/whatever.
Re:Mass and angular momentum, left ambiguous by Einstein, ge...
by derefr on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:44PM
(#32114288)
Thought experiment: if you have an elastic band floating in space, and you nudge it repeatedly to get it rotating faster and faster, will it stretch out (the way a timing belt would if run too fast) or will it stay slack? In its own reference frame, is the band being put under tension — and so experiencing elastic deformation — from the momentum of the particles within it?
Re:Mass and angular momentum, left ambiguous by Einstein, ge...
by yongjik on Friday July 15, 2022 @09:06PM
(#32114400)
Yes it will stretch out.
Re:Mass and angular momentum, left ambiguous by Einstein, ge...
by mwint on Friday July 15, 2022 @08:26PM
(#32114175)
Lay person’s attempt at an explanation: Centripetal force, but no work is done because the motion of the spinning object is perpendicular to the force continually changing the linear motion to follow the circular course?