News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by metadat on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:05AM (#32052057)
Isn't this to be expected with any similarly weighted network?

Guess who private sector loves to promote to executive positions like VP and SVP? Harvard and ivy grads. Even in engineering, where it's supposed to be more of a meritocracy, you can see this at every bigco.

Human idiosyncrasies lead to branding pedigree consistently being selected over pure skill and / or superior experience in favor of an abstract perception.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by Hydraulix989 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:19AM (#32052148)
Nobody cares where you graduate from school in engineering. It's all about what you can do, and in larger corporations, also how politically savvy you are. Most of middle and upper management (VP / SVP) also has degrees from no-name schools. If anything, they'll have degrees from worker bee / nerd schools like CMU, Caltech, and UC Berkeley, not Ivy degrees (except for Cornell, which is basically a public school). Upwardly mobile engineers are usually immigrants with high IQs who don't have connections and so have to work 60-80 hour weeks to make up for what they normally could have gotten "for free" with a more privileged upbringing.

The C-suite is a different story: The Ivy Grads are either joining their parents' companies, going into VC, or starting their own companies (YC), not working as lowly "senior" ICs at say Amazon. Chances are the company you work for was founded by a Harvard or Stanford grad who spent their school years partying and networking in social clubs instead of studying...

You might further split Ivy into HYPS and others (Stanford is much more like the other Ivies than Cornell). The others like Brown and Dartmouth are more like a Northwestern / U-Chicago, for people who didn't quite make the cut or for good test takers from upper middle class rather than upper class backgrounds.

UPenn and Columbia lean in the middle. Sure, Elon Musk and Donald Trump went to UPenn, but the school itself still mainly graduates "just" worker bees in finance / investment banking. Your coworkers at Google didn't go there, though.

There are always outliers at all of these schools, but by definition, they are the exception rather than the rule...

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by jollybean on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:57AM (#32052373)
"Nobody cares where you graduate from school in engineering."

Oh yes they do. It definitely opens doors. After that, depending on the role, it can have subtle effects. For mid-level management, right in the grinder, probably no as you say. For externally facing things, yes. They also might have more opportunities for lateral moves, into BD/Sales etc..

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by Hydraulix989 on Monday July 11, 2022 @01:56AM (#32052707)
Regardless of school, I would be hard pressed to find someone in my engineering organization who is an extroverted native English speaker with the very high EQ needed to hack it in sales. We're all better at working with computers than people.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by cableshaft on Monday July 11, 2022 @09:25AM (#32055809)
Yeah probably not, because those people would realize they'll make more money for less work, being in sales.

I'm aware of at least one company a friend works at in the marketing department, and works directly with salespeople, and at that company a single salesperson brings in 40% of the entire company's revenue, makes 7-figures, and non-execs in the company complain they can't get him to do anything else in the job, like provide data for presentations and the like (personally I'm of the opinion that if they're generating that much revenue for the company, the salesperson has already done their job, and C-suite seems to think so too, but I digress).

Other salespeople at that company pull in a lot less but are still difficult to get them to do other work (except attend meetings here and there), just slightly less so. They're still making good money. And that seems to be the norm at all the companies my friend has worked at.

I imagine sales is more of a grind when you're starting from the bottom, and/or for companies where the margins are much smaller, but Corp2corp salepeople in particular seem to have a pretty sweet gig.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by forum_ghost on Monday July 11, 2022 @01:14AM (#32052487)
>Nobody cares where you graduate from school in engineering.

I have witnessed numerous times hiring managers that would request that HR only sends them resumes from 1-2 target schools, specified by name.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by metadat on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:20AM (#32052160)
> Chances are the company you work for was founded by a Harvard or Stanford grad...

Thankfully not at the moment, but I get your point.

My original point stands- looking at the social network connections, nothing these days is a surprise with regard to general composition.

