News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by bb88 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @04:46PM (#31912796)
I feel conflicted on this.

> It makes the gun owner a lucrative target.

I mean, on one side they're saying that owning guns is necessary to protect their property. But now they're saying that owning guns makes them a target for crime? To me it seems like they're trying to have it both ways on this.

> Criminals get guns through burgling and robbery.

Private transactions are still legal. The gun show loophole is still around. Buying a gun and gifting it is legal.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by jakebasile on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @04:58PM (#31912917)
Having a gun allows you to protect your life and property with force. Owning valuable property like guns can make you more of a target. It is ideal not to have the ownership of that property broadcasted. The vast majority of gun owners hope never to have to use their weapon except to put holes in paper from a distance.

The "gun show loophole" doesn't exist. It is still a crime for a prohibited person to possess a firearm no matter how they get it. In many states including California, it is illegal for a private sale to occur without a background check. Somehow, many prohibited persons still acquire them, and their info wasn't just leaked by the California AG.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by wyager on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @04:50PM (#31912837)
> But now they're saying that owning guns makes them a target for crime?

They're saying that the government leaking their personal information makes them a target for crime. Is this comment a joke? I'm having trouble believing that anyone could seriously view this as somehow indicating that gun owners are hypocritical. I guarantee you that no gun owners wanted California to track and subsequently leak their personal details. If you're being serious, this is some of the (unintentionally) funniest sophistry I've seen in a while.

> Private transactions are still legal.

If you can't legally buy a gun at a store, you can't legally buy a gun privately.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by jasonladuke0311 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @06:14PM (#31913775)
> If you're being serious, this is some of the (unintentionally) funniest sophistry I've seen in a while.

Almost without exception, every discussion with anti-gun advocates is predicated on this kind of attitude, in concert with an astonishing ignorance of the subject they wish to further regulate.

Kind of like conservative men and their beliefs on women's reproductive rights.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by hgsgm on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:28AM (#31916506)
Difference of course being that a fetus can't be used to kill anyone except the womb owner.
Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by chmod600 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @06:38PM (#31913994)
Generally you don't want to give more information to potential attackers.

The reason is because it allows improved matchmaking of criminals and victims, and allows criminals to improve the efficiency of their crimes. A criminal that's looking for guns could go outside your house, wait until you leave, then rob you looking for the guns and getting out quickly (with a fence ready to buy them). A criminal looking for something else could see that you're not on the list, break in with their gun while you are home, and do who-knows-what to you.

Sure, there are exceptions. Maybe you want a "beware of dog" sign or a "closed-circuit camera" notice that might push the criminals to keep looking for their next victim. These notices are best to prevent crimes of opportunity, and probably better posted on the house than in a leaked database online.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by seadan83 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @05:20PM (#31913155)
> They're saying that the government leaking their personal information makes them a target for crime

Why is this? Are we talking about burglars who want the valuable guns? That does seem odd as the number two deterrent to burglary is knowledge that the home-owner has a gun (the number on apparently are large dogs).

If the above is the case, the idea is that a burglar will scan this list for nearby homes and target them? On the basis that they have a gun alone (which again, is the number two deterrent to burglary). Plus, there is a lot of precedent that it takes almost nothing to use deadly force against an intruder and have zero consequences.

> I guarantee you that no gun owners wanted California to track and subsequently leak their personal details.

I'm guessing that California gun owners are perhaps amongst those who particularly do not want their personal details leaked. There are all sorts of reasons to not want that for anyone. This argument though of "we're now bigger targets for crime", when they have guns to "prevent" that crime, I can't reconcile that. So is the gun a deterrent, or not?

I can think of a lot of other things that would make someone the target for burglary, like having a 4 car garage and gated fence.

> If you can't legally buy a gun at a store, you can't legally buy a gun privately.

While that is the case, if there is no obligation to run a background check (gun-show loophole) - then how do you prevent these people from purchasing guns?

The loophole is not that it's legal or illegal, the loophole is that someone is obtaining a gun that shouldn't.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by ruste on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @08:10PM (#31914804)
The reason guns are the number two deterrent behind dogs is because the overwhelming majority of burglaries generally, and in particular, for the purpose of theft, happen when the homeowner is gone. A gun won't operate itself, but people often leave their dogs home alone.

Given this context, the fear that those looking for guns would use this information to target a relative minority that have them becomes much more plausible.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by seadan83 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:23PM (#31937283)
The guns are supposed to be locked up in a safe, right?

So, the fear is that burglars would actively mine this data, go to the physical location, wait and ensure nobody is home, then break in? All that compared to say doing the same for someone that has an expensive car in their drive way?

How would the burglars feel about travelling to that neighborhood to first case it? Would you go a few dozen miles to first just find out if there are security cameras, neighborhood watch, etc..?

I think this speaks to a sufficiently motivated burglar. Would this list be the different for that motivated burglar to target someone on that list, compared to any other target? For that motivated burglar, was this leak really the difference in who they target?

Thinking through this scenario concretely, it seems like there are plenty of other actual dangers to worry about.

It makes me think that this side of the coin is just high-pitched whining (my opinion),vs a very legitimate complaint regarding data breaches.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by txsoftwaredev on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @05:27PM (#31913232)
What is a gun show loophole? To purchase a firearm at a gun show you must go through a background check.
Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by alkaloid on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @05:52PM (#31913518)
In Texas private sellers can rent a booth at a gun show and sell without performing a NICS check.

https://www.thoughtco.com/gun-show-laws-by-state-721345

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by txsoftwaredev on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @06:05PM (#31913686)
And the laws still apply to them. They are not allowed to sell to anyone not allowed to legally own a firearm, e.g. under 18, felon, out of state. If they do they are committing a crime.

And they will need an FFL if they make a business of selling privately.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by tomatotomato37 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @07:02PM (#31914220)
The law also says they need to file taxes on that purchase, but what is required and what people actually do often differs
Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by Clubber on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:58PM (#31916331)
>The law also says they need to file taxes on that purchase, but what is required and what people actually do often differs

I think you inadvertently hit on why people are opposed to further gun regulation. The people committing the crimes aren't gonna follow the law and it stands to only further burden regular citizens.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by hgsgm on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:27AM (#31916500)
There is more than one kind of regulation. Regulating people with an incentive to obey (professionals running businesses, like stores or shows) makes it harder for criminals to obtain guns they aren't allowed to possess.
Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by Clubber on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:00AM (#31920202)
>Regulating people with an incentive to obey (professionals running businesses, like stores or shows) makes it harder for criminals to obtain guns they aren't allowed to possess.

Can you give me an example of how this would work?

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by Rebelgecko on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:52PM (#31915541)
Just to clarify, private sellers couldn't perform a NICS check even if they wanted to. There were some proposals to open the system up to regular people (kind of akin to my understanding of how Switzerland does BG checks), but they never passed.

Anyways, it's kind of a moot point in California because that's a felony here.

Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by txsoftwaredev on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @12:15PM (#31922222)
A private seller can utilize a NICS check with an FFL if they choose. It's up to the private seller.
Re:Gun owners’ private information leaked by California Atto... by Rebelgecko on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @06:00PM (#31926220)
The fees from that are rather exorbitant. At least around me, most FFLs charge $100-$200 since they'd rather you buy from them directly (except for PPT transfers, where the cost is legally capped at like $50). IMO people should be able to run BG checks at cost.