News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by InclinedPlane on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:49PM (#3197020)
If you need to pump out a high volume of moderately creative trash, then working in factory conditions makes sense.

If you need to foster actual creativity, if you have a desire to build things that touch people's lives and that people will talk about and be inspired from then perhaps less so.

The caveat that real artists ship is still in effect of course.

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by TomOfTTB on Friday November 04, 2011 @02:32PM (#3197178)
I don't buy that at all. It's impossible to look at the success The Richards Group has had and conclude it's all "moderately creative trash". More to the point it's insulting to the people who did that work.

If there's a lesson here for the HN community I think it's that there's more than one way to do things. You bristle at the idea of punching a clock and accounting for your time in 15 minute increments. So you shouldn't work there.

At the same time there are surely creative people out there who bristle at the idea of working through the night or on weekends. To those people a workplace that closes at 6pm and enforces a no-work policy after that would be appealing.

The beauty of this article is it tells us both ways work. So people who want to close down at 6pm can start a company and draw other like minded people to them. While people with no interest in that lifestyle can stay away

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by JoeAltmaier on Friday November 04, 2011 @05:50PM (#3197848)
All ads are trash. They do not aspire to art - only to hook the viewer with a few seconds of nonsense. Ad people are perfectly aware of this.

Just compare any ad with, for instance, Shindler's List. or Blade Runner. One has a single, cute, memorable tagline. The other is a monumental effort of style, atmosphere, meaning.

If you don't trivialize art to mean "anything pretty", then of course advertisements aren't art.

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by blankenship on Friday November 04, 2011 @06:31PM (#3197957)
They're not art (typically) they're design—they exist to solve a problem. They're not all trash, sometimes they're rather brilliant solutions to selling a product or service or experience (of course they're still selling).

Don't fall into the Is Not For Me = Trash line of thinking. It's intellectually lazy.

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by JoeAltmaier on Friday November 04, 2011 @11:28PM (#3198808)
Hm. Trash has a dozen meanings. I guess I would say, its trash in the use-once, disposable sense. Nobody thinks their ad is going to be timeless.
Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by Vandy_Travis on Saturday November 05, 2011 @12:57AM (#3198976)
I 100% agree, when you're talking about the ads that are aired a hundred times a day on syndicated television. Then again, the shows are terrible, so I suppose it's fitting that the ads match.

However, what about Apple's 1984 ad? Or the BMW mini-movie advertisements they ran about 6 years ago?

There are some incredibly cool concept ads out there. They usually are not the ones broadcast, but if you watch the end of the year awards for the industry, there are some very creative minds working there. (And creating some impressive work).

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by mmcdan on Friday November 04, 2011 @10:46PM (#3198692)
Although this is an "ad" for wearing a seatbelt, I still watch it occasionally because it is so artistic: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-8PBx7isoM
Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by TomOfTTB on Friday November 04, 2011 @08:25PM (#3198352)
To say Art isn't Art unless it's the highest form of art is silly. Is the work of a great comic book artist not art because it isn't Picasso?
Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by JoeAltmaier on Friday November 04, 2011 @11:24PM (#3198798)
A comic book is so far above an ad as to make the comparison silly.
Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by dissident on Saturday November 05, 2011 @12:31AM (#3198936)
That's absurd. Just because the motive of the advertisement is to sell you an idea, doesn't mean it isn't done creatively and artistically. In fact, advertisements tend to be most effective when they are extremely artistic and unique.

Art is supposed to be emotionally engaging. What does a comic book do better?

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 09, 2011 @08:15AM (#3215336)
A comic book has a theme, a moral, characters, continuity.

An ad has "Buy this car! Buy this car! Buy this car!"

I deny ads work better when artistic. True, you remember them better. But often I totally miss what the product was, which makes them score Zero on the ad-o-meter. Do you remember the product for those 'artistic' Apple ads? Not good enough to say "some Apple thingy".

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by InclinedPlane on Saturday November 05, 2011 @01:20AM (#3199016)
Perhaps "trash" is going too far, even so I find it offensive that someone would put forward the notion that a work environment that is suitable for producing mildly creative advertisements should be the universal model for all creative work.

Advertisements are perhaps the shortest lived, least substantive, and least impactful creative works.

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by regularfry on Sunday November 06, 2011 @09:36AM (#3202730)
Bad adverts are non-substantive and lacking in impact. Good adverts have perhaps the most impact of any medium in existence.
Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by jfarmer on Friday November 04, 2011 @02:48PM (#3197238)
When it comes to producing amazing work, quantity beats quality.

That is, it's better to produce 100 things and throw away 99 than it is to sit around a perfect 1. In the end the quality will be higher.

http://russelldavies.typepad.com/planning/2007/02/quantity_e...

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by kitsune_ on Friday November 04, 2011 @08:26PM (#3198355)
I don't buy into this. I've been producing music for over 10 years now. The "snippet" and fire and forget approach doesn't work. I'm sitting on thousands of different loops, demos, half-finished songs, and so on.

Over the course of of a session, when you're jamming with your synthesizers and instruments, a project can transform from A to B to C to D to E where E ends up sounding nothing like A. You have your hard- and software synths, fantastic effect plugins and hardware, drum machines, more outboard gear. You tweak and compress, change melodies and harmonies. You press 'save as a new version' every minute.

Your wandering mind be damned, if you want a great track you need to stop, sit down, and focus. All good tracks I come up with come from a focus on quality, not quantity. By the way, in my opinion, iterative refinements do not belong into the category of "quantity", I don't know how anyone could make such a statement.

Of course you sometimes need the sessions to come up with some idea that resonates with you, but after that you (read: I, I'm talking about my own experience) have to force yourself to focus.

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by skb_ on Friday November 04, 2011 @09:15PM (#3198488)
My own work-flow is kind of a mixture of the two. I find that I have to play around with my synths a bit just to find that right sound - it might not be the right sound for the current project, but I save it just in case. Same thing with melodies, I have a ton of files with unfinished melodies that I mine ideas from.

My best work is actually a culmination of these "snippets" that I build up over a few months/weeks. It's like with each mediocre/average project I produce, I'm discovering the parts of the great one not too far off.

It's the same thing with code, design and all my other creative projects. I have to wade through a lot of weaker ideas and designs in order to discover the best parts. And once I figure those out, it's mostly a rewrite of all my past ideas into the one good idea.

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by r00fus on Friday November 04, 2011 @02:55PM (#3197272)
Absolutely this. The trick is to getting where people see you deliver that one out of a hundred, and assume that your quality beats others' quantity.

How are Jobs' keynotes so well delivered? Repetition, iteration, practice, just like martial arts, makes perfect.

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by stdbrouw on Friday November 04, 2011 @05:59PM (#3197872)
Doing the same thing a hundred times until you've got it down isn't the same as doing a hundred different things and picking the best effort, though.
Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by InclinedPlane on Saturday November 05, 2011 @02:05AM (#3199091)
This is how you build skill and artisanship but that's not the sum total of art. Is James Patterson the best writer of our age? He wrote 10 novels just in 2011 alone.

Shockingly there's more to art than a trite truism. If you want to acquire skill, go for quantity. But after that, if you want to become a master, if you want to impact people's lives in a way they appreciate and care about you'll need more than skill, you'll need inspiration.

Re: Creativity doesn't need a muse. It needs a drill sergeant. by nickpinkston on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:53PM (#3197030)
Re: Real Artists Ship

I was expecting them to talk more about getting people structure to get them shipping more and challenging themselves - a la Jobs'. Instead, it really did feel like that place was a soul-grinder. The guy they interviewed didn't even work there anymore - telling...