Re:Ask HN: Where have all the forums gone?
by NoSorryCannot on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:32AM
(#31933915)
Google will choose shoddily-generated blogspam of no use to anyone and I will append "reddit" to my query, doubly ruling out small forums.
Re:Ask HN: Where have all the forums gone?
by weird-eye-issue on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:08PM
(#31935464)
Reddit is one of the forums I was referring to in my comment. It's very easy to outrank because as it turns out it provides a poor UX and has a lot of noise.
But yes I too sometimes search out reddit results if I'm looking for different opinions for example
It's because the content is usually shorter and less in-depth than a blog post. It will also contain unhelpful posts mixed in with helpful posts so the user experience is not always great
Imagine a question followed by 1kb of HTML containing a username, avatar, signature etc just to contain the words "I'm also having this problem" or a meme. Sure 20kb of HTML later maybe somebody gave a helpful reply but it's just noise. Now compare that to a properly crafted blog post. What do you think Google will choose?