I don't know if it would irreconcilable, but I think I would have an issue if someone tried to openly judge me and think me a lesser person based on their personal truths.
The fact the people judge other people actions based on their worldview is just a fact of life. Seeking that external validation of ones life choices to me shows insecurities in those choices.
In order have a pluralist society we have to be a to allow people to "think less of us" while still engaging, talking, and transacting with them. If we instead simply reject everyone that does not share our worldview then that is a monoculture, and most likely and dystopian society as well
However, we are talking about friends, not strangers. Surely there is some point when the opinions of others should matter.
Would you want a friend, or worse, a spouse that considered you to be a failure, fool, or generally inferior person?
In my belief, healthy and meaningful personal relationships are based on mutual respect. This includes accepting the fact that other people may have different life goals and objectives.
This doesn't need to be absolute, but depending on the magnitude and frequency it can certainly be a irreconcilable difference.
lets change the context to something less divisive, say i was an Alcoholic and my Alcoholism was destroying my life would my "friend" be a friend if they continued to supply me with Whiskey and Beer or would they be a "friend" is they took me to task, told me as I fool, and a failure?
That said, there is productive and unproductive disagreement. Similarly, there is also transient and permanent disagreement.
There is also the matter of perspective. In the case of the alcoholic friend, there is a difference between viewing it as something that is preventing them from achieving their own goals versus your own personal code. I think the former is a much more compassionate view (and perhaps more productive).
I think this is an interesting example because most people would agree that destroying your life with Alcoholism is a bad thing, so we both share the same bias.
What if you had an alcoholic friend who judged you for not regularly drinking to excess? How does that change the logic in the example?
like the different belief that not having kids is a fail? Or can you alienate friends over beliefs you disagree with, but not ones you do?
I mean I do not have any kids, but I know many people that believe one of goals of life is to have children, and I am intelligent enough to understand that procreation is evolution's goal
Thus I do not get offended or alienate people from my life if they say me not having kids is a failure