Who's doing the best job in maximizing profit - the gas station selling lots of gas at $2/gal, or the one across the road selling far less at $2.50/gal? (I don't know, but surely one is doing better than the other!).
In other countries where "no reason" returns are not the norm, are stores missing out on profit they could be making by adopting this policy and adjusting prices accordingly, or is it the American stores that have it wrong?
If all stores in unison dropped no-reason returns then there's be no competitive reason to drop prices, but if only one or a few did it then presumably they'd have to (else why pay same price for less flexibility). More to the point, they might WANT to drop prices as a result of this reduced cost-of-goods since that'd be a way to attract more customers, as non-stop "10% off" sales attest.
The error is in neglecting the stores’ competitors selling the widget for a lower price, and customers opting to buy from said competitors.
I don't believe that the world operates under such a system, but in theory it works that way.
Retail is a near perfect example of multiple sellers competing for multiple buyers resulting in razor thin profit margins, which means the buyers are getting what they want at the lowest prices possible.
Retail business do not earn 2-4% profit margins because they want to, they earn them because their customers will go to the store next door if they try to take 5%+.
Have you seen Home Depot's and Lowe's profit margins? Consistently 5-9% for decades. Kroger, Walmart, and target all earn 1-3%. They hardly ever earn 4% nowadays. Perhaps after all of the cashiers and stockers are automated or made redundant. They are all heavily investing in automation, delivery, pickup, and supply chain tech.
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/HD/home-depot/prof...
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/LOW/lowes/profit-m...
The logistics of selling the things Home Depot and Lowes sells is much harder to replicate than Target/Walmart/grocery retail, so the profit margins need to get bigger before a competitor will want to invest in the market due to the higher risks.
The point is competition does cause each other to up their offerings and/or lower prices to maintain market share.
I've heard this before but it always confuses me. Stores always charge the amount such that (price per widget)*(expected number of widgets sold) is maximized.
Put another way - If stores somehow managed to eliminated returns with no other side effects, would you expect the price to drop?