News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by 0xbadc0de5 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @08:53AM (#32069150)
I realize comparisons to Tulip Mania [1] aren't necessarily apt, but listening to the home improvement contractor I hired explain his crypto strategy certainly did leave me with that "peak bubble" vibe [2].

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/dutch_tulip_bulb_market... [2] https://archive.fortune.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archiv...

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by wpietri on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:30AM (#32070510)
I know that feeling. I was on a subway platform when a rando started explaining to me how she was investing in bitcoin mining. She was a real estate agent with no tech knowledge, but somebody she talked to persuaded her to buy and run hardware.

What really scares me is that this was easily 5 years ago now. At the time I too thought "peak bubble". The extent to which this space has metastasized blows me away. Normally a scam dies when the novelty wanes and it runs out of suckers. But the cryptowhatever space has continually generated shiny new illusions for people to pump and dump. I'm now wondering if we've entered the age of the permanent floating scam, where "there's one born every minute" is enough to provide an eternal flow of suckers for an ever-shifting constellation of predators and useful idiots.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by godelski on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @03:52PM (#32074822)
> Normally a scam dies when the novelty wanes and it runs out of suckers. But the cryptowhatever space has continually generated shiny new illusions for people to pump and dump.

I think what's happening here is that there's both scams and legitimate usages. The legitimate users are having a hard time advancing because the scammers dominate the ecosystem and the scammers perpetuate because the legitimate users/developers keep using/developing. We see big companies investing in these companies. We also see scammers funding research (to help prop up the bubble and legitimize themselves).

I think this is what separates crypto from tulip mania. At the end of the day, tulips had very little actual value. On the other hand, crypto does have some value, but people are convinced the technology is much further along than it actually is and thus the bubble refuses to pop. What the actual value of crypto is is up for debate. But I think we can all agree that it is neither zero nor what the current market reflects (at least the current state of crypto).

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by wpietri on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @05:39PM (#32076020)
I have spent the better part of a decade looking for legitimate uses. By which I mean legal, value-creating activities that aren't served better by some other technology. The very best I've found is that it's good for some light financial crime. Some money laundering, some ransomware, various sorts of scams and fraud.

When I compare Bitcoin's paltry real-world use versus, say, M-Pesa and Venmo, which target the same initial uses as Bitcoin, I think it's especially easy to see that the legitimate problems were long ago solved pretty well. So a decade in, I'm comfortable saying the actual value is near enough to zero that it makes no practical difference.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by godelski on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @08:08PM (#32077448)
I think there is real value in having digital cash. That is, a digital currency that is both private and secure. I'm thinking something along the lines of zcash though, not bitcoin.

I agree that there are other technologies that solve a lot of the same problems cryptocurrencies serve, but I think your search criteria is wrong. You're looking for legitimate users instead of looking for legitimate usecases. Since the tech is new the only legitimate users you're going to find are fanboys and geeks. This is going to tell us very little about real world usages. If we judged a technology's use case by the number of legitimate users then we'd never invent new technologies because there are never legitimate users using technology that doesn't exist (and very few when it is new). So I don't understand your search criteria.

There are many big fin companies investigating and using different cryptocurrencies though. Whether you call these legitimate users or not is very debatable though.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by wpietri on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:30PM (#32078747)
I think this shows a very poor understanding of technology adoption cycles:

> If we judged a technology's use case by the number of legitimate users then we'd never invent new technologies because there are never legitimate users using technology that doesn't exist (and very few when it is new).

This is definitely not true. Take the internet as an example. From its earliest days it was practical for its initial users. Then there was a long virtuous cycle of increasing capability and increasing users. Along the way, many of the new technologies had plenty of plausible initial users. E.g., look at the initial proposal for the WWW: http://info.cern.ch/hypertext/WWW/Proposal.html

You might also read "Crossing the Chasm", which describes the typical tech adoption lifecycle, who early users tend to be, and how one gets from there to a real success.

> I think there is real value in having digital cash. That is, a digital currency that is both private and secure. I'm thinking something along the lines of zcash though, not bitcoin.

I believe you think that. But I don't think the evidence bears you out. For most people digital cash already exists, and has since the days debit cards became popular. Bitcoin's actual use is a rounding era compared with M-Pesa's transaction volume, let alone debit and credit card use.

> There are many big fin companies investigating and using different cryptocurrencies though. Whether you call these legitimate users or not is very debatable though.

