News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by ALittleLight on Monday June 27, 2022 @01:30AM (#31890893)
I am extremely concerned that the Monkeypox outbreak seems to be growing. I don't get why, unless we do some intervention, the growth would stop. Why is it spreading in multiple countries? Why now?

COVID confirmed for me our pandemic leadership is braindead at best and actively malicious at worst. I have very little confidence they know what they're doing here or would handle Monkeypox if it turns out to be a significant problem.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by dillondoyle on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:45AM (#31891342)
MSM (men who have sex with me) mostly right now. Seems like it's just a new STD, but perhaps someone has reading/research showing it's spreading at any significant scale further than that.

Hopefully we handle it better than we did HIV

Also it's pride right now sooo... Just like Chinese New Year couldn't have picked a more opportune time.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by jpster on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:24AM (#31893539)
> MSM (men who have sex with men) mostly right now.

“…as far as we can tell”. How do we know if we’re not testing enough and have no concept of the actual scale of the outbreak?

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by cplusplusfellow on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:40AM (#31893729)
Is this another virus that you can contract but never know you have it?
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by prirun on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:01AM (#31893968)
Or like shingles, where the virus lies dormant for years and then activates if the host's immune system gets weak enough, either from age or some other cause. This would make it very hard to trace the initial exposure.
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by foldr on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:51AM (#31891735)
>Seems like it's just a new STD

There’s no evidence that the mode of transmission of this variant is specifically sexual. Monkeypox in general can be spread by close contact (such as e.g. holding hands, sharing bedsheets, …).

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by tjs8rj on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:24AM (#31891914)
Not to be all conspiratorial but I noticed my gut reaction to this statement was “I wonder how much of that from WHO/CDC is stretching the truth to prevent stigma”.

The CDC really did a real number on its own credibility by showing itself to willfully stray from reasonable public health strategies in order to push political agendas. I wonder how much more monkeypox will spread above what it otherwise would do to this same politics over health approach that puts “prevent stigmatization” over “save lives”

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by londons_explore on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:47AM (#31892040)
They need to just publish figures... "Of 150 analyzed transmissions, XX were from sexual activities, YY were from family interaction or shared living space, ZZ were unidentified"
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by foldr on Monday June 27, 2022 @05:10AM (#31892190)
I don't see how this would work, as people generally don't know how they got Monkeypox. Even if you somehow know that a sexual encounter was the cause of transmission, it doesn't follow that transmission occurred through a specifically sexual route (rather than just general close physical contact).

If such figures aren't being published, it isn't because of a conspiracy – it's just because no-one knows.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by londons_explore on Monday June 27, 2022 @05:26AM (#31892302)
It seems a survey could build a pretty conclusive picture, especially while case numbers are low... You'd identify places where someone interacted with a previously infected person.

You'd then send them a survey with questions like "how many hours were you in the same room as this person", "did you touch their bedding", "did you have sex", "which days, how many times, what type of sex?" etc.

Using those results together with information about whether each contact got infected or not you should be able to get a good indication of the causes of transmission. More importantly you can probably also find what does not cause transmission, allowing those to be eliminated from public health guidance.

I think the main limiting factor for such a survey will be people being dishonest on the survey. It only takes a few people to say "nah we just talked and didn't have sex" (when in fact they did, and got infected), and suddenly the survey results cause incorrect health guidance to be issued, putting others at risk.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by foldr on Monday June 27, 2022 @05:38AM (#31892378)
Leaving aside all the usual difficulties with collecting data of that kind, it’s worth noting that such a procedure only has a hope of producing reliable results if:

* The majority if cases of Monkeypox are both symptomatic and reported.

* The majority of transmissions occur by contact between people who know each other personally (rather than e.g. brushing up against each other in a tube carriage).

* It is possible to share names and other details in a way that respects people’s privacy. (On the face of it, sending out surveys saying 'Sam Jones had Monkeypox, did you kiss them last week?' is just unlawful.)

We may eventually get reliable information about the main vectors for the current outbreak. At present, we haven’t. No-one is hiding anything. We just don’t know because it’s difficult to find out.

edit: Also note the following from the article:

>For many of the confirmed cases, health officials don't know how the person caught the virus. Those infected haven't traveled or come into contact with another infected person. That means the virus is spreading in some communities and cities, cryptically.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by foldr on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:43AM (#31892012)
I think you are being a bit conspiratorial. Monkeypox isn't a new disease and we know that it can transmit through non-sexual means. I have seen no evidence that the variant of Monkeypox responsible for the current outbreak is any different in this respect. If you know of any evidence to the contrary then by all means link to it.
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by makomk on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:22AM (#31893525)
Monkeypox can transmit through non-sexual means, but it transmits poorly enough amongst humans that way that those routes of transmission cannot explain the current outbreak. I think there's other hints that this is the cause too, such as the actual sites of the infection and most of the spread so far being amongst the more sexually promiscuous parts of the gay male community...

