Got a lottery ticket with a 10% chance of being worth $100? I'll give you and each of your friends $8.50 for them, guaranteed, today.
Lotteries penalize people who are bad at math. It really is that simple.
https://highline.huffingtonpost.com/articles/en/lotto-winner...
But it’s also possible that math whizzes like Jerry Selbee are finding and exploiting flaws that lottery officials haven’t noticed yet. In 2011, Harper’s wrote about “The Luckiest Woman on Earth,” Joan Ginther, who has won multimillion-dollar jackpots in the Texas lottery four times. Her professional background as a PhD statistician raised suspicions that Ginther had discovered an anomaly in Texas’ system. In a similar vein, a Stanford- and MIT-trained statistician named Mohan Srivastava proved in 2003 that he could predict patterns in certain kinds of scratch-off tickets in Canada, guessing the correct numbers around 90 percent of the time. Srivastava alerted authorities as soon as he found the flaw. If he could have exploited it, he later explained to a reporter at Wired, he would have, but he had calculated that it wasn’t worth his time. It would take too many hours to buy the tickets in bulk, count the winners, redeem them for prizes, file the tax forms. He already had a full-time job.
This is patronizing and wrong. Math skills are also lacking in many white communities. Maybe it is more about cultural acceptance than math skills.
Denying effects of systemic racism and blaming 'culture'
The view of such a situation is further demonstrated by the state minimizing any possible benefits from the profits of the lotteries to the same Black poor neighborhoods they are taking advantage of. They are primarily funneling money out of those neighborhoods, from the people that can least afford it, to any and everywhere else.
Arbitrage is a real issue, but it's not magic and there's a lot of friction in the real world. For ex, you don't get spam callers trying to buy your chance of a large settlement payout.
Some might consider UBI an implementation of John Rawls' Difference principle [0], that distributive inequalities should work to the advantage of the worst-off. Lotteries would support utilitarians' counterargument that one may very well prefer to roll the dice on his or her welfare, rather than accept a guaranteed, minimally satisfactory baseline.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justice_as_Fairness#Second_pri...
Both of these are the siphoning of money from large volumes of people to a few people, who are the “success stories” used to dupe the next set of people.
If the evil of the lottery is that the expected value is lower than the ticket cost that's just a simple stats problem to fix.
What is the point of tax subsidised lotteries, to enrich a minuscule % of poor people while all the others buy tickets in hope?
I'm talking about something more like the difference between a 1/10 chance of $1,000/month for a year with a new drawing in a year vs $100/month for a year every year.
My uninformed guess underlying this is that making the payouts smaller and more frequent would solve this. First off, people would grow up in better communities. Second, I think if the payout wasn't advertised as "retire for life and be a rich person" people would face less social pressure to shower friends and family in gifts.
I think given no constraints giving everyone $1,000/month is best, but I think there's a fair argument giving 1/1000 people $1000/month (and alternating) is better than giving everyone $100/month.
I also don't think poor people are wrong to think a chance of getting a life-changing amount of money is a worthwhile luxury spend compared to the other available options. They may be wrong about the probability, but instead of fixing that with education, we could fix it by making the probability closer to people's intuition.
Given the well-known issues with means testing, randomly assigning the payouts instead might be a significant improvement.