Sorry, but no, there's no real debate. It's true that many of them have investigated, because some VP saw something buzzy enough that a pilot project would give him a career advantage. But it's also true that real financial companies are actually doing very little with cryptocurrencies, and it's less over time. One could argue that's because major financial companies just don't get it. But I think the more plausible explanation is that they see a lot of risk, especially reputational risk and regulatory risk, with comparatively little offsetting reward.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by godelski on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @03:46PM (#32087862)
> For most people digital cash already exists, and has since the days debit cards became popular.

I don't think exchanging money that is tracked and the data is sold is privacy preserving and akin to cash. Honestly, I feel like you didn't read my comment but just ranted because I said cryptocurrencies might have some value (after stating that the vast majority of it is scams).

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by wpietri on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:27AM (#32124463)
I read your comment. I just think you're wrong.

I understand that for you, being able to secretly use your money has value. Setting aside the extent to which that may not make sense (money is inherently social), it's still not something most people care about. In the US, use of actual cash is declining rapidly, going from over 30% of payments to under 20% in less than a decade. In many countries, it's lower still.

I get that there are some people who have practical needs to hide their transactions. E.g., criminals. And there are some people who, as you, have an emotional or ideological desire for financial secrecy. But I don't think either group is sufficient to drive real adoption of cryptocurrency as a common payment mechanism. The former group is self-limiting; they attract police attention and regulatory scrutiny and create branding problems. And I think the latter group is too niche to matter enough to the rest of the payment market.

Maybe I'm wrong, of course, but after a decade of asking for real uses and getting back handwaving, I'm not sweating this one.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by jq-r on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:09PM (#32071974)
You're right, its a perpetual scam. Every day there are thousands of kids who get old enough to think that they can get quick rich by being part of that scam. Some people exit the "market", many more enter it. That's a serious problem and I don't think it will end soon.

That's the reason why a lot of those cryptocurrencies didn't go straight to zero in the last month or so, there are just more morons "buying the dip" and expecting that new money will come and create another hockey stick (and unfortunately it will as explained above).

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by atwood22 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:54AM (#32071757)
I didn't think Bitcoin was a bubble 5 years ago. The only people I knew using it were using it to buy drugs, and the price seemed to reflect that utility plus the novelty of its implementation. That real estate agent probably did quite well for herself, even at current prices.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by wpietri on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:06PM (#32071948)
Depends upon her timing and what she was doing. Bitcoin had a peak in late 2017 and then fell 75%, taking 3 years to recover. If whatever she "invested" in was even valid, it's plausible that she made her bet based on rising prices. Or that the hardware became obsolete sooner than she was told. Or that she doubled down based on thinking the fall was a blip.

There are a lot of ways for amateurs to lose money, and many of those ways are, as here, engineered by the people eager to take advantage of amateurs.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by atwood22 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:54PM (#32072691)
I guess it just feels a little elitist to assume she didn't know what she was doing because she was a real estate agent. She definitely was a part of the scene way before most people, so hindsight makes me think she should get some benefit of the doubt. Like yea, she sells real estate, but maybe likes to socialize with a more tech-oriented crowd, or used to work in tech herself but chose real estate to have better hours, etc.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by wpietri on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:47PM (#32074129)
I'm not assuming it was because she was a real estate agent. I specifically said she had no tech knowledge.

It's nothing personal against real estate agents; half of one side of my family was in real estate. What makes you good in real estate is mainly dealing individually with people in a sales-y way, plus moderate knowledge of your local property market. It requires only 9th-grade math and no tech savvy.

Is it possible she was also a tech genius? No. Because she not only said she wasn't into technology, she also quickly demonstrated that lack of knowledge. But more importantly, she was excited about bitcoin, which even then was obviously a technology that was not good for much besides creating a zero-value, highly hypeable speculative instrument.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by skinnymuch on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:30PM (#32073941)
You can frequently tell how tech savvy someone is, at least to a degree. Just like someone can tell I don’t know anything about cars within a minute of talking about cars.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by powerhour on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:28AM (#32070486)
For me it was minimum wage workers at a Jiffy Lube -- folks that probably don't have much disposable income believing they're going to 10000x their investment and be instarich.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by nerdix on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:43AM (#32070725)
You can see this on reddit too. Find a relatively new/unknown coin thats starting to get "next Doge/Shiba" hype on crypto blogs then look for a subreddit for that coin. You'll find quite a bit of people who clearly are working low end hourly wage jobs that are putting sizable percentages of their paycheck every couple of week into the coin. The sub will be littered with posts like "I just bought another 1 million JindoCoin! To the moon!!!!!" They are all hoping for the moonshot return that turns them into millionaires so they can leave the crappy job.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by hotpotamus on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:20PM (#32072166)
I assume a lot of that is astroturfing, but it's really impossible to tell. It also seems to have religious elements to it which I find unfortunate.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by rhodorhoades on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:21AM (#32069511)
At the bottom of that tulip mania article, investooedia is offering $1M crypto giveaway. We definitely live in a simulation.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by Aaronstotle on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:43AM (#32071574)
I knew things were ridiculous when my good friend who is not technically inclined casually said "When dogecoin hits a $1"

