Re:JCOF: JSON-like Compact Object Format
by Beltiras on Friday July 15, 2022 @02:22PM
(#32111248)
JCOF and gzip are not mutex.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
No, but when you get ~95% of the benefit (per other people's data) while keeping all the flexibility, compatibility with everything under the sun, and native-performance parsing everywhere, the supposed improvement looks a lot less like one.
A sibling has the data. For that case it's 10% of egress which can be a healthy chunk of change on your bill. For all such use cases you should of course benchmark a lot and then pick what fits. I think this tool is a nice one to have in the toolbox. The low-rate files seem to be close to optimal.
> For that case it's 10% of egress which can be a healthy chunk of change on your bill. For all such use cases you should of course benchmark a lot and then pick what fits.
Provided that you don't run into the issue of one end only talking in language X, which does not have JCOF support due to there not being any libraries for it yet. In the GitHub repo, it seems like there is only the JavaScript reference implementation for now.
The design documents are really thorough. I don't think I would be more than a day making a serializer in Python for example. Lack of libraries just means an interested developer needs to tend to the matter and solve the issue.
Re:JCOF: JSON-like Compact Object Format
by zimpenfish on Friday July 15, 2022 @05:26PM
(#32112992)
> A sibling has the data.
And now has updated data showing that sorting your keys lets `lzma` beat `jcof|lzma` at every level. The egress bill has been reduced! All rejoice!
Re:JCOF: JSON-like Compact Object Format
by zimpenfish on Friday July 15, 2022 @07:53PM
(#32113981)
EDIT: Nope, I was wrong, I was doing `lzma` against `jcof|zstd`. `jcof|lzma` is still sneaking ~1M below `lzma` at all levels.
You just blew my mind that “mutex” is a portmanteau of “mutually exclusive.” How have I been programming for 20 years and never realized this?
Perhaps you haven't had to program concurrencies or thought much about bitwise operators. It's not very frequent anymore. Used to be.
Re:JCOF: JSON-like Compact Object Format
by zimpenfish on Friday July 15, 2022 @03:13PM
(#32111748)
See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32111239 where I tested gzip vs jcof vs jcof+gzip (tl;dr: you save 2M at the cost of an extra CPU intensive process)