News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by blueflow on Monday July 11, 2022 @04:17PM (#32061229)
Why should i believe this vaccine protects me and people around me from Influenza? Will it be better than the COVID vax that ended up only reducing the risk of a bad case?
Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by gruez on Monday July 11, 2022 @04:45PM (#32061575)
>Why should i believe this vaccine protects me and people around me from Influenza?

You shouldn't. It has only been tested "in cell culture and in mice". Its efficacy in humans will be determined in human clinical trials.

>Will it be better than the COVID vax that ended up only reducing the risk of a bad case?

This table shows that it's still effective "against symptomatic disease" and "against infection".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pfizer%E2%80%93BioNTech_COVID-...

Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by Brian_K_White on Monday July 11, 2022 @04:56PM (#32061720)
I don't understand the purpose of this question.

If you're looking for an excuse not to take it when it eventually becomes available, that's a long way off yet and seems a silly thing to worry about.

What other possible points for such a question... are you suggesting they just shouldn't even be researching?

In what way is a treatment that helps even 10% not better than nothing, when nothing is the only other option in existence?

I see no admirable way to unpack this question.

Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by dannyw on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:03PM (#32061807)
The newsworthy aspect of this is "broad, sustained protection". The parent comment directly questions this, and it's a very reasonable thing to ask; particularly with recent events showing a questionable job at it.

If you make a claim for a new solar cell technology that doesn't degrade over a century, people can question whether that claim is true or not, without implying that solar technology should not be researched.

And there's certainly no need to speculate on people's intentions, like questioning if someone is making excuses for big oil.

Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by Brian_K_White on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:09PM (#32061890)
I consulted my official reference for reasonable and it didn't decree either comment reasonable or unreasonable. It's almost like it's not even much of a statement.
Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by Hallucinaut on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @06:06AM (#32067754)
When a comment leads with a provable falsehood, that "the" COVID vax (already a rampant simplification) "only" reduces risk of a bad case, and that, by implication, there's no reduction in transmission or reduction in duration or reduction in severity of mild cases, there's not much charity to be given.

Using your analogy, it's like if someone questioned the claimed efficiency of solar panels "given the Earth is flat after all". It shows a fundamental divergence from observed fact and science.

Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by blueflow on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:57AM (#32068558)
Check out the measles vaccine. 95% on first, 99% immunity on second dose. Immunity lasts for years. Herd immunity was (at least temporarily) achieved. Also Tetanus or Diphtheria vaccines.

This is my bar for a 'good' vaccine.

What the Covid vaccine provides is a fucking joke. And it pulls all other vaccines through the mud.

Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by roywiggins on Monday July 11, 2022 @07:53PM (#32063780)
Current flu vaccines are often not super protective because they have to make an informed guess as to which flu strain will be circulating months in advance, and sometimes the guess is off.

A vaccine that can target more strains at once may be more reliable than what we've got, which is why they're researching them.

Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by BurningFrog on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:46PM (#32062373)
Reducing the risk of a bad case is protecting people from the virus.
Re:Universal influenza B vaccine induces broad, sustained pr... by birdmanjeremy on Monday July 11, 2022 @04:33PM (#32061433)
TBF, that'd still be a win if it worked for all variants of the flu.