News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by czottmann on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:04AM (#32056288)
Not meant as a diss, but:

> What do you do when an entire region is sunless and windless for a week

To me that sounds like a highly theoretical problem. I'm not a meteorologist or climate scientist, clearly, but I think a if you have a week-long thick cloud cover chances are probably comes with solid winds, no?

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by throwaway894345 on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:17AM (#32056474)
I’m not sure. Last winter Chicago went something like 40 days without sun IIRC, and I assume the same is true for much of the surrounding area. It doesn’t seem particularly unlikely that you could have many consecutive windless days as well, especially as climate change brings us these “once in a millennia” events every few years.

Moreover, as we transition homes from gas heating to heat pumps, this will increase demand on the grid and it will also increase the risks in case of failure (people freezing). Moreover, even without cloud cover, winters are snowy and the days are short and the light is indirect.

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by Retric on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:34AM (#32056705)
You just described why placing solar panels in Chicago is a bad idea.

Real world grid scale solar farms are placed in sunny areas that don't get regular cloud cover or even snow like that. Washington State and Chicago are terrible locations for solar, but moving electricity is surprisingly cheap. https://blog.solarenergymaps.com/2014/05/potential-solar-ene...

That said, cloudy days reduce but don't eliminate output, so as excess capacity is added the minimum output keeps increasing. A hypothetical green hydro/wind/solar grid would have significant excess solar capacity the same way the current grid adds redundant conventional powerplants.

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by throwaway894345 on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:55AM (#32056973)
> Washington State and Chicago are terrible locations for solar, but moving electricity is surprisingly cheap. https://blog.solarenergymaps.com/2014/05/potential-solar-ene...

Your link doesn’t support your claim that moving energy is surprisingly cheap. I’m of the impression that this isn’t the case (we can’t easily build transmission lines that can carry the necessary amount of power from the southwest to other parts of the country).

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by Retric on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:39AM (#32057570)
I didn't add a link on power transmission. Actually building stuff in the US has issues that have little to do with cost.

Individual UHVDC links are in the multiple GW range. Exact numbers depend on a host of factors but something like 1c/kWh per 1,000 miles for long range is a reasonable ballpark. (Upfront costs in the billions.) Though it’s much higher for underwater links, etc.

A link sending power 24/7/365 at maximum capacity is significantly cheaper, conversly geographic barriers can quickly increase prices. Also those costs aren't constant with distance the transmission lines cost far less than the equipment at either end.

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by ZeroGravitas on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:12PM (#32058062)
Solar makes sense Chicago, and even in places in Alaska that genuinely experience weeks of darkness. An interesting current research area is how much vertical bifacial modules take advantage of reflections from snow on the ground, while shedding snowfall better and flattening the supply curve.

A grid entirely based on solar in those regions is less optimal, but no one is proposing such a thing.

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by toomuchtodo on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:14AM (#32057242)
I have worked with several folks to get solar installed on their roof in the Chicago suburbs, and it offsets over 100% of their local consumption.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by Retric on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:51AM (#32057759)
There is a big difference between producing enough power on average and having power when you want it. Going 100% off grid is possible in Chicago but I doubt it's cost effective. Staying grid connected is offloading all the difficult parts to your electric company.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by toomuchtodo on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:27PM (#32058280)
Yeah, that’s their job, the hard part. You don’t get a free return on equity. Orchestrate power across a distributed system of load, generators, and storage or let someone competent do it and earn that margin.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by Retric on Monday July 11, 2022 @01:50PM (#32059340)
Sure, but the point is actually doing the hard part means a different approach is needed.

And don't be surprised when electric companies pay a lower rate for solar from you as they charge to supply you with power.

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 14, 2022 @09:14AM (#32095669)
You mean like this?

https://reneweconomy.com.au/queensland-to-add-more-than-a-do...

> “The new batteries will be spread across major centres in regional Queensland near communities that have significant rooftop solar generation because we know that’s where they will have the greatest overall benefit.

> “The network of the future will not only need to move electricity from where it is generated to where it’s going to be used, but also to when it’s consumed.”

And sure, utilities can buy power from consumers at a lower cost than they charge for power, but that only works until batteries decline to a cost point where consumers simply replace their utilities with batteries. Is that today? Not yet! But with the amount of battery manufacturing capacity spooling up for EVs and utility scale storage, that day will arrive.

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by LunaSea on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:47AM (#32057688)
Not during night time.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by throwaway894345 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:10PM (#32058036)
It probably could with enough batteries and panels, but it's probably a very expensive setup.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by LunaSea on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:46AM (#32057686)
Moving electricity comes with a loss of production every few miles.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by Retric on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:53AM (#32057780)
Read up on UHVDC. You pay significant conversion losses, but per mile it’s very efficient.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by Hermitian909 on Monday July 11, 2022 @11:35AM (#32057507)
Short answer is no, slightly longer answer is that even if you have "solid" winds they're often not enough to make up for the loss of solar. Additionally, cloudy and low-wind periods are common enough that without grid-stabilization tech we'd expect regular blackouts through many countries throughout the world.

All that said, I'm quite hopeful for grid stabilization tech coming online in the next decade.

Source: I've spent the last few years working on renewables R&D

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by throwaway894345 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:11PM (#32058050)
Can you elaborate on grid stabilization tech? I haven't heard about this before.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by Hermitian909 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:55PM (#32058642)
Sure, so in my mind there are two kinds of grid stabilization, I'll call them short term and long term.

Roughly speaking, short term stabilization helps deal with fluctuations in demand over the course of a day. The Hornsdale Power Reserve[0] is a good example, it's basically a big bank of Lithium Ion batteries. This allows us to handle, say, everyone in Australia turning on their AC when they get home without needing blackouts to reduce load. At night, excess power generation can then refill the batteries.

Unfortunately this is not a workable solution if total demand per day exceeds total power production per day for more extended periods (think weeks). This is precisely the problem that can occur with solar or wind. Lithium Ion Batteries are not suitable for storing large amounts of charge over longer periods. We would instead like a battery that can perform longer term storage of power at an affordable price during winder and sunnier periods.

I'm currently excited by the approach taken by Form Energy[1] for what is called a Rust Battery. If they get it working this essentially allows us to trap and release energy through an extremely cheap and scalable chemical process. During a sunny summer you could potentially store enough excess power to get you through a very cloudy winter.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hornsdale_Power_Reserve [1] https://formenergy.com/

Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by tsimionescu on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:07AM (#32056327)
While rare, it does happen often enough, and electricity is critical enough, that it must be considered.
Re:Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lastin... by czottmann on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:31PM (#32062163)
Why am I being downvoted for asking this? C'mon. :|