Is it the best? No, I think it is elitist and pointlessly or harmfully exclusionary. These are fundamental divisions in society, a glass ceiling that is hard to break through.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by Hydraulix989 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:45AM (#32052300)
If Harvard went away, I would be VERY happy. Schools like Tsinghua, IIT, and C9 are much more meritocratic. Oxford / Cambridge are also very "exclusive" in the worst way possible, and given the history of the early US, it's not surprising that this insular Victorian / London culture of poshness also permeated into 17th / 18th century Ivy League schools in the Puritanical US. I'm amazed at what abject conditions Eastern Europeans overcome to earn top international ranks in IOI competitive programming, for example.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by lordnacho on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:44AM (#32052997)
> Oxford / Cambridge are also very "exclusive" in the worst way possible

I went there, and I didn't see anything but ordinary people. Something like Classics will naturally skew towards secondary schools that have a Latin class, but apart from that admissions are close to a dice roll among qualified kids. Certainly the impression I got was that dons were jealously guarding their right to decide, on their own, who would get in.

The place was non-elite enough that I never even realized the Bullingdon Club was a thing until after I left.

As you might expect though, a fairly large proportion of kids came from wealthy backgrounds. Private schools that cost way more than university tuition, that kind of thing.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by meetingthrower on Monday July 11, 2022 @04:49AM (#32053725)
Can confirm. Just went to open days at Oxford and Cambridge with my son. We are Americans. Both my wife and I are double ivy grads.

Totally different than the US and much more meritocratic. Steps are:

1. Be qualified to apply. In UK this means at least AAA if not more. Varies by course. US equivalent is have at least three 5s on AP and above 1450 on SAT. This is roughly equivalent to top 10% of uk graduates.

2. Take the entrance exam. Huge weed out. This really separates the grinders vs the smart kids as the tests are based on what you intend to study, but most are more intelligence based and cannot necessarily be prepped for.

3. Assuming you make it past that, you get two sets of interviews. They are testing for the ability to go toe to toe in an intellectual conversation on your subject. This is obviously biased toward a certain "type", but given the small group tutorial teaching, it is really a responsibility of the student to engage this way to provide a good experience for all. No sitting in the back of the room taking notes!

4. There are some additional crazy things like applying to specific colleges, and wildly different admit rates based on the course you choose. But the overall impression I got was that for a well prepared and smart kid, it is much more straightforward than the so called elite US schools.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by lordnacho on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:18AM (#32053899)
> But the overall impression I got was that for a well prepared and smart kid, it is much more straightforward than the so called elite US schools.

Yes, plus you can skip applying to all the US schools if you get accepted, because you get the acceptance letter in December.

I went to a high school that sent kids to both US and UK universities, and the US ones are incredibly onerous, not to mention expensive to even apply for. Multiple teacher references, essays that are supposed to be some sort of work of art, requirements to do extracurricular stuff. I did the SATs, got the Oxford acceptance, and just dropped all the US stuff entirely.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by meetingthrower on Monday July 11, 2022 @06:25AM (#32054321)
Damn I wish that were still true. They say they issue decisions in January now, which is after application deadlines for everyone else (Jan 1.)
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by ProjectArcturis on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:56AM (#32056989)
>This really separates the grinders vs the smart kids as the tests are based on what you intend to study, but most are more intelligence based and cannot necessarily be prepped for.

Can you expand on that? I would be amazed to find tests that truly measure intelligence and where your score doesn't improve with practice.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by meetingthrower on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:53PM (#32060932)
Sorry posted to the child comment below. It can certainly improve with practice but since these are so specific to each major, there is not a test prep industry geared up behind them. (you can do it on your own though, as they post the tests and most answer keys for prior years.)

https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/applying-to-ox...

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by lordnacho on Monday July 11, 2022 @01:40PM (#32059194)
Not sure I agree with it. I think you get a lot of Asian kids passing because they teach a lot of advanced things in their education system that are just beyond the curriculum in the West. Thus when it comes time to ask the clever questions, some kids already know the answer.

I think in general people who know the answer to something misjudge how hard it is to figure out from first principles.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by meetingthrower on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:51PM (#32060909)
The grinds that can ace the test but can't speak are weeded out by the interview part.

Just look on oxfords website for the admissions test. The TSA test for example is required on top of the math test.

Of course you can train yourself to do these better, but because they are so specific to each major, there is not a test prep industry behind them. So it is a more natural test.

https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/applying-to-ox...

