I don't think it's inherently unhealthy. I was giving that point to the top commenter as to make my point about the relative merit.
Ok, then that's your answer. The argument for "none of the above" is because some people (which I'd include myself) would say that all branding is unhealthy, and that there is no "relative merit" to any of it.
If you do think that it is unhealthy and you can avoid it altogether, why still debate the relative merits of one vs the other?