This is even kind of hinted at in the article. The symptoms people are presenting with are different from classic monkeypox outbreaks, and as far as anyone can tell the actual disease hasn't changed and this is all due to the route of transmission.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by foldr on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:10AM (#31894078)
> but it transmits poorly enough amongst humans that way that those routes of transmission cannot explain the current outbreak.

Previous Monkeypox outbreaks have not been linked primarily to sexual transmission. It may be that the initial cluster of the current outbreak is caused by people meeting up for sex (although really, who knows?), but given what we already know about the disease, it would be unwise to jump to the conclusion that sex itself is necessary for efficient transmission.

If there's really a consensus among experts that sexual transmission (rather than just transmission via contact during sex) is playing a key role here, then by all means reference this. I've been unable to find anything of the sort.

>most of the spread so far being amongst the more sexually promiscuous parts of the gay male community...

Here you're moving away from informed speculation (which is already unwise at this early stage, in my opinion) and simply repeating sensationalist nonsense from less reputable sections of the news media. There is absolutely no reliable data on how 'promiscuous' the people who have been infected so far are.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by Jeema101 on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:26AM (#31895016)
The WHO's assessment does seem to suggest that it may be sexually transmitted but doesn't explicitly state it. Here's what they state:

"The clinical presentation is often atypical, with few lesions localized to the genital, perineal/perianal or peri-oral area that do not spread further, and an asynchronous rash that appears prior to the development of a prodromal phase (i.e. lymphadenopathy, fever, malaise)." [1]

[1] https://www.who.int/news/item/25-06-2022-meeting-of-the-inte...

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by foldr on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:30AM (#31895075)
It may be. I am not saying the possibility can be ruled out, only that we don't know at present. The WHO doesn't explicitly state that it's sexually transmitted because they don't know that it is, and neither does anyone else.

For example, the 'atypicality' of the presentation could simply be a consequence of MSM who are used to getting sexual health checkups being more comfortable with showing their genital sores to a doctor or nurse than other population groups.

I'm not sure if the presence of genital lesions is necessarily even a good indicator that transmission was via sex. See e.g. https://academic.oup.com/ofid/article/4/4/ofx168/4588539

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by GekkePrutser on Monday June 27, 2022 @06:47AM (#31892755)
I think what's causing the heaviness in sexual transmission is that the hands simply are a much easier spot to detect sores etc. The carrier will know they have them and people they meet will see them before shaking hands.

And the nether skin folds also tend to have more skin conditions due to the lack of natural ventilation. And sex is often practiced in poorly lit environments at moments when people are not super observant..

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by dillondoyle on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:30PM (#31899593)
Maybe STD isn't the right term. Intimate contact spread? IDK what else to call it. but the trend is pretty clear.

On the same hand it seems pretty unlikely that bedsheets are causing more infections than sex or hookups. Though the two are closely related ;)

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by foldr on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:59PM (#31899968)
The distinction is important, because many on the right are suggesting that ‘gay sex’ specifically is the transmission vector. This given that at present we don’t even really know that sex of any kind is the major transmission vector.

I don’t see any terminological difficulty here. You can easily catch a cold from someone by having sex with them, but no-one suggests that colds are STDs.

The ‘trend’ also has to be viewed against a background of underdiagnosis and limited testing. It may simply be that gay men are more likely to end up getting tested for Monkeypox.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by sterlind on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:39AM (#31891652)
monkeypox is far less dangerous than HIV, as well as acute rather than an insidiously slow burn. and we have a vaccine for it, which we've already stockpiled.

also you have a hilarious typo. you must be quite the stud!

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by treeman79 on Monday June 27, 2022 @07:31AM (#31893093)
HIV was an absolute death sentence when I was growing up.
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by ginja on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:13AM (#31891497)
>men who have sex with me

Please start practicing abstinence before you get everyone sick, you sexy bastard!

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by feet on Monday June 27, 2022 @07:15AM (#31892961)
Mans out here hoggin all the booty
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by dillondoyle on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:29PM (#31899583)
Lol but it's pride!!!!
[dead]
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by dillondoyle on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#31899571)
Lol I don't think I'm patient zero. Trying to give benefit of doubt given the forum, but man that sounds not so great...

Can't deny it's not spreading in this community. quickly.

Sure we get tested far more and that contributes to the reporting for sure.

But symptomatic patients very clear to know if infected and easy to diagnose.

Question is how much is not obviously symptomatic.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by foldr on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:05PM (#31900047)
> But symptomatic patients very clear to know if infected and easy to diagnose.

The article explains that it is not in fact easy to diagnose at present. (“Eventually, after seeing more than four doctors, the man finally finds an activist who's trying to expand testing. The activist connects the man with a doctor who orders a test through a private company (that's working to produce a commercial test.) The result: He's positive. He has monkeypox.”)