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by lordnacho on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:38PM (#32062259)
There's no separate test prep industry, but private secondary schools will have extra classes for people based on what they intend to apply for. They also prep the kids for the interviews, for instance with mock sessions. That kind of thing is not available to ordinary kids. There's a wealth of Oxbridge application experience that is basically what such schools sell. I'm currently looking at them as a parent.

Isn't this what was depicted in The History Boys? The extra class for kids who wanted to get into Oxford? Can't quite remember.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by meetingthrower on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:52AM (#32065788)
I don't know if you are from US or not, but the stuff over there cannot hold a candle to what happens in the US. I'm not saying it's totally meritocratic, but compared to US system, it is WILDLY more so for high performers.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by lordnacho on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:47PM (#32072567)
I agree on that. There's no back door in the UK system, whereas the US system seems to be a front door with 1% acceptance plus a back door with maybe 40%. Choose your door with money.

In the UK system, even if you do have privilege, you still have to do the same exercises and the same work, and impress the same person to get in.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by brutusborn on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:14AM (#32053209)
Your first point seems paradoxical but I might be misunderstanding. When you said 'dons were jealously guarding their right to decide, on their own, who would get in', are you inferring that although the right to decide is owned by the dons, they are 'ordinary' so there is less selection pressure for people from powerful backgrounds?
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by lordnacho on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:21AM (#32053239)
Basically I got the impression that the Dons/profs would not like if the college master tapped them on the shoulder and said "Little Johnny's dad gave us some money, please let him into your tutorial group".

If you look at how admissions work, it seems reasonably fair: most courses have some sort of entrance test, and then a grilling by the don. There's not a lot of soft questions in those interviews: what's e, let's take the log of a negative number, what's magnetism. Not a lot of cultural fit or motivation questions.

There's also the fact that the dons seem to just have their own set of applicants to look at. My understanding of the US system is you have a whole pile of applicants from which to shape the class as a whole. At Oxford it seemed like your don has 10 applicants and chooses 2 or 3, and that's his class. The rest of the uni does the same and the incoming few thousand kids are just whatever the sum of those little decisions is.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by brutusborn on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:26AM (#32053274)
Ah I get it, the dons are the gatekeepers and they aren't incentivized by donations so meritocracy prevails. Thanks for the detailed reply.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by brutusborn on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:10AM (#32053183)
What does the entrance process for Tsinghua, IIT, and C9 look like? I'm just wondering how they are more meritocratic, do they just have less side-door admissions?
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by tintedfireglass on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:38AM (#32053335)
IIT is pseudo-meritocratic. It's a very rigorous exam and the person who can spend their whole high school time studying phy, Chem and maths and who can spend the most money joining the best coaching institutions and best mentors bacially get the admission. Doesn't matter if someone has an IQ of 200 or India's best football player or coding genius unless they get the highest marks in physics chemistry in maths they aren't allowed. It's technically meritocratic but it is a really flawed system that rewards rigorous practice over skill, interest and other aspects of a student.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by zozbot234 on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:49AM (#32053392)
There's nothing "flawed" about rewarding rigorous practice over irrelevant "skills" like being a good football player or scoring well on an I.Q. test. Sure it might be nice to pick up other meaningful predictors of achievement including e.g. deep interests, but that's very hard to do reliably in any sort of high-stakes situation, and school admissions are no exception.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by tintedfireglass on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:09AM (#32053836)
I think I was biased due to getting my IIT entrance test results today where I did real bad. Now that I read it, it looks like a rant/vent :(
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by ngc248 on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:25AM (#32056588)
lol .... by this definition all college entrance exams are pseudo meritocratic.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by ngc248 on Monday July 11, 2022 @10:37AM (#32056740)
There are no side door admissions basically. You have to write a National level entrance exam and get the best rankings to get into the best universities and departments.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by TrackerFF on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:04AM (#32053811)
Tech has started to absorb more and more Ivy/HYPS kids, many whom would have chosen a more traditional path (consulting/banking) before eventually going to graduate school. I guess the current pay is too good for many to pass out on - even though careers in finance and consulting will pay more, if you manage to climb all the way up.

But I guess it's the more "polished" post-MBA candidates from said schools that go on to become product managers, and eventually become executives.

