Every time it happens it hardens my opinion that a L1 should be like the foundation of a building - it should have one job (be hard money), it should be simply and elegantly designed, it shouldn't have any cracks (a.k.a misaligned incentive structures), it should evolve very slowly if at all, and it should be designed to be built on top of. L1 exists to anchor L1+N to the real world and that's it.
I don't think Bitcoin qualifies as such. Sure, projects like Ethereum are far more complex, but there are projects that significantly improve on Bitcoin in simplicity and elegance. Bitcoin script in particular is not that simple and full of warts.
I liken Bitcoin to e.g. the Model T or the first grey brick cellphones. It changes everything forever because it works very well, but also is quickly improved upon and thus eventually won't be that popular.
If so, no. I strongly predict Bitcoin, both the blockchain and the currency will nearly, if not fully, "die," as the Model T and grey phone have. Ethereum is already much better at it's core, and it's not hard to think even Ethereum will be improved upon.
In the long run, literally all bitcoin has is history and name recognition. Like the Model T, you will see it revered like something in a museum, and also just about nobody will actually use it.
What you and many others seem to overlook is first mover advantage, network effects and most important: trust. Bitcoin is not Yahoo or Facebook, it is not a company product which has to improve and break things all the time.
In the long run Bitcoin is a store of value. That requires trust, which takes time. To gain trust over time it has to move slow and steady because there can be no mistakes.
When it comes to money and trust it is almost impossible to get a second chance (see Terra UST). Just one mistake could result in everyone distrusting Bitcoin.
Your argument strikes me as very odd -- you seem to suggest that nothing can beat Bitcoin in theory, but Ethereum is already beating it in practice.
In theory everything is possible. I do not follow the beating really. They can both exist with different use cases.
Bitcoin wants to be digital gold (and money) and Ethereum wants to be a smart contract world computer running dapps. They solve different problems.
Now, I'm sure Bitcoin will enjoy name recognition for some time, but in my experience, always bet on the tech.
- Twitter uses lightning for its tipping mechanism
- The Podcasting 2.0 standard is all lightning based
- NCR is integrating lightning
- Blackhawk is integrating lightning
- Kraken has enabled lightning
- Robinhood is integrating lightning
- Square/block is investing heavily into lightning development and enablement
I'm probably missing some big ones...
The concept of layered system design, especially in money and technology, is not new.
Ethereum is an inherently flawed system.
The reason I know more about Ethereum than Layered Bitcoin stuff is that that is what more people (myself included) are actually using today to do cutting-edge stuff on.
Moreover, it's pretty easy to first-principle your way into why it's probably better; layered Bitcoin saddles you with a particular kind of technical debt -- you're literally trying to hack Bitcoin into something it wasn't intended for, and the Bitcoin code is of course mostly immutable. Ethereum, on the other hand,is built for it.
Sure, all software has problems, but a car built from the ground up is likely going to be better than a Model-T with addons.
(edit)
Bahaha, I checked out the guys book. He's a Bitcoin Maxi who apparently quotes -- Nassim Taleb aka the guy who thinks that BTC will go to zero. Not looking like a worthwhile thing.
Actual ideas:
Bitcoin is layer 1 of the internet of value. It only needs to be secure, decentralized, and stable. It has one job; enforce digital property rights while maintaining the above characteristics (Think the internet layer: IP)
Layer 2 (lightning, liquid, etc) build on top of the secure, decentralized, stable foundation of L1 Bitcoin and create standards/protocols for application/user comms (think the transportation layer: TCP, UDP)
Layer 3 (Strike, TBD, Sphinx, CashApp, etc) applications to fulfill specific use cases built on top of layer 2 (think the application layer: all the things you do on the internet)
Bitcoin is the only commodity on the planet who's supply is completely unaffected by demand.
An emission like 1 per second forever is much more immutable due to guaranteed miner incentives and lack of arbitrariness. And thus a better basis for hard money [2].
[1] https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2022...
[2] https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-su...
The "solution" of slapping something like LN on top of it is "let's completely forgo all of Bitcoin's guarantees and build something else; while still being hurt by Bitcoin's cripplingly slow speed when creating our network".
Also, the incentive structures being discussed are only meaningful as long as the miners believe that Bitcoin will keep increasing in value. If it looks like BTC is dying, they have every reason to try to squeeze the last few drops of value from it by running an attack on it and running away with what real money they can extract.
The "solution" of slapping something like banks on top of it is "let's completely forgo all of the Fed's guarantees and build something else; while still being hurt by Fedwire's cripplingly slow speed when creating our network".
