News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by jamiequint on Thursday July 07, 2022 @08:41PM (#32021603)
You can have plenty of friends while believing that not having any kids is a fail, 70% of married couples have kids. Also, most reasonable people don't alienate friends over differing beliefs.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by greenthrow on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:09PM (#32021798)
The person saying someone else's reproductive decisions are a failure is the one alienating people.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by Godel_unicode on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:11PM (#32021809)
That’s their point, though. Calling not having kids a fail is alienating people who have chosen not to (or can’t) have kids.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by matt-attack on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:35PM (#32022375)
Wouldn't alienate me. I have religious friends who call my atheism a "fail". Doesn't both me one bit. Being confident in your believes gives you the ability to weather criticism. Likewise I routinely an upfront with religious friends that I think they believe in made up things, and are wasting their time. It's just a fact that I think that, and it's honest. Again, shouldn't bother well-adjusted religious people. They kinda know that 100% of the earth's population doesn't believe the same things as they do. You kinda get that going in to it.

People should be more open to welcoming differing opinions. No one should have to self-censor their own opinions.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by otterley on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:17PM (#32021854)
It might alienate some atypically sensitive people, but as someone who has no children, I don't feel particularly alienated by it; and I don't think most people who have no kids take particular offense to it either.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by m_mueller on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:44PM (#32022063)
I read it in the context of giving your life to a woman and her company who then marries someone else and has kids. But yeah in hindsight the inclusion of that is not in the best taste, he could be childless for many reasons, none of which should be of public concern.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by Semaphor on Friday July 08, 2022 @01:37AM (#32023690)
How am I atypically sensitive if I don’t want to have anything to do with a person who thinks my beliefs and choices are a failure? That sounds like a recipe for disaster. Instead, I choose to be friends with people who accept me as I am.

ETA: Though I wouldn’t want them to not express it, the opposite.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by otterley on Friday July 08, 2022 @04:37PM (#32026652)
Because most people aren’t so offended by it that they choose to avoid people with such opinions altogether (I’m not talking about not wanting to be friends, but rather, being offended). Such sensitivity is atypical by definition. It’s not intended to be an insult, merely an observation.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by Semaphor on Saturday July 09, 2022 @08:00AM (#32034217)
I mean, as long as you also don’t mind me finding it a failure to have children…

> I’m not talking about not wanting to be friends, but rather, being offended

That’s not what you said, you said alienate.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by Godel_unicode on Friday July 08, 2022 @06:09PM (#32028091)
How can you possibly know that? The hubris of thinking that because you haven’t seen it it’s uncommon on it’s face is truly staggering.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by otterley on Saturday July 09, 2022 @01:07PM (#32037114)
I have seen it. It's still uncommon.

Besides, how does it possibly help you (or anyone else) to get emotionally wounded by some random stranger on the Internet's insensitive comments? Most people older than their 20s have figured this out already and are living more productive lives.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by Semaphor on Friday July 08, 2022 @05:17AM (#32024709)
I wish the people who are apparently extremely easily offended by this would tell me what’s so bad about my opinion.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by carrolldunham on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:28PM (#32021940)
Have you thought about people who want to but can't? And the whole range of factors that might be in play as to why not?
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by throwawaylinux on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:52PM (#32022123)
> Have you thought about people who want to but can't?

Well that's clearly a failure then, isn't it? By definition.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by skissane on Friday July 08, 2022 @07:28AM (#32025715)
Some people use the word failure in a way which – whether by denotation or just connotation – includes an aspect of culpability, blame, fault. If that's your understanding of failure, using it to speak of people in that situation does seem particularly insensitive. On the other hand, maybe other people have a different understanding of the word, in which the element of culpability/blame/fault is either missing, or at least, less emphasised–these people may struggle to understand what others are so upset about, especially if they aren't aware of that difference in the understanding of the word.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by throwawaylinux on Friday July 08, 2022 @08:08AM (#32026092)
If they tried to have kids and were not able to then they failed. There is no "understanding" of the word where that's not true.

And people get upset or offended by anything, it's really not useful trying to shut down discussion by claiming you shouldn't say or think something because allegedly some hypothetical people might get upset.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by skissane on Friday July 08, 2022 @08:24AM (#32026292)
> If they tried to have kids and were not able to then they failed. There is no "understanding" of the word where that's not true.

"They failed" does have some connotation of culpability though, doesn't it? I mean, the phrase certainly is sometimes used in situations where nobody would understand it as implying any blame; but, on the other hand, there are many other cases in which it is used in a blaming way, and those other cases contribute to its connotations.

> And people get upset or offended by anything, it's really not useful trying to shut down discussion by claiming you shouldn't say or think something because allegedly some hypothetical people might get upset.

I'm not trying to shut down anything. I'm just attempting to produce an explanation of why some people, rightly or wrongly, actually are upset (which is rather apparent from other comments on this post.)