What school you went to, what your 2-4 first years of work experience was like, and what business school you went to, seems to work pretty well when signaling potential and success - especially when trying to either come up with funding, or convincing some big corporation that you're the man to lead their product XYZ.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by denimnerd42 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:22AM (#32052174)
come on you can't make blanket statements like that. Plenty of my Ivy friends who took the tech path are senior ICs at big tech, startups (not founders), etc. Same as the stanford, caltech, MIT kids.. some are managers now of course.

they're just normal people who happens to be extremely smart and also from wealthy backgrounds. maybe some day they'll be C-suite but they're only mid 30s right now. I would say only a handful have the personality traits for C-suite or founding a company anyway. they're mostly just nerds who went to a top private HS and got perfect SAT scores.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by Hydraulix989 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:30AM (#32052220)
Nope, I worked at two FAANG companies and with not a single Harvard or Stanford graduate. I hosted an intern from Stanford once who received a top of band return offer and rejected it for a "better option." I had one coworker from MIT who admitted he should have gone in finance instead. He later left for a prestigious hedge fund and 7 figure compensation. Most of my coworkers ended up here on H1-B visas from top schools in their home countries, but no network or strong family wealth here in the US. I always joked that Harvard graduates are above putting up with the semi-annual hoop jumping FAANG companies have for "performance reviews."
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by Hydraulix989 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:46AM (#32052306)
Quant trader at a firm that I've never even heard of but routinely pays even engineers 7 figures
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by novok on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:46AM (#32053024)
I've also heard working at such firms has crazy finance hours too, which dissuades me from working there.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by Hydraulix989 on Monday July 11, 2022 @06:41PM (#32063078)
Are you an MIT graduate? I am told the recruiters don't accept job applications, they only reach out to people directly to invite them to apply.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by novok on Monday July 11, 2022 @08:29PM (#32064066)
I'm a mid career staff engineer & manager, and like many I filter out recruiter cold emails.

Plus I wouldn't let that dissuade me from attempting to figure out how to break in if it lead to x2 FANG compensation rates consistently at the same work load.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by grapeskin on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:54AM (#32052354)
> Most of my coworkers ended up here on H1-B visas from top schools in their home countries, but no network or strong family wealth here in the US.

That's an interesting matter on its own. Americans are jumping through 12 stage interviews at a chance for a job and getting ghosted while somehow people from other countries are quickly filling up corporations.

It's also weird that so many people with no local connections and no reason to stay in the country get important roles in tech companies, return home, and data is consistently being leaked or "hacked" through various vulnerabilities obvious to employees.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by slt2021 on Monday July 11, 2022 @01:47AM (#32052664)
it says more about your skill that someone from 3rd world country, whose parents earn $10/mo is more skilled and smart to pass interview.

Keep in mind it is more expensive for company to hire foreigners as there are 12 hoops to bring foreigner in board, they just desperate for any talent that can do the job (at high bar though)

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by grapeskin on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:08AM (#32052764)
Nah. H1B sponsor mills are a well documented issue that the US government has been trying to handle for a while now. These organizations go as far as filing multiple applications so they can more easily push one through. [1] It's nothing to do with "skill level" but everything to do with employers pushing down wages and wanting employees that are easily churned when necessary and kept obedient with the threat of their contract and thus visa and livelihood being cut at any time.

The "Americans just aren't good enough!" excuse hasn't been bought by anybody for years now. It's boring and desperate sounding.

There's nothing wrong with hiring workers from other countries. The H1B system just promotes abuse.

[1] https://content.techgig.com/us-govt-to-end-h1b-visa-abuse-he...