Also, the incentive structures being discussed are only meaningful as long as the Banks believe that the Fed will keep increasing the money supply. If it looks like USD is dying, they have every reason to try to squeeze the last few drops of value from it by running an attack on it and running away with what real money they can extract.
ah, he doesn't understand at all how lightning works. He's just repeating sound bites.
While a channel is still open, transactions happening on the channel aren't in any way protected by Bitcoin's guarantees (they get LN's guarantees, which are different). And those are the only transactions that have any speed boost.
Contrary to popular belief, miners aren't choosing anything when it comes to BTC. They're rubber stamping the decisions of the BTC core developers, who are blessed by the exchanges such as Bitfinex, and they are collecting fees on that rubber stamp.
Why would the hash power decide what is called BTC? If Dogecoin some day attracts more hashing power than Bitcoin, then Bitfinex is supposed to assign the BTC ticker to Dogecoin?
Look up the debate between big blockers and small blockers if you're interested in learning more; a quick summary, many people wanted larger block size so bitcoin could process more transactions.
I believe several newer core developers staged a coup to prevent this from happening, despite several of the longer-term contributors being in favour of it. The original contributors (sans satoshi, who was mostly inactive at this point), had their access to the git repositories revoked.
This video goes into a bit more detail (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfcvX0P1b5g) but basically the people opposing a larger blocksize had financial incentives.. a lot were in bed with a company called Blockstream which benefits from their development on sidechains (now the lightning network). Had the block-size been increased, Bitcoin would be much more useful as a means of exchange (more transactions would be processed, and they would be cheaper).
This is where Bitcoin Cash is now, but it doesn't get the BTC ticker symbol because Bitfinex and other CEXes have a lot of influence as well.
Of course the flipside of this is that it would become very expensive to run a node. Bitcoin's blockchain is ~400 GB after 13 years. BCH has a 32x larger blocksize cap, so we can extrapolate that if anyone actually used that fork, it would grow a 12 TB blockchain over that same period. As a result running a node would become expensive and the network would become much less decentralized (the very thing people are complaining about in this thread!)
Simple fact of the matter is that the whole justification for the permanent 1mb limit was an outright indefensible lie, pushed on idiots, and supported by censorship. Nothing more, and nothing less.
Any mechanism which rubber stamps the above process as legitimate and collects a fee for doing so is corrupt, letalone over the objections of an enormous fragment of both customers and partners in the restaurant in question. Lack of objection or approval from those whom the change is in the interests of, or who are simply too ignorant to understand what is going on, don't change that.
That is effectively what happened with BTC.
The way that it was supposed to work would be that the hashpower would choose the canonical tip of the chain if there were two conflicting ideas about what the chain should actually be. BCH stuck to that ideal and through two contentious and many more peaceable forks proceeded according to it. BTC did not.
That's exactly what happened with BTC. And yet almost everybody calls it Bitcoin.
Satoshi said in 2009: "The existing Visa credit card network processes about 15 million Internet purchases per day worldwide. Bitcoin can already scale much larger than that with existing hardware for a fraction of the cost. It never really hits a scale ceiling. If you're interested, I can go over the ways it would cope with extreme size."
Some latecoming BTC core devs cancelled that plan, with zero justification, changed the consensus mechanism for the chain from hashpower to fiat declaration by fraudulent centralised exchange running a pump and dump scam with fake money, and sabotaged the entire project in the process into complete uselessness, and to this day we're stuck with people who believe a fundamental financial revolution is going to take place on a chain that was forced to 4tx/second and get very angry, confused or surprised when you point out that such a change is clear and obvious sabotage.
If you're claiming otherwise, then I'm done here and I wish you the best of luck.
Hashpower between chains is only relevant if they are compatible (same consensus rules), as the accumulated proof of work is used as an indicator of which chain should be followed. Once a chain hard forks to alter the consensus rules like Dogecoin, Bitcoin Cash, etc, there is no amount of additional hashpower that would make up for the incompatibility -- a node will simply ignore the invalid blocks.
https://saito.tech/the-double-spend-attack-is-not-the-same-a...
The entire point of crypto is to bypass the regulatory framework. In some cases that may make for a more robust system in some cases it may not.
This has happened before
For example: "The number of entities sufficient to disrupt a blockchain is relatively low: four for Bitcoin".
This probably refers to the 4 largest mining pools.
Yes, they could temporarily annoy some people by not processing their transactions. But it would come at a giant cost to them. They would be out of business quickly as miners can switch to a different pool in minutes.
That is like saying the US economy is brittle because if Walmart, Apple, Amazon and ExxonMobil would just send everybody home and set their premises on fire, there would be a problem.