>Your system administrators department is not gonna block any innovative employee initiatives because of the strain maintaining more projects puts on a deployment stack carrying 150 different projects but which was architected to solve a single business goal 15 years ago.
As someone in the “cloud” team at a legacy enterprise I strongly disagree with both of these points.
Cloud networking is as complicated as anything the Cisco people ever did but instead of CCNA you have certifications that barely scratch the surface of the complexity. So you get cloud people who barely understand the platform they’re administering flying by the seats of their pants. And instead of having a networking team to focus on networking the same people trying to figure out static routing across regions in AWS are also the people responsible for migrating EC2 instances from GP2 to GP3 but they were deployed with cloudformation which will replace the instance if your change of the disk type.
So getting to the second point this team will be totally overwhelmed and likely inexperienced so good luck getting them to do anything to help your “innovative” project because right hope they’re too busy trying to figure out how EKS is using up all the IP addresses in us-west-2.
Executives who think they’ll save on money by moving to the cloud are delusional. They’re also delusional if they think it’ll increase stability or resilience. And that’s not even getting into the EMR clusters the “data science” team spun up and left running at $30k/day.
I don't know why I have to explain this every time "data center vs cloud" discussions come up, but if you reduce risks, then you are in effect saving money.
I'm quite sure if you take managing your IT infrastructure as seriously as you take your core business, you can definitely save tons of money by handrolling your infrastructure.
There's also a big difference between doing so 10 years ago versus now, with all the enterprise grade open source solutions to infrastructure challenges.
Try telling a company like Catepillar who manufactures excavating tools to "take IT as seriously as you do making tools"?
> with all the enterprise grade open source solutions to infrastructure challenges
You mean like OpenStack? Have you ever been in a large IT org (non tech company...like a distributing/manufacturing company) that has tried to implement it? and then maintain it? Oof...
And I'm saying you're completely armchairing this analysis because you literally don't know any of these details.
> A company like caterpillar I think should be run almost entirely on no/low code platforms.
Are you suggesting a global manufacturer like Catepillar run it's global financial ledger on a no-code platform? Which implies building the code for it and then maintaining it?
> It seems you're trying to nail down an absolute
In fact, I'm not. The only absolute I'm trying to nail down is "you need to do a buy vs build, rent vs own assessment and make the decision there, neither one is unilaterally true without that assessment". Anyone trying to speculate about budgets in the $100M+ space is just heresay.
And exchange it with dependability risks
> you're not getting strangled by any Oracle contracts
Unless you go to the Oracle cloud
> Your system administrators department is not gonna block any innovative employee initiatives
They're still there, aren't they?
If you go to the cloud you don't need to fire anyone for choosing IBM, you're not getting strangled by any Oracle contracts, you're not gonna lose all your data because of security holes in your use of Microsoft products.
You're also not going to be dealing with downtime because you couldn't find staff talented off to properly configure your Cisco networking equipment.
Your system administrators department is not gonna block any innovative employee initiatives because of the strain maintaining more projects puts on a deployment stack carrying 150 different projects but which was architected to solve a single business goal 15 years ago.
Imagine being a 67 yr old manager who just wants to be in the business of getting letters printed on tree pulp from Bumfuck, Idaho delivered to Louisville, Alabama reasonably effectively. Knowing nothing about computers or information technology, imagine the insane stack of perfect decisions that have to be made to get the IT infrastructure of a company like FedEX running.
Not saying going to the cloud is the best decision. Not even saying it's the decision I would make. But it does sound very enticing to just have all of those problems go away by throwing a couple hundred million dollars a year at Google, Microsoft or Amazon (btw lol if they go with Oracle or IBM instead).