Re:State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities,...
by iudqnolq on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:51PM
(#32065393)
I'm saying it's about the specific values of the parameters. Right now they're set so it's an evil trap. But we could maybe just tweak the parameters so that wasn't the case.
If the evil of the lottery is that the expected value is lower than the ticket cost that's just a simple stats problem to fix.
Re:State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities,...
by ac29 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:12AM
(#32066247)
Are you suggesting the lottery should be changed so the expected value is higher than the ticket cost? How would that work?
Re:State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities,...
by iudqnolq on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:16AM
(#32066269)
The same way below market rate public housing works: subsidy from tax revenue
Re:State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities,...
by yunohn on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:33AM
(#32066368)
But why not just direct UBI?
What is the point of tax subsidised lotteries, to enrich a minuscule % of poor people while all the others buy tickets in hope?
Re:State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities,...
by iudqnolq on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:36AM
(#32066382)
As one fair way of allocating insufficient resources. The lottery is evidence a lot of poor people would rather have a chance at radically improving their life than a small amount of money.
Re:State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities,...
by yunohn on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @03:16AM
(#32066642)
Do you have any real evidence that poor people would prefer a 1/300M chance in winning the lottery versus a guaranteed paycheck for their monthly expenses? I would love to see the proof for your assertion.
Re:State lotteries transfer wealth out of needy communities,...
by iudqnolq on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @03:22AM
(#32066663)
No, that sounds highly implausible to me. A guaranteed paycheck of $1,000/month to every American (in current USD) would be way better than what I suggested. This idea presumes scarcer resources.
I'm talking about something more like the difference between a 1/10 chance of $1,000/month for a year with a new drawing in a year vs $100/month for a year every year.
Both of these are the siphoning of money from large volumes of people to a few people, who are the “success stories” used to dupe the next set of people.