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by novok on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:47AM (#32053034)
WiPro H1B contractor mill staff are very very bad. The other person is probably talking from their non-wipro hiring experience.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by KptMarchewa on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:55AM (#32054130)
You're talking about two different things. Google, Microsoft, other FAAGs's H1Bs are not the same as Infosys or Wipro.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by yellowcake0 on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:44AM (#32052294)
Your coworker from MIT left to be a quant/software engineer at a hedge fund, or was the role non-technical?
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by formerkrogemp on Monday July 11, 2022 @01:50AM (#32052677)
"Normal people" aren't afforded the same opportunity or even half the chances in that just so happens from "being from wealthy backgrounds.". I think that's the issue.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by netr0ute on Monday July 11, 2022 @08:15AM (#32055118)
> If anything, they'll have degrees from worker bee / nerd schools like CMU, Caltech, and UC Berkeley, not Ivy degrees

That's weird, because all those schools you mentioned are ivy leagues in the comparative sense.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by Hydraulix989 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:13PM (#32077866)
No. They are as academically rigorous but not nearly as good for networking or upward mobility
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by wenc on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:47AM (#32052309)
> Guess who private sector loves to promote to executive positions like VP and SVP? Harvard and ivy grads. Even in engineering, where it's supposed to be more of an meritocracy, you can see this at every bigco.

No. This has not been my experience working at bigcos -- the opposite is true. This isn't even hard to disprove -- just take a look at any large company (outside of those with Ivy funnels like management consulting). Just go to their websites. Many executives often did not attend Ivy league colleges.

You'll find that most US executives actually didn't go to prestigious schools. This fact surprised me when I first observed it, but it makes sense. Assuming US management is a meritocracy, those who make it to the top are those who are in some way good with people. Ivies optimize for intellect, but this often has a negative correlation with social skills.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by DocTomoe on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:15AM (#32052796)
Given that many managers/executives are horrid when it comes to people, I think the Peter Principle explains that a lot better: People who can do (and won't get promoted because their productivity is needed where they are). People who can't will get promoted out of the way.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by wenc on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:30AM (#32053301)
I think this take is too cynical. Many executives are by definition good with people -- politics included. There are negative forms of this, but there are also positive forms. I've had really good managers who could work across orgs and manage expectations and drive results. Tech ICs typically don't have this aptitude. Andy Grove's book "High Output Management" explains how good middle management ought to be, and I've experienced it first hand.

The Peter Principle is widely known and modern orgs are designed to account for it (American management is constantly evolving) -- for instance, promotions today are based on personnel already performing at the next level rather than them just showing good results at their current level.

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by metadat on Monday July 11, 2022 @01:33AM (#32052584)
My experience has been in tech, so I don't have information handy for other sectors.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by wenc on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:35AM (#32053325)
Even in tech, the majority of executives don't have Ivy League degrees. Some of them might have MBAs from good schools, but many went to ordinary colleges. I work in tech and in my entire reporting line, there is exactly 1 Ivy league graduate. Tim Cook went to Auburn (MBA at Duke). Satya Nadella went to Manipal Institute of Technology (then UW-Milwaukee, and later an MBA at UChicago Booth).
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by TrackerFF on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:21AM (#32053918)
Had to check up the CEOs of the largest tech companies in the US - looks like the following:

Alphabet - Sundar Pichai (IIT, Stanford, Wharton)

Amazon - Jeff Bezos (Princeton)

Apple - Tim Cook (Auburn, Duke)

Microsoft - Satya Nadella (MIT Manipal, UW–Milwaukee, UChicago)

Meta - Mark Zuckerberg (Harvard - dropped out)

Tesla - Eleon Musk (UPenn / Wharton, Stanford - dropped out)

Nvidia - Jensen Huang (Oregon State, Stanford)

Broadcom - Hock E. Tan (MIT, Harvard)

Oracle - Safra A. Catz (UPenn)

Adobe - Shantanu Narayen (Osmania University, Bowling Green State University, University of California, Berkeley)

Cisco - Chuck Robbins (UNC)

Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by dgb23 on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:56AM (#32054134)
Those are predominantly elite schools right?
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by adamsmith143 on Monday July 11, 2022 @09:59AM (#32056230)
Check Linkedin, it's been a revelation for me. Filter by company and school and you will find hundreds of Ivy League+ types as Upper Level Management. Idk why one would only look at C-suite
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by wenc on Monday July 11, 2022 @12:04PM (#32057961)
Look below C-Suite. There are actually relatively few Ivy League types if you take a larger sample across industries.
Re:People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate acade... by aj7 on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:44AM (#32052996)
It is important to note that schools teach mannerisms and expectation.

The undergrad curriculum in Physics at MIT and a good state school are hardly dissimilar.