So value (in this sense) is not really between buyer and seller at all, but a common agreement between a large enough number of people.
What OP in this discussion did was shine a spotlight on that fact, maybe in the hopes of getting at least one person to change what they think is valuable, to ultimately help society redirect money to more needed things.
Rolexes are a status item. They're cheap in the world of watches. Many brands you've never heard of command far higher prices.
The value is in the fact someone who studied horology their whole life devoted a certain amount of hours and effort into creating something. People who love watches love the craftsmanship.
So "hours of craftsmanship and effort" is not what makes something valuable. It takes something else -- in this case that it's a status symbol. A long time ago it would have been certain tulips. Now it's watches.
Owning an actual luxury item is pointless if there's nobody to brag about it to.