News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wayland is not ready as a 1:1 compatible Xorg replacement... by wmf on Friday July 01, 2022 @12:14AM (#31942280)
The fact there was no default widget kit is the big one for me.

This wouldn't have worked. Different DEs will never ever ever agree on a common toolkit. If Wayland had a single official toolkit that means that today one DE (probably GNOME) would be using Wayland and every other DE would still be on Xorg (which is unmaintained).

The movement from "window manager" to "compositor" is a huge scope creep.

It's not. It's actually simpler and more reliable to implement window management inside the display server than using a separate process.

I wonder if it would have made more sense to go with a paired approach-- a single master compositor implementation, with the complicated and more hardware-sensitive stuff involved, and a pluggable window manager that spoke to it.

Agreed. Wayland probably could have done a better job of putting 99% of the code in libweston so that different compositors would only have to reimplement 1%.

Re:Wayland is not ready as a 1:1 compatible Xorg replacement... by kaba0 on Friday July 01, 2022 @04:39AM (#31943865)
> Agreed. Wayland probably could have done a better job of putting 99% of the code in libweston so that different compositors would only have to reimplement 1%.

But at the same time that was meant as reference implementation, prone to quick changes and no promise of backwards compatibility. It could hinder their initial progress instead.

Wlroots is exactly that and has been available for quite some years now (with many niche wms building on it)