I'm also confused how your model accounts for all the ecosystem development and enablement work that is being done across the Filecoin ecosystem. Filecoin isn't just another ETH clone - there is a ton of engineering and product work happening across many teams, with a ton of resources and dev work being poured into them (ex https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ApVVg78ZBog)
Fine to complain about crypto economic token distributions or something specific - but please don't imply that the dev teams working on Filecoin / IPFS are freeloading or disingenuous. There's a massive amount of work going into building new content-addressed web primitives by some very mission-driven folks that you're unintentionally maligning. (full disclosure - I'm one of them)
I am trying to form informed opinions on this space, so I'd really appreciate an answer!
Filecoin may not be centralised the same as AWS but they are centralised in other ways.
Any time you have a project like this with $250+ million in VC investment there is going to be an inherent conflict in their goals and motivations versus other contributors to the project.
It's like Spark, MongoDB, Cassandra etc. Yes they are open-source. But the billion dollar companies that are behind them hold all the cards and will win against any attempt to take the project in a direction they don't like.
Nowadays there are other companies offering S3-compatible file storage, so at best "S3-compatible" would be federated, but compared to something like IPFS that's much closer to the "centralized" end of the spectrum than to the "decentralized" end.
That is: decentralization is a separate concern from geographic distribution; the former pertains to control/ownership over the data and the hardware storing it, and in S3's case that control/ownership is centralized into a single corporation.
If somebody else could perhaps speculate about the detailed reasoning behind @sub7's claims (or even their own reasoning as to why FileCoin is a money-grab), that would also be great.
I'm happy to answer questions directly, or discuss any sources, but I'm not able to respond to this point by point because this just is not correct. I'm on here all the time if you'd like to talk further, or email me directly - david (dot) aronchick (at) protocol (dot) ai
Disclosure: I am co-director of Research Development at Protocol Labs.
And the rest of us should believe you despite your refusal to articulate any sort of rationale for your conclusion... why, exactly?
And then post the Protocol Labs cap table inception + changes over the same time frame.
And then post the FIL loan books from the biggest miners/market makers.
And then you will have actually done research and likely will stop shitposting
It's a great story filled with 80+% APR loans clamoring for unvested FIL balances, all kinds of middle men taking cuts, and of course putting max risk on retail when the ship eventually sinks
I really hope their $300m or whatever will build something useful, but I would be shocked if this tech ends anywhere because the whole project was/is a simple money grab and the grabbings been done already