News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by olalonde on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @12:25PM (#32084882)
That's almost the opposite of what I said. My whole point was that it's possible to use non-blockchain payment systems (e.g. Lightning) to transact in Bitcoin while still reaping many of its benefits. I guess if you wanted to sarcastically quote me, you should have gone with "Bitcoin is better because fiat currencies don’t even have a blockchain." (a statement I agree with).
Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by TradingPlaces on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @02:37PM (#32086939)
Why is blockchain better than a centralized database for the end user? What specific advantages does it offer to me when I go to 7-11 and buy a Slurpee with my watch, which is how I do it now?
Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by olalonde on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:50PM (#32087904)
Third attempt: it's not! The Bitcoin blockchain is not suitable for day-to-day transactions like buying a Slurpee. You should use your watch and a centralized database to do "offchain" BTC transactions instead[0]. The real question is: why is BTC better than fiat (e.g. USD)? This is what I attempted to answer in my topmost comment.

[0] Or better, use the lightning network. As an end user, its benefit over more centralized alternatives like Paypal or credit cards is that it's an open network. You don't have to ask permission and open an account to start using it. Also, low fees. Also, your account can't be frozen or confiscated. Also, it works everywhere in the world and there are no extra fees for international payments. Also, you can do peer-to-peer transactions.

Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by TradingPlaces on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @08:45PM (#32090595)
I am asking why I would open an account in the first place when the current system works great for me. I am sorry you find it so frustrating that I would like to know why I should switch to using Lightning. The only answer seems to be “because blockchain,” and that explains exactly nothing.

Edge cases are not mass deployment use cases

Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by olalonde on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:53AM (#32093238)
Ah, I see. I didn't mean that you could literally buy a Slurpee with BTC on your watch today. It was just a hypothetical example for how it could work in the future.

There aren't many use cases for the "average Joe" for now. It's still the early days and not many merchants support it. So if you aren't particularly interested in the technology/philosophy nor have a use case for it, there's probably no compelling reason for you to use it. Right now, it is of most utility to unbanked/underbanked people, for remittances, and p2p payments. It is also used for payments by merchants but only in some niches (e.g. online porn, gambling, cannabis industry, etc.).

Of course, it's also appealing to speculators who believe in its long-term potential. They are probably the largest class of Bitcoin holders, but Lightning doesn't really target that use case.

Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by skinnymuch on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:00PM (#32097757)
13 years is not early days
Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by olalonde on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:00PM (#32101968)
Yeah, a metaphorical "early days". What I meant was that adoption level is still relatively low and there are still many infrastructure components and services that are lacking or incomplete.
Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by preseinger on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @02:25PM (#32086791)
How is Lightning not a blockchain system?

It depends on a blockchain?

Re:The Lightning Network: Turning Bitcoin into Money by olalonde on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:53PM (#32087965)
Yes, the lightning network is built on top of Bitcoin and depends on it but the transactions happen "off-chain". I was just making a generic claim about payment processors that enable "off-chain" BTC transactions, from the decentralized ones like Lightning to the completely centralized ones like Paypal.