Attacking someone personally is not ok. We're trying to avoid the online callout/shaming culture here: https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&type=comment&dateRange=a...
Having a flamewar about the definition of a word is particularly pointless because different people have very different associations with the same word—especially when you remember that this place literally has commenters coming from all over the world.
Edit: you've unfortunately been breaking the site guidelines in other threads as well, e.g. here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32050947. We eventually ban accounts that do that, so please don't do that. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
It’s like being a loan shark or pimp. People actively choose that life and society talks poorly about them because of the social harm they bring. There’s nothing stopping someone from washing their hands of any of those things and being productive.
This is exactly the problem. The MBA skill set is climbing corporate hierarchies. Not product design, customer service, empathy, or long-term thinking; only promotions. That's the whole reason anyone gets an MBA.
MBAs often lack domain knowledge, but even when they have it, the MBA problem remains because their priorities are unrelated to product improvement. They spend their time ingratiating themselves and taking over the top layers of management, hiring more MBAs all the while, until a formerly functional company ends up like Boeing or Sculley's Apple.
Too many MBAs will inevitably degrade product quality.
My. God. Man.
The amount of misunderstanding, arbitrarily 'made up stuff' and naive speculation on this thread ... it's just ridiculous.
It's kind of general professional designation, and valuable education for those with no business background (though likely not useful unless from one of the better schools). I'll gather that more than 1/2 of them come from hard professional backgrounds (i.e. CFA, Finance, Eng, Science, Econ) and that they may not be directly oriented towards a specific 'role or trade' frankly is not that important.
Almost everything that has been specifically said in this thread is a bit ridiculous (almost comical), and a lot of it kind of petty as well.
"Those sneaky manipulators!"
"Their priorities are this or that!"
And really, really weird the amount of hyperbole here.
I'm going to guess that maybe you don't really know MBA is (that's ok, it's not an insult, most people don't), and because you don't speak the language of finance, macro/micro economics, marketing, you may be inclined to assume that those things 'are not irrelevant', which is and oddly peculiar form of ironic glibness.
It's a generalist designation.
Some of them are good, some are not.
It's not that big of a deal, and it's not at all like what some people are implying here.
> the language of finance, macro/micro economics, marketing
This is like saying people get computer science degrees to learn about programming. Is it important for the job? Yes. Will you learn it in the program? Yes. Is it why people pursue the degree? Absolutely not. An MBA is an expensive, time-consuming certification. Nobody gets a graduate degree in business administration because they enjoy the classes. People pursue them because they provide opportunities for career advancement at the higher levels.
> Some of them are good, some are not.
This is the core of the problem. For a company, it doesn't matter whether the MBAs are good, because they're almost definitionally climbers and as climbers their incentives are fundamentally misaligned with long term success.
I'll use Boeing as an example again, because it's such a textbook case. Management (composed primarily of MBAs) discovered senior engineers were expensive and laid them all off. Twenty years later, their planes crash, their capsules leak, and their rockets don't work well enough to launch at all. Did they make the wrong decision? Well it looked very good on a lot of quarterly revenue reports, EBITDA was up, and the CEO responsible for most of those layoffs (James McNerney, MBA) retired well before the disasters to accolades, trusteeships, and not tens but hundreds of millions of dollars. From his perspective, he achieved the goal behind getting an MBA in the first place.
There's nothing wrong with ambition, but being wary of people with too much of it has been a tenet of humanity since before the refinement of bronze.
"Convenience Fee" "Synergy" "Circle back to this" "Double-click on this issue"
This is just the fallacy of definition. Technically being anti-racist or anti-terrorism is "bigotry" on a fallaciously "strict" interpretation of some short definition of the word if one refuses to acknowledge its social and historical context (and how the word is used in the real world.)
If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
"Engineer" can at least be a verb. I don't think MBA can?
Flamewar comments are not ok, and personal attacks are very not ok. No more of this please, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are.
Engineering without professional leadership leads to wasted effort, solutions in search of problems, and also occasional successes such as Linux.
Leadership without engineering (or equivalent in other fields) is the B-Ark.
If you let yourself respond with anger, no matter how justified you feel, you're going to end up in the second group — leadership is a position of strength, and if there's one thing people like even less than sore losers, it is sore winners.
I'm an Engineer and an MBA, very proud of both designations, and proud of almost all of my colleagues in both of those fields.
I'm a better person for knowing the people I worked and studied with.
I'm not hugely offended by the OP comment (or even yours), it's not a big deal, rather I'm pointing out that it is straight up a kind of misplaced bigotry - maybe not the best word, but it's correct. It's more ridiculous than anything.
Just re-read what you wrote: "because you are in the squeeze & exploit group and you know it"
Seriously? What the F is your problem? Why would you even conceive to write that to a random commenter on HN?
Do you folks not see this weirdly dark and perverse cynicism coming out here? What's wrong with you people?
I think maybe there is an odd, intellectually lazy thing happening whereby some people, possibly lacking the understanding of a lot of the mechanics of the 'business world', and knowing that 'bad business people exist' ... just want to throw it onto 'MBAs' for some strange reason, not understanding how odd and misinformed that rationalization is. It's really weird. Guys, stop this, it's just misinformed.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Edit: you broke the site guidelines particularly badly later in the thread. We ban accounts that do that, so please don't do it again. More here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32072856.
It happens when people change perspectives from building and sustaining businesses to exploiting and squeezing every employee, supplier, and customer for the last drop.