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by mos_basik on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:11PM (#31900130)
>benefit of the doubt

Ah, he was making a joke about a typo you made. Not an attack.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by dillondoyle on Monday June 27, 2022 @05:30PM (#31901093)
ha! just saw that. can't edit now will live forever! And I wish....
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by uoaei on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:08AM (#31891126)
The excuse I've heard is, the R0 is low enough that we are not at risk of pandemic per se. I'm not so sure about the likelihood of reaching epidemic status or similar.
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by cameldrv on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:24AM (#31891227)
Daily cases are doubling every 12 days or so. Now maybe that won’t hold up in the general population, but it’s thousands of people already. I’m very disappointed to not see a anything approaching a robust response given what we’ve gone through the past two years.
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by tidenly on Monday June 27, 2022 @02:50AM (#31891367)
My guess is that it doesn't mutate as quickly as a corona virus - so our body can build a defense against it rather easily without high chances of re-infection, just like most other poxes. It basically is quite slow moving, and will burn through its fuel in the major population centers quickly if it does peak - unlike corona which can just keep peaking after it mutates using the same people.
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by mensetmanusman on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:51AM (#31893868)
Which language do you think should be illegal in the article?
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by wronglyprepaid on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:52AM (#31893888)
I'm not interested in repeating it, I don't want to cause further violence against marginalized communities. Enough people have already quoted it from the article in the comments.

And maybe ask yourself, why would a social construct have any impact on a disease?

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by mensetmanusman on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:07AM (#31894042)
Social constructs or Memes can manifest real behavior changes.

Think of the TikTok teens who are twitching: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/tiktok-causing-tics-in-te...

I wouldn’t be surprised if social constructs had impacts on rates of spread in this context.

[dead]
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by ALittleLight on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:36AM (#31894417)
That seems like an absurd claim. The public health institutions in the US have an abysmal track record for accuracy and also knowingly lied to the public - e.g. advising against masks at the outset because they wanted to preserve their mask supply.

Saying that public health institutions should be illegal to criticize is such an extremely myopic, cowardly, and sycophantic view I previously wouldn't have thought anyone actually believed it.

Finally, just for fun, there's a significant possibility the US public health institute bear responsibility for the pandemic itself - to the extent they funded gain of function research and the Wuhan Institute where COVID possibly (likely?) escaped.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by wronglyprepaid on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:39AM (#31894459)
> The public health institutions in the US have an abysmal track record for accuracy and also knowingly lied to the public - e.g. advising against masks at the outset because they wanted to preserve their mask supply.

Their track record is flawless, they are just maligned by the right wing media. They stopped COVID-19 and saved millions of lives.

> Finally, just for fun, there's a significant possibility the US public health institute bear responsibility for the pandemic itself - to the extent they funded gain of function research and the Wuhan Institute where COVID possibly (likely?) escaped.

This is a racist anti-Chinese conspiracy theory and in part the reason for the anti-asian hate pandemic in the USA. They did not fund gain of function research in Wuhan, and there was no gain of function research there [1].

[1]: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/11/04/fauci-says-rand-paul-egregio...

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by water554 on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:27AM (#31895935)
They totally did fund gain of function research and Fauci is weasel wording about that. He is a liar.

Creating mice with humanized lungs. Creating new viruses with spike protein to infect said lungs. Making virus more fit by passing through human lung mice. Not GOF huh?

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by shkkmo on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:18AM (#31895772)
> Their track record is flawless

There were clearly mistakes made. There were always going to be mistakes made in addressing a large scale disaster of a sort that we haven't faced in recent memory. Insisting that the response was flawless is idiotic, short sighted, and prevents from learning from those mistakes for the future.

The causes of the loss of trust in the US medical system are complicated and are due in part to all of: bad messaging from the CDC, reduction of personal relationships with doctors (especially in rural areas) and political opportunism.

Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by nathanasmith on Monday June 27, 2022 @01:56PM (#31898178)
Well played. This (and the preceding comments) is some high class bait. Congrats on hooking a few fish with it. FWIW though Hacker News isn't typically the best place for this kind of thing. >my karma now burns
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by QuizzicalCarbon on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:37AM (#31896065)
Covid-19 has not been stopped at all.
Re:Monkeypox outbreak in U.S. is bigger than the CDC reports... by ALittleLight on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:27AM (#31895928)
The public health authorities in the US have a "flawless" track record? Really? So I was imagining how they said masks weren't useful at the start of the pandemic and later admitted they lied to conserve mask supplies?

The US public health institutions made many, many, many terrible and substantive errors with COVID. It's hard to believe they are as bad as they are. Everything from not shutting down travel from infected regions at the start, blocking testing with "unapproved" tests that were superior to their own, denying the airborne nature of COVID, knowingly misrepresenting vaccine efficacy, housing infected COVID patients in elderly homes, giving vaccines to young people who didn't want it over old people who needed it, half-hearted lockdowns arbitrarily destroying some businesses while not slowing the virus - this is off the top of my head and I could go on.

Finally, I'm short on time but it's not even possible to construe as racist the uncontested fact that an unsafe Chinese lab working on coronavirus gain of function research is at the geographic center of a novel coronavirus outbreak.