News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by ddingus on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:51PM (#32046376)
I DO NOT agree with the other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32046231

deleted! And boy did I have this wrong!! (This comment has been edited to show the text, and where I was in error!)

Here's the text:

ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Fifty-fifth Legislature Second Regular Session House: APPROP DPA 7-5-0-1 HB 2319: law enforcement activity; recording prohibition Sponsor: Representative Kavanagh, LD 23 House Engrossed Overview Outlines regulations for a person making a video recording (recording) of a law enforcement activity (activity). History Provisions

1. States that it is unlawful for a person to knowingly make a recording within eight feet of an activity and without the permission of a law enforcement officer (LEO). (Sec. 1)

2. Directs that for an activity occurring inside a closed structure on private property, a person authorized to be on the private property may make a video recording of the activity from an adjacent room that is less than eight feet away from the activity. (Sec. 1)

3. States a person may not make a video recording of an activity from within eight feet of an activity inside a closed structure on private property if the LEO determines the person is interfering with the activity or that is it not safe to be in the area. (Sec. 1)

4. Provides that a person who is the subject of the police contact may make a recording if doing so does not interfere with lawful police actions. (Sec. 1)

5. Asserts these provisions do not establish a right or authorize any person to make a video recording of an activity. (Sec. 1)

6. Classifies unlawfully recording an activity as a petty offense. (Sec. 1)

7. Classifies failing to comply with LEO verbal warnings regarding recording an activity or if the person has been previously convicted of unlawfully recording an activity as a class 3 misdemeanor (Sec. 1)

  Statute prohibits a person from obstructing governmental operations. A person commits obstructing governmental operations when the person uses threats or violence to hinder a peace officer from enforcing the law or acting under official authority. This offense is classified as a class
 1 misdemeanor (A.R.S. 13-2402).
  8. Defines law enforcement activity. (Sec. 1)
 Prop 105 (45 votes)  Prop 108 (40 votes)  Emergency (40 votes) Initials FK Page 1
 Fiscal Note
HB 2319 House Engrossed

>and without the permission of a law enforcement officer (LEO). (Sec. 1)

That language is not in the stories talking about the bill, and said language is not in line with the First Amendment.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by mlyle on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:17PM (#32046636)
I'm not sure why you think this law explicitly allows people to be 8' away and film. Instead, it criminalizes being closer than 8' and filming, while not superseding other laws that could be used to harass or prevent recording.

An explicit codification of the right to record and circumstances when it applies could be part of a decent compromise here, but this legislation isn't it.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by ddingus on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:17PM (#32047322)
>and without the permission of a law enforcement officer (LEO). (Sec. 1)

I went to the original text, pasted here. That language is NOT OK. This law does NOT explicitly allow.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by gambiting on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:21PM (#32046679)
Because previously, the cop could define their personal "safety zone" as literally whatever - 20ft? 50ft? It wasn't defined in the law. Now it is - it's 8ft. If you're further away than 8ft then it cannot be argued that your filming was unlawful.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by mlyle on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:04PM (#32047162)
This isn't true-- any existing laws that could have been employed at 15' can still be employed at 15'. They have not been superseded or repealed.

There's a new misdemeanor for 8' or less.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by ddingus on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:08PM (#32047223)
I agree with this and had not considered the legislation in this light.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by staticassertion on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:38PM (#32046873)
> This is likely to strengthen the ability for people to document policing.

God I hope this is the stupidest thing I read today.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by ddingus on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:06PM (#32047197)
Well, it might be!

Edit: I put the text of it above. Here's where the ugly is: "and without the permission of a law enforcement officer (LEO). (Sec. 1)"

Yeah, that's not in line with the First Amendment at all.

>The National Press Photographers Association sent a letter to Mr. Kavanagh in February that said the bill violated constitutional free speech and press protections. The New York Times Company was one of more than 20 media organizations that signed the letter, which said that the law would be “unworkable” at protests and demonstrations.

I was thinking about the interactions I see sometimes on YT. Often, SCOTUS saying 10 feet is mentioned. The way I saw this was that often questioned bit of information was made explicit, and 8 feet.

The media appears to take it an entirely different way.

Just to be clear, I am an advocate of recording public officials, including the police of all kinds and perhaps didn't take the language of the bill in the same way many are.