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by throwawaylinux on Saturday July 09, 2022 @01:15AM (#32031968)
> "They failed" does have some connotation of culpability though, doesn't it? I mean, the phrase certainly is sometimes used in situations where nobody would understand it as implying any blame; but, on the other hand, there are many other cases in which it is used in a blaming way, and those other cases contribute to its connotations.

It usually does have some, yes. For example if you are infertile through some fault of your reproductive system, then that is to blame for your inability to have children.

> I'm not trying to shut down anything. I'm just attempting to produce an explanation of why some people, rightly or wrongly, actually are upset (which is rather apparent from other comments on this post.)

I think they're just vicariously upset. Either way I wasn't wondering about them. Just correcting a misconception about the use of a word.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by hndamien on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:02PM (#32022183)
The genes would see it as a failure, but they don't really have feelings or motivations, so I'm not sure it makes sense to anthropomorphise them. If we do, it's easy to not take offense, you just have a charitable interpretation and move on with your day.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by s1artibartfast on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:14PM (#32021839)
That hinges on what you mean by fail.

Most reasonable people don't alienate friends over different beliefs, but most people also have some sense of discretion when judging the lives of their friends.

I think I would have issues with a friend who judged me as having failed, or worse, a failure for what I consider personal and subjective life choices.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by phpisthebest on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:35PM (#32021994)
>Most reasonable people don't alienate friends over different beliefs,

like the different belief that not having kids is a fail? Or can you alienate friends over beliefs you disagree with, but not ones you do?

I mean I do not have any kids, but I know many people that believe one of goals of life is to have children, and I am intelligent enough to understand that procreation is evolution's goal

Thus I do not get offended or alienate people from my life if they say me not having kids is a failure

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by s1artibartfast on Friday July 08, 2022 @06:45PM (#32028670)
There is a difference between believing something to be a personal truth and a universal truth.

I don't know if it would irreconcilable, but I think I would have an issue if someone tried to openly judge me and think me a lesser person based on their personal truths.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by phpisthebest on Saturday July 09, 2022 @06:51AM (#32033783)
Well that is getting close to an ongoing trend I see in wider society. I do not need anyone else to approve of my life style. If someone told me a lifestyle choice I made was to them a "failure". I would seek to understand why, evaluate if their logic has any application to my life and if not simply shrug and disgard thier opinion. If I instead it did have value I would see if I wanted to make a change

The fact the people judge other people actions based on their worldview is just a fact of life. Seeking that external validation of ones life choices to me shows insecurities in those choices.

In order have a pluralist society we have to be a to allow people to "think less of us" while still engaging, talking, and transacting with them. If we instead simply reject everyone that does not share our worldview then that is a monoculture, and most likely and dystopian society as well

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by s1artibartfast on Saturday July 09, 2022 @02:13PM (#32037817)
I think you have a very good point with respect to general society and an overly expressed need for validation.

However, we are talking about friends, not strangers. Surely there is some point when the opinions of others should matter.

Would you want a friend, or worse, a spouse that considered you to be a failure, fool, or generally inferior person?

In my belief, healthy and meaningful personal relationships are based on mutual respect. This includes accepting the fact that other people may have different life goals and objectives.

This doesn't need to be absolute, but depending on the magnitude and frequency it can certainly be a irreconcilable difference.

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by phpisthebest on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:51PM (#32047675)
I guess that depends on the context, I do not want a people around me that will just agree with everything I say and do, and in the context here we are talking about a life choice I made (in this case not having children) as a failure... not that I am "failure, fool, or generally inferior person" I think those are different things.

lets change the context to something less divisive, say i was an Alcoholic and my Alcoholism was destroying my life would my "friend" be a friend if they continued to supply me with Whiskey and Beer or would they be a "friend" is they took me to task, told me as I fool, and a failure?

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by s1artibartfast on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:29PM (#32060636)
I think that is a good point. Context and intent matter. Sometimes being a good friend means disagreement.

That said, there is productive and unproductive disagreement. Similarly, there is also transient and permanent disagreement.

There is also the matter of perspective. In the case of the alcoholic friend, there is a difference between viewing it as something that is preventing them from achieving their own goals versus your own personal code. I think the former is a much more compassionate view (and perhaps more productive).

I think this is an interesting example because most people would agree that destroying your life with Alcoholism is a bad thing, so we both share the same bias.

What if you had an alcoholic friend who judged you for not regularly drinking to excess? How does that change the logic in the example?

Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by WalterBright on Friday July 08, 2022 @01:32AM (#32023656)
I wouldn't have any friends if we couldn't have a beer and laugh about our differences.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by anarazel on Friday July 08, 2022 @03:28AM (#32023893)
Considering friends failures seems a bit more than differences. But I'd assume that's more a thing of quickly writing an HN comment than anything else.
Re:Theranos former president found guilty on all fraud counts by WalterBright on Friday July 08, 2022 @04:24AM (#32024340)
You can't succeed without first doing a lot of failing. I didn't say my friends were losers. Losers quit when they fail. Winners get up, learn, and try again. I like to hang out with winners.