Yes. It is. But as another poster has noted, he largely recanted in 2017 [1]. And this is to his credit. Few scholars -- and fewer prominent ones -- have been willing to reverse course in as public a fashion as this.
[1] https://replicationindex.com/2017/02/02/reconstruction-of-a-...
This is a great insight.
So he admits that the studies don't replicate but he still believes in their conclusions? Somehow that makes him look worse, not better, in my eyes but maybe I'm too critical.
Admittedly, the experiments he conducted and cited were found to be flawed. But I think his point, as I understand it, still stands.
Blind faith in the results of a study is not good science. If a study is counter intuitive, one should question it.
Restated: "I'm correct, about us all being prone to cognitive errors, where you like it or not."
> My reason for writing this letter is that I see a train wreck looming. I expect the first victims to be young people on the job market. Being associated with a controversial and suspicious field will put them at a severe disadvantage in the competition for positions. Because of the high visibility of the issue, you may already expect the coming crop of graduates to encounter problems. Another reason for writing is that I am old enough to remember two fields that went into a prolonged eclipse after similar outsider attacks on the replicability of findings: subliminal perception and dissonance reduction.
> I believe that you should collectively do something about this mess. To deal effectively with the doubts you should acknowledge their existence and confront them straight on, because a posture of defiant denial is selfdefeating. Specifically, I believe that you should have an association, with a board that might include prominent social psychologists from other field. The first mission of the board would be to organize an effort to examine the replicability of priming results, following a protocol that avoids the questions that have been raised and guarantees credibility among colleagues outside the field.
His more recent (2022) retrospective on the episode is also pretty interesting: https://www.edge.org/adversarial-collaboration-daniel-kahnem...
Yeah, your reaction is. The whole point was to be humble and accept that you might be wrong. In particular, if well-done research contradicts your prior belief, then you "have no choice" but to consider that you might have been wrong.
It turns out that the "well-done" was not the case here, but I find it hard to think your post was in good faith.
> The idea you should focus on, however, is that disbelief is not an option. The results are not made up, nor are they statistical flukes. You have no choice but to accept that the major conclusions of these studies are true. More important, you must accept that they are true about you.
So so arrogant, and he ended up being wrong about it too. It's very hard to take him seriously after reading this.