News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I loved C. But it always fell short for me. Objective-C f... by tptacek on Monday November 07, 2011 @04:54PM (#3208336)
What can I tell you here? You're right, of course: most apps don't care about performance at all, either in space efficiency or time efficiency. Those apps shouldn't use C, and should certainly use a GC'd language.

I'm only reacting to the idea that (pp) "because it's 2011, nobody should be using ARC". Well, a statistically tiny number of apps may require the bare-metal performance that hand allocation provides, but they're also disproportionately important apps.

Re:I loved C. But it always fell short for me. Objective-C f... by pvg on Monday November 07, 2011 @06:08PM (#3208595)
Ah, I read it more as 'It's 2011, where's my flying car/why aren't just about all apps running in managed environments'. Sort of like one says, 'It's 2011, why did syslogd just brick my server'. And it's not a completely lisp-machiny, neckbeardy sentiment, 10 odd years ago everyone was telling us the flying car was just around the corner - Apple was busily trying to bridge Java into Rhapsody, Microsoft was working on .NET/CLR. And yet, and yet...
Re:I loved C. But it always fell short for me. Objective-C f... by Flow on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @02:06PM (#3212245)
The last years I thought that Objective-C was perhaps not future-proof enough when MS pushed .Net more and more into being desktop class.

And now MS shows WinRT that is not .Net. Hmmm... :)

Re:I loved C. But it always fell short for me. Objective-C f... by chalst on Monday November 07, 2011 @06:04PM (#3208579)
I think eropple's point was that ARC is not a very high-level sort of approach to GC, i.e., not Lisp-style exact GC.
Re:I loved C. But it always fell short for me. Objective-C f... by eropple on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @01:12PM (#3211940)
That's right (sorry, forgot about this thread). Not saying that ARC is bad, for where it's used--but it doesn't strike me as terribly "high-level".

(Neither, though, does C++, and smart pointers don't help there either. ;) )