Re:Facebook says Apple is too powerful – they're right
by verall on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @11:52AM
(#31825358)
Ah but Minecraft was sold and purchased outside of Steam when it was still a tiny indie game, long before it was popular. On an iphone it would not have been allowed. And steam provides services that are IMO great, which is why I keep using it for things that I can use it for. So it seems like Apple could keep up a similar margin and most of their customers, while still allowing the choice for users. It's still a massive improvement.
Re:Facebook says Apple is too powerful – they're right
by musicale on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @07:11PM
(#31830191)
> I feel like this situation would be similar with Facebook and Apple - if they manage to break Apple's monopoly, still nobody would use a 3rd party app store, save for people forced by giants like Facebook.
The Amazon app store exists for Android. And yet Google Play still commands high platform fees.
As you note, Facebook is probably big enough to force people to use their 3rd party app store (and thereby avoid Apple's privacy regulations, which interfere with Facebook's business model.)
Re:Facebook says Apple is too powerful – they're right
by enos_feedler on Tuesday June 21, 2022 @06:58PM
(#31830070)
Well I suppose this is a testament to the idea that 30% cut is warranted commission fee for marketing/distribution. Being that aggregator has a lot of value that you can extract from content creators.
Yet Steam takes the same 30% cut. So far others with money, like Epic have been unable to break Steam's stranglehold, even though they take a much lesser pay cut of the earnings.
Every dev ever who has posted about game sales says that non-Steam merchants are a rounding error in terms of revenue.
In practice, the PC being an open platform has only allowed giants like EA and Epic's Fortine to get around having to pay the 30% to Valve.
I feel like this situation would be similar with Facebook and Apple - if they manage to break Apple's monopoly, still nobody would use a 3rd party app store, save for people forced by giants like Facebook.