News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Can competitors catch up to Apple Silicon? by JohnHaugeland on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:07AM (#31976609)
Apple fans sure love pretending other chips are as slow as they are

> The Apple M1 Ultra SoC chip achieves 87% of the performance of the Intel 12900K and Nvidia RTX 3090

Benchmarks not run by Apple do not support this claim

In reality it is not competitive with chips five years old

Re:Ask HN: Can competitors catch up to Apple Silicon? by defactoPun on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:12AM (#31976643)
Well, I dont think there's need for a personal attack here. Even though they might not be 87% faster, they are still quite significantly faster for an ultrabook and they do deliver the battery life. So I guess the OP's question can be taken as, could intel or amd or OEMs achieve the performance to power ration soon ?
Re:Ask HN: Can competitors catch up to Apple Silicon? by JohnHaugeland on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:20PM (#31983323)
> Well, I dont think there's need for a personal attack here.

Correctly observing that someone is making false claims due to their allegiance to a brand name is not a personal attack.

.

> they are still quite significantly faster for an ultrabook

The benchmarks do not support this claim.

.

> and they do deliver the battery life.

Tom's hardware has them at 14 hours, the Surface Laptop at 17. Tom's hardware also says the Surface Laptop is faster. There are Lenovos with 35 hour battery life.

14 hours is pretty standard. The flagships of HP, Dell, Lenovo, and MSI also all do 15-17 hours. Apple's actually slightly behind the pack here.

Please note that battery life and CPU power are inversely correlated; you'll never find a laptop that's good with both, and if someone's telling you they have, they're lying to you

It's like saying that the car that delivers the most horsepower also uses the least gas. No, it doesn't, and you should know that.

In reality, these are both average middle of the road machines. They aren't particularly powerful when compared to one of MSI's beasts, and they aren't particularly battery lived when compared to one of those glorified tablets you can get.

.

> could intel or amd or OEMs achieve the performance to power ration soon ?

They did five years ago, according to the measurements and evidence.

I have never shopped for laptops according to their "performance power ratio."

Re:Ask HN: Can competitors catch up to Apple Silicon? by stefanfisk on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:29PM (#31983374)
What are your sources for these claims? A quick googling led me to https://www.tomsguide.com/face-off/microsoft-surface-laptop-..., and there they clearly state that the MBP has both better battery life and performance.
Re:Ask HN: Can competitors catch up to Apple Silicon? by JohnHaugeland on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:45AM (#31989640)
That is the Surface Laptop Studio, a different computer than the one that I named
Re:Ask HN: Can competitors catch up to Apple Silicon? by stefanfisk on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:43AM (#31997154)
Do you have any links to the articles that you are referring to?
Re:Ask HN: Can competitors catch up to Apple Silicon? by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:25AM (#31976761)
This is precisely the right reformulation of the actual question.

Apple's competitors are already ahead of of Apple in terms of pure performance. "Catching up" is only a thing if you care about the performance/power ratio.

Re:Ask HN: Can competitors catch up to Apple Silicon? by jmiskovic on Monday July 04, 2022 @01:17PM (#31979475)
Yes, but the performance/power is extremely important for laptops. As a long time Linux user I'm seriously considering migrating to Mac just for the laptop staying cool and silent after hours operating on battery.