I was shocked because he said it with the same conviction as when the sun rises tomorrow.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by germinalphrase on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:13AM (#32070260)
For me - it was seeing a Bitcoin "ATM" next to the Dipping' Dots machine at my local mall.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by popcalc on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:28AM (#32070487)
Those have a genuine purpose though. To help local drug dealers launder their earnings to cash.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by HashBasher on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:15PM (#32073754)
2013 called, they want their narrative back. ATM machines have cameras and does KYC.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by popcalc on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:12AM (#32080151)
The ones near me in SoCal let you liquidate 2.5K/day with an SMS verification and 360p selfie. In Europe you can do magnitudes higher and it's even laxer. Do the cameras actually turn people off? Hell no. Most people using the machines are networked mules sourced from Craigslist. What legit use case is there for paying the crazy 17-30% premiums if you have other options? Whales have always had OTC and the average dude can probably pay less in taxes selling on even a US-banked CEX.

I know a guy who owned a sizable exchange at one point in the 2010s. Today he wishes he had never stepped into the world. The real shot callers are a mix of CBOE quants and international organized crime players. The narratives exist for a reason.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by dharmab on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:03AM (#32071018)
Those are so the elderly can pay scammers and ransomware.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by quickthrower2 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:18PM (#32072123)
Quotes because Bitcoin ATMs rarely allow conversion to cash (just from cash)?
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by germinalphrase on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:45PM (#32072538)
Correct
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by mherdeg on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:52AM (#32069922)
What was his crypto strategy?
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by 0xbadc0de5 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:11AM (#32071118)
I'm sure you can guess - basically boils down to the usual combination of "buy the dip" and "line goes up" that you often hear repeated on various YouTube channels and sub-Reddit's. In his defence, he did not use the phase "to the moon" even once. We did probe a bit, out of morbid curiosity, he was down something like 50%. There wasn't much deeper knowledge of the technical aspects of crypto or the various implementation differences, key management, etc. Not to mention traditional investing ideas like volatility and risk. For all appearances, just looks like a victim of the hype. He does do good reno work though and we pay him well for it. If he wants to buy magic beans with it, that's up to him.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by yuuu on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:39AM (#32069749)
Why does it matter that he was a home improvement contractor?
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by michaelt on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:08AM (#32070187)
There's a (possibly apocryphal) story [1] that Joe Kennedy got out of the stock market just before it crashed when a shoeshine boy gave him investment advice, which he saw as a sign of a bubble about to burst.

0xbadc0de5 revists this classic story, with a home improvement contractor replacing the shoeshine boy.

[1] https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/BUSINESS-INSIDER-The-Mai...

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by yuuu on Friday July 15, 2022 @12:10PM (#32109599)
The question was mostly rhetorical, intending to point out that getting investment advice from a home improvement contractor is no different than getting investment advice from a software developer on Hacker News. There was an implication that, since a home improvement contractor works with his hands, he's as stupid as a shoeshine boy.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by blululu on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:42AM (#32069794)
If he were good at speculating he would be doing it full time.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by fundad on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:03PM (#32072829)
Probably because of how much money is sloshing around the home improvement industry. We're in the wrong business.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by akhmatova on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:21PM (#32073081)
It is significant that the people being taken aren't just teenagers and adult wastoids with addictive personalities. But rather professionals with (otherwise) stable careers.

Who were led to believe that crypto was legit, and a way to finally get their fare share.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by LegitShady on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:41AM (#32069773)
read the second link
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by phabricator on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:15AM (#32069442)
Tulip mania is the go-to comment for every post about crypto on HN, you don't need the link.

Shocked no one called this a Ponzi scheme yet.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by sofixa on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:19AM (#32069491)
TFA isn't describing a Ponzi scheme because (as far as we know) the person doing the machinations doesn't run the scheme (underlying "coin") and doesn't use new investors' money to pay off existing ones. It's just a pump and dump (buy while something is cheap, hype it up to make the price go up, then sell at the top).
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by phabricator on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:22AM (#32069526)
I know, still surprised no one has called it that
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by efficax on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:41AM (#32069774)
tulip mania and ponzi schemes come up for a good reason
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:49AM (#32069902)
..and those reason are what exactly in relation to the solve of the Byzantium Generals problem?

