Re:Filecoin Virtual Machine – Polyglot, WASM-based execution...
by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @01:08PM
(#32085576)
Why exactly do you call S3 "centralized"? You can distribute it around the world if you choose to.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Filecoin Virtual Machine – Polyglot, WASM-based execution...
by yellowapple on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:21PM
(#32087571)
S3 is owned and operated by a single entity (Amazon), with all data stored on and served by that single entity's servers - i.e. it's centralized.
Nowadays there are other companies offering S3-compatible file storage, so at best "S3-compatible" would be federated, but compared to something like IPFS that's much closer to the "centralized" end of the spectrum than to the "decentralized" end.
That is: decentralization is a separate concern from geographic distribution; the former pertains to control/ownership over the data and the hardware storing it, and in S3's case that control/ownership is centralized into a single corporation.
Re:Filecoin Virtual Machine – Polyglot, WASM-based execution...
by davidatbu on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @01:13PM
(#32085668)
In this case, I'm happy to use another adjective like "traditional cloud" or something. My inquiry is into why @sub7 thinks FileCoin is a money-grab.
Re:Filecoin Virtual Machine – Polyglot, WASM-based execution...
by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @01:38PM
(#32086104)
Almost all coins are money-grabs. At this stage I default to assuming a coin is a money grab, and expect them to convince me it's not. Maybe the person you were talking to is the same.
Re:Filecoin Virtual Machine – Polyglot, WASM-based execution...
by davidatbu on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @02:29PM
(#32086847)
@sub7 specifically called out FileCoin as a money grab, I don't understand their reasoning (which might be because I'm a newbie to FileCoin/web3). And from @sub7's reply to @TheIronYuppie, it doesn't look like they are willing to explain further.
If somebody else could perhaps speculate about the detailed reasoning behind @sub7's claims (or even their own reasoning as to why FileCoin is a money-grab), that would also be great.