USD is still the goto choice for ponzi and scams in general, does that invalidate it's utility?

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by TomSwirly on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:41AM (#32071542)
Blockchain doesn't actually solve the Byzantine Generals problem, because that is in principle unsolvable.

It mitigates the issue by making a 51% attack or its equivalent harder.

Outside cryptocurrencies, there is literally no practical application for even an approximate solution for the Byzantine Generals problem.

Outside cryptocurrencies, you can always use a 1970s vintage Merkle tree without the 10000x weight of the blockchain.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:52AM (#32071723)
Byzantium would disagree with your analysis...except it doesn't exist anymore because it couldn't solve the problem.

You are splitting hairs on the solve and it comes off as petty. Bitcoin 100% has solved it, prove me wrong by showing me how it's failed.

> Outside cryptocurrencies, there is literally no practical application for even an approximate solution for the Byzantine Generals problem

Hmmm sure

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by svnt on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:47PM (#32074133)
> prove me wrong by showing me how it's failed.

This shifts the work for your position to another person, and in the negative. Certainly it makes your life easier, but in traps you in a bubble of your own creation.

It’s essentially the same as admitting “I can’t prove it, so you have to prove the inverse” and hoping the other person will Marty McFly for you, and waste their time instead. It’s a solid method for reinforcing confirmation bias because whether they try or forget about it and move on you get to continue in your assumed position.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by rovolo on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @04:43PM (#32075413)
> Byzantium would disagree with your analysis...except it doesn't exist anymore because it couldn't solve the problem.

Leslie Lamport commenting on the 1982 paper. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/byzanti...

> There is a problem in distributed computing that is sometimes called the Chinese Generals Problem ... the original title of this paper was The Albanian Generals Problem ... The obviously more appropriate Byzantine generals then occurred to me.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by recursive on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @03:47PM (#32074777)
Sure, bitcoin "solves" byzantine generals the same way TCP "solves" it. The theoretical construction is probably unsolvable, like the halting problem. In practice, you can "solve" the halting problem for most inputs too.

In the general construction of byzantine generals, there's essentially an adversarial agent preventing arbitrary communications. As far as I know, a distributed ledger can't generally survive in such an environment. Nor can TCP.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by 8note on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:13PM (#32078285)
Compromised private keys are pretty obvious, aren't they?

If I've got your private key, I can do what I want with the bitcoins it has access to.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by jameshart on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:29AM (#32070498)
All scams are actually denominated in a currency that has actual value. The goal of a scammer is for them to obtain something valuable (US Dollars, say) from their victim and leave their victims with something worthless (a crypto coin, say).
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:55AM (#32071768)
Again how does that invalidate the utility of blockchain?

Protip: don't FOMO into anything as you will always be a bag holder.

That's about the jist of your response and has nothing to do with the utility of blockchain

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by jameshart on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:19PM (#32073050)
It doesn’t. Any more than tulip mania invalidated the utility of planting bulbs to get flowers to come up in the spring.

The posts you are responding to never said blockchain consensus protocols don’t work. All they are saying is that hype coins tend to have the shape of a scam.

Now, if you want to get back to us just as soon as you find an application for blockchain consensus protocols that isn’t basically a hype coin, we’d be happy to hear about that.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @12:42AM (#32079104)
I'm responding to you not OP, nice try but very dishonest of you.

IPFS, storj, any number of infrastructure projects/value props.

Hellium, which is a wireless access point blockchain, there are a bunch but you aren't actually interested in any of this.

> Get back to us

Dude speak for yourself only, I have no idea who you think you represent but you're wrong if you think it's anyone but yourself.

It's clear your not a genuine actor in this dialogue. Let's see you move that goal post.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by jameshart on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @09:03AM (#32082049)
IPFS is not a blockchain consensus protocol though? And the first five hits on google for storj talk about its investment potential, so.. that looks a lot like a hypecoin to me. But that’s not really important.

Personally I haven’t even seen the goalposts in this interaction since you decided that, in a discussion of a shitcoin pump-and-dump scam, the fact that said coin is built on a solution to the Byzantine Generals problem is somehow important, and… means that people shouldn’t criticize scammers taking advantage of credulous investors to fleece them?

It does not matter if a shitcoin is built using quantum manipulation of the space time continuum, if all that is being done with it is selling it to rubes to obtain their dollars.

You can be excited about blockchain, that’s fine, and you can believe it has actual value. But when people point out that your favorite technology is actually continually being used to perpetrate scams, you should get angry with the scammers, not the people who are pointing that out.

Personally, I like JavaScript. When people shout about tracker-infested slow loading websites, I don’t respond by saying ‘you’re wrong because actually the object dictionary duality in JS is a really elegant system’. That doesn’t matter. I reserve my anger for the people who are using JavaScript for evil.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:26AM (#32094144)
>Hellium, which is a wireless access point blockchain, there are a bunch but you aren't actually interested in any of this.

You fell for the trap and ignored the one project that meets your requirements...like I called.

You're not a genuine actor in this conversation.

And when people point out that any asset can be used, and is used to a much greater degree, you ignore it.

You are literally projecting yourself on to others.

Feel free to be Paul Krugman on this tech stack, it's not going away because of it's utility. Just because there are assholes that scam people doesn't invalidate it's use cases.. Same applies for the USD.

Anyway, GLHF!

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by JshWright on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:12AM (#32070237)
> USD is still the goto choice for ponzi and scams in general, does that invalidate it's utility?

What percentage of circulating USD is involved in that sort of activity?

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:57AM (#32071791)
How about absolutely value over percentage as that is a total BS metric in this context and you know it.

Give us absolutely values...yeah nice way to deflect but doesn't hold up bud.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by JshWright on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:11PM (#32072926)
Why wouldn't percentages be relevant? If one currency delivers a massive amount of utility and value to society while a tiny fraction of it is used for illicit purposes (i.e. USD), and another currency is overwhelming used for illicit purposes, with only a tiny fraction being used for actual utility, that is a meaningful comparison.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @12:38AM (#32079083)
Because it's a way to hide the true depth of an issue by boiling it down to % of market cap.

Deal with absolute numbers and it pales in comparison, and again it's used for scams is a null argument unless you hide it in percentages.

The argument applies to any fungible asset and isn't unique to blockchain.

Also check the history of the dollar and financial networks.. clever shitty people will always be ahead of the curve.

It's why I support regulation, people are very good at identifying bad behaviours and mitigating it..that is until they end up running it.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by JshWright on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @10:31AM (#32083290)
You're not making an argument here, you're just saying "percentages bad, absolute value good". The only argument you're making is that using percentages "hides" the negatives USD, but the reverse of that is equally true (absolute values hides the problems w/ cryptocurrency).

My argument is that the net impact of USD is positive, while the net impact of cryptocurrency is negative.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by efficax on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:40AM (#32070665)
crypto solves the byzantium generals problem, sure, but that's not a problem we were struggling with in the financial system, and it creates more problems than it solves
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:49AM (#32071677)
Knowing who to trust is absolutely a major problem in financial networking, whether it's crypto, digital or physical.

FUD & FOMO are exactly derived from this problem.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by NateEag on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @04:13PM (#32075038)
> Knowing who to trust is absolutely a major problem in financial networking, whether it's crypto, digital or physical.

Solving the Byzantine Generals problem doesn't help you know who to trust.

With a large enough network, it makes it extremely difficult for malicious actors to subvert the process of exchanging money.

It does nothing to solve other crucial aspects of "who do I trust with my money", such as having recourse when someone scams you into giving them money.

In fact, the technology's spread has enabled terrible abuses of trust like cryptolocker attacks, and has probably made scamming much more profitable and practical.

If the solution to those problem has even a whiff of "user error" in it, then I submit that the problem is not actually with the users (it so rarely is).

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by prepend on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @05:10PM (#32075742)
I don’t think so as evidenced by financial systems moving trillions of dollars that have figured out who to trust. There are exchanges that have “solved” the trust issue and they seem pretty solvent and successful.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by 8note on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:08PM (#32078259)
Does it actually save the Byzantine generals problem though?

How do you prove that only the attacker doesn't also have access to a private key?

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by Swenrekcah on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:11AM (#32070219)
False equivalency, since USD has actual uncontested utility and is backed by real world value.
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by rout39574 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:29AM (#32070499)
Backed by fiat.

I mean, the US has got some really sharp and explodey fiat, arguably the most fiat fiat in the world. But we stopped pretending it was backed by anything else in the 70s.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by Swenrekcah on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:49AM (#32070810)
It isn’t backed by fiat. Fiat isn’t a thing, it is a description.

USD is fiat money, built on trust sure, but in practice backed by the wealth and power of the United States.

Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by johnnymorgan on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:50AM (#32071688)
Nice circular logic there
Re:I watched a friend of mine pump a shitcoin on Binance by ... by jwozn on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:19AM (#32070333)
USD is the go-to choice, but the percentage of total volume that is involved in ponzi's and scams is much, much